Not much of a debate:
For Removal of BFA in war : 2
For Keeping war mechanics the same : 11
For Accounting BFA in Matchup : 3
Flip-Flop say nothing of consequence : 1
So at best it's 11:5 for your suggestion.
As for the Pro/High School comparison, BFA is not the separation here, that is your Average Warrior Combined Stats.
BFA seperates the Pro teams that are more dedicated.
Consider building your BFA like Film study, proper scouting, drafting, free agent signing. It takes time, effort and dedication to make these choices. BFA just doesn't 'happen', so I say match clans based off Combined stats and let the chips fall where they may.
Considering BFA in matchups is a slippery slope with includes Equipment , bonuses, pots, towers, spy builds and experience.
Btw, your 'debate' started on page 31.
Also, if people would have used the system war in the first place, they wouldn't need a matchup system.
...and to station, my nub comments were not just towards you, but more to the movement.
...I would however support your no bfa movement if you non-bfa'ers forfeit your right to all of the equipment. So you can war fair, and I'm still not penalized for playing a complete game.