Estoc Trials - Week 2 of Test Wars *UPDATED*

  • Thread starter Thread starter admin
  • Start date Start date
Guild hansels should be left the way they are, if you feel guild hansels has an advantage then try to be a gh and see what they go through to get eq. They rejected alot from big ebs and the only way they get accepted into top clans is through war. Be a gh and don't tell your friends or use your main to ask for to be let in then go eq hunting you have to beg to get accepted make promises of using mith, all pots and xtals to help out. Devs don't listen to peeps complaining about guild hansels they should make a guild hansel kingdom if they don't like it and see what other gh are going through in the game.
 
Alice is right. I'm not even a GH but I have the option to build my kingdom that way if I so choose as does EVERYONE ELSE. No one forced you not to be a GH.
Grab a straw and suck it up and move on.

The more changes they make the more people will complain there is something they don't like or is unfair even though they have the CHOICE to do the same.
 
What in the freak is going on.. I for once am against the GH changes *IF* its for the benefit if others and the GHs. I would recommend making other builds better rather than messing up us GHs
 
Why can't I cast WoC? :|
SC20130614-224809-1_zps36ee304c.jpg

Devs fix it quick please
 
@alice- I have so many things to say to your comment.
First, ATA is looking at changes with guild hansel in relation to ee wars. You are rambling about epics.
Second, the reason you aren't let into large clans is because they are T5 clans and you are a T3 build.
You do very little damage on the eb. That is why no one wants to let you in.
So buck up and pay the price to build a decent kingdom and stop playing victim that your 50 land gh that cost you the same price as ONE level 2 upgrade for the rest of us doesn't get to join clans that are out of your stat range.
3) the higher tiered equipment isn't even programmed in to drop for you! Because you are too small to hold that equip without gaining a large advantage over other accounts that are t3 range.

What I can tell is that the guild hansel is like the kid who plays house. You don't have a real house or a real mortgage. You can easily build your imaginary house with a few well placed cardboard boxes. If you want to play with the big kids, grow up and build some volaries. Or stables. Stables rock.
 
Re: Estoc Trials - Week 2 of Test Wars

LP022 said:
**Disclaimer for Kaw players: this post is not intended for people with short attention spans with a proclivity of posting TL;DR -target audience is for the devs and is extremely wordy. Read at your own risk**

Darling Devs. What. Are. You. Thinking? Lololol

I was finally getting some hope you were on the road to understanding your own game mechs and were thinking through the impact of your changes, but you are reinforcing the cliche of you can't teach an old dogs new tricks. Why you insist on trying to fix **** that isn't broke and then spin it like an "improvement" is beyond comprehensible to me. Do you really think that poorly about the intellect of your player base? I mean sure we have our noobs who don't know better and then the general handful of vocal intellectually stunted people, but really? Y'all are gonna try to pass off decreasing bfa effect WHILE widening the strength tolerance in matchmaking as an enhancement? What the hell is it enhancing? Who thought this crap up? They need to be put on idea probation for awhile, sit them in a corner and have them face the wall, it's more productive to bettering the game than this worthless "test" lol

*Taking a deep breath before going on, before extremely long winded logical beat down of said "test" items for this week*

To start, I am assuming from your post, since you did not specifically outline a certain player population in #2 of points contained in matching related change, that it will effect EVERYONE by the all encompassing pronoun of "your". I am also assuming since you also didn't give a vague disclaimer that I and many in the kaw community would hammer you on, such as "adjustments to bfa effect is dependent on actual bfa of the individual", that everyone's bfa will be effected equally. So first I want to know which monkey among the apes who slept through middle school math classes decided that to allow more players with large bfa differences to participate you needed to reduce the effect of everyone's bfa.

Now unless I'm missing something, in essence what you plan on doing to accomplish a lowering effect on bfa is to deflate it. Which means yes you will be removing some raw stats from the matching equation...but umm if you are deflating everyone's equally you are not diminishing the gap in strength of player to player. So if player 1 with 200m in bfa stats has his/her bfa cut in half and player 2 with 100m in bfa stats has his/her bfa cut in the same amount, the resulting difference is 100m vs 50m....guess what player 1 is STILL 2x stronger than player 2. What in frozen hell does that accomplish in terms of allowing bigger bfa players more of a chance to participate?

If I have read your analysis from matching each war correctly or rather analysis of no matches, y'all don't determine match-ability on bfa stats alone. You base it on multipliers...i.e. clan x your bfa was 4x higher than any opponent close to your stats. Now if you are equally decreasing everyone's bfa, that multiplier is not going to be changed, meaning the same clans with their big ole bfa players will still be too strong for anyone in terms of comparable strength. Hopefully a monkey who stayed awake during math class is reading this and can understand my point.

"But wait!" one lil monkey says while scratching his head, "there are two parts to this! We are allowing for 'VASTLY' larger bfa differences in our match ups!!!"

Well now allow me to retort! Monkeys. You already tried "vastly" larger bfa differences in match ups, that is what you have spent the last 3-4 months trying to fix  I have already explained that just b/c raw bfa stats are lowered that will not help to lower strength differentials between players as long as the change is equal across the board. So why are you even screwing with the effect of our bfa at all? You can accomplish the same failure you did at the beginning by not considering bfa appropriately in matches by just again widening that bfa tolerance in the matching algorithm again. To quote on of my favorite movies: "Sticking feathers up your butt wont make you a chicken", just like dressing up this widening of the bfa tolerance in the matching algorithm won't "create" more opportunity for players with large bfa to participate. It's a superficial "fix" to a problem that actually doesn't exist, and I'm calling y'all out on it. We are not that dumb, we can see through your rouse.

Now for the banana bonus round! Let me tell you darling devs what you have "won" through this epic miscalculation!

1. A fabulous trip back in time where players again complain that their opponents strength has created a statistically skewed match!

2. To keep you warm on those cold lonely nights on your fabulous trip back down feedback nightmare road, you have an excuse of "well we lowered the effectiveness of bfa so it should be fair for you" accompanied by an elephant in the room of "yes but we lowered yours too, so the effect of the "lowering" cancels out any productive effect we were trying to sell"

3. Most importantly you get a fancy 1st rate dining experience at "oops we didn't consider the effect of lowering bfa against normal build mechanics resulting in screwing over other aspects of game play!"

Oh you have not heard of #3? Well let me give you the tourist version until you arrive at your destination and experience it for yourself! Many Kaw players take into account the static stats their bfa provides when creating their builds. I.e. I have "x" in spy def bfa therefore in order to keep out "z" level of attk build spies and reduce # of attempts by "y" stat spies, I need "Q" # of towers.

By changing the impact of our bfa and not even giving us the amount it's gonna impact us doesn't even give us a chance to intelligently change builds to compensate for loss of static stats we count on to defend against normal build stats, bfa not even a consideration. Granted build changes for one weekend of tests won't spur a run on the bank phenomenon for build changes; however, should you choose to make this a permanent "enhancement" to EE wars, there will be.

I know y'all have watched the evolution of the tower trend, at the beginning of EE wars tower reqs to participate in wars were non-existent and only for those crazy osw clans. Now you will be hard pressed to find any clan that regularly does EE wars without at least a 1m tower req. If players are being turned away and denied participation b/c they don't meet minimum # of tower reqs now when they have their full bfa to supplement some static def from just regular build mechanics, what do u think will happen as those tower reqs increase to compensate for the cut in bfa effectiveness?

If you haven't caught on darling devs, players are still struggling to build and meet the current reqs, now you are going to incite clans to raise them more? It makes me wonder if you guys even want this system to succeed.

As anyone who has read any of my other posts know, I could go on and on and on about impact this seeming "small tweak" to a singular aspect of the game has. ill spare your eyes the strain and say without going into detail, reducing effectiveness of bfa potentially will negatively impact payout per hit meaning potentially lower mith payout due to plunder, give spies, who are typically "ally light", yet another advantage against now "ally lighter" attk builds, discourage importance of building allies to new players, take away the one aspect of the game that players new to EE wars had to fight competitively against experienced clans with EE equipment (i.e. instead of needing 200m in allies to match the eb vs EE item differential now they will need that PLUS whatever said decreasing factor equals), etc etc etc.

So darling devs, you have my attention again. I truly do not understand what you are trying to accomplish with this test, unless you believe bfa is skewing the results of Bfe analysis, which if that is the case...I suggest you come clean before you lose all credibility y'all have worked so hard to build over the past months. While i will be watching and waiting for my i told you so moment, I will NOT be assisting in this ********* "test" of something that you already tested and fixed and are now not only going back to after you already determined it had a negative impact on success of EE wars, but are making its negative effects more pronounced in other aspects of the war system dynamics and mechanics.


This the single greatest thing I've read on the forums in the year I've been here. And, as it seems, was largely overlooked because, as stated above, it contains more that 6 characters. Well done LP!! :lol:
 
What about a handicap system?

If Devs r so hell bent on trying ot make things somewhat equal

Count CS / BFE and BFA into the equation. Rank each Clan accordingly.

Clan A is 50% stronger than Clan B.

Matchup tolerance - lets say - 10%.

Give clan B 40% increase to meet the 10% tolerance.

I am sure there would be need to be more to this. Clan size etc etc. unless u do one size.

Random matching - adjust strength calculation of lower strength clan to be within the matchup tolerance.
 
As I'm hearing it smaller players pvp are making less and larger players making more depending on build make up of the two involved maybe ... Just wondering if anyone else noticed a difference in payouts
 
The new changes sound interesting, though i will never get to try these test wars because they are always on the weekends when i work. Would it be possible to have some sheduled for the weekdays? Greatly appreciated and thank you.
 
Back
Top