-_-OPTIMAL-_-CHAOS-_-
Well-Known Member
Like this argument hasn't been done to death but.
Japan had zero intent of surrendering. Their leaders wanted all out victory or defeat.
Allies predicted losses in the millions due to civilians fighting to the death not just the armed forces of Japan.
The allied death toll would have been extreme as well.
Did the Japanese kill civilians prisoners of war? Yes. Repeatably.
Can you justify bombing Hiroshima and Nagasaki?
200,000 deaths versus millions lost in direct conflict.
The bombs were horrendous. Their use, a last desperate act to force a strong but suicidal enemy to surrender. It worked.
Yes it was deplorable that civilians were targeted. But it was an essential and in the grand scheme of things lesser of two evils.
And for an enemy to cry foul if a weapon used in war. Perhaps one would have felt more reluctant at the time had the enemy first declared war prior to an unexpected attack and the better treatment of prisoners of war.
But that's history. It is not relevant today.
As for how the world sees America. While the above criticism is accurate in many people's perceptions, when one of the most powerful nations on the world stands idle and watches others suffer they as a society fail.
They have failed before and yes they choose to be the worlds police ( not alone ).
Their allies may be weaker in their eyes but are allies nonetheless.
The largest issue in the world is that the three most powerful military mights in the world stand apart on beliefs and ideals.
Unless the heads of those nations talk and compromise nothing the realm of world security will change.
And the worst case scenario is that we have 2 members of the UN with new inexperienced leaders. We have one old guard with a little man complex and one strict authoritative figure too proud to back down.
People's pride and ignorance will result in tragedy.
Sins of the past and wars that people should have learnt and moved on from will define stances ( even if people on this thread ).
Our ancestors did not die so that we can repeat their mistakes.
Those responsible for ww2 are in their grave.
The world needs to grow up and move on. Or you may as well rush to war with your head shoved up your own ass
Japan had zero intent of surrendering. Their leaders wanted all out victory or defeat.
Allies predicted losses in the millions due to civilians fighting to the death not just the armed forces of Japan.
The allied death toll would have been extreme as well.
Did the Japanese kill civilians prisoners of war? Yes. Repeatably.
Can you justify bombing Hiroshima and Nagasaki?
200,000 deaths versus millions lost in direct conflict.
The bombs were horrendous. Their use, a last desperate act to force a strong but suicidal enemy to surrender. It worked.
Yes it was deplorable that civilians were targeted. But it was an essential and in the grand scheme of things lesser of two evils.
And for an enemy to cry foul if a weapon used in war. Perhaps one would have felt more reluctant at the time had the enemy first declared war prior to an unexpected attack and the better treatment of prisoners of war.
But that's history. It is not relevant today.
As for how the world sees America. While the above criticism is accurate in many people's perceptions, when one of the most powerful nations on the world stands idle and watches others suffer they as a society fail.
They have failed before and yes they choose to be the worlds police ( not alone ).
Their allies may be weaker in their eyes but are allies nonetheless.
The largest issue in the world is that the three most powerful military mights in the world stand apart on beliefs and ideals.
Unless the heads of those nations talk and compromise nothing the realm of world security will change.
And the worst case scenario is that we have 2 members of the UN with new inexperienced leaders. We have one old guard with a little man complex and one strict authoritative figure too proud to back down.
People's pride and ignorance will result in tragedy.
Sins of the past and wars that people should have learnt and moved on from will define stances ( even if people on this thread ).
Our ancestors did not die so that we can repeat their mistakes.
Those responsible for ww2 are in their grave.
The world needs to grow up and move on. Or you may as well rush to war with your head shoved up your own ass