Devs...you're driving everyone crazy...yourselves, the kawmunnity, our wives, etc.
Seriously..I don't care what algorithm you come up with at this point...just come up with something and KEEP IT. I can't imagine you don't know what the major issues are after all the feedback you've received. So make the changes that have received the most negative feedback and make the changes. Plain and simple. I, for one, have always been a proponent of just adding up raw stats (ALL OF THEM), BFE, and BFA. This is the fairest way of measuring the true strength of everyone..therefore ensuring a decent matchup. Nobody can argue with that algorithm because it's fair. No nuance of nonsense dtw/dts...you're complicating this far more than you need to. Ever heard of the KISS principle...if not it means Keep It Simple Stupid.
One other thing you DEFINITELY need to do is incentivize more people to war. Don't be so darn stingy. It's fake gold and fake equipment anyway...why not have a 'treasure trove' for the winners with ridiculous amounts of gold and inferno/aqua/xstals/nobs. You want people to war...give them a reason...economics/psychology 101. In the end you will see your bottom line increase...don't be so concerned with that. Please your customers=more $$ for you.
You have over 8 months of feedback and there are some very common threads. If that's not enough data for you to come up with a reasonable scenario that INCENTIVIZES people to war, then it's a lost cause for you as developers. But please stop the nonsense and changes. Keep it simple: (1) add up raw stats, bfa, and bfe with a reasonable threshold for differences and (2) BE GENEROUS with war rewards.
Also, T6L2...what in the world were you thinking? There are far more subtle ways of accomplishing the objective it appears you were trying to accomplish. That is, narrow the gap between lb players and the rest of kaw.
If you can't do any of the logical things I and others have proposed then I can only assume you're trying to sabotage your own game...who knows maybe so people quit instead of you having to tell everyone you can't succeed as a viable business any longer.