The_Big_Bang_Theory
Well-Known Member
__Individually_Idiosyncratic__ said:OP, it's commendable that in your opening remarks you recognise that the Executive Order is not in fact a ban on Muslims entering the United States; yet you then persist in labelling it a "Muslim" ban without the use of quotations to denote the label as inaccurate. This is intellectually dishonest, but consistent with the defensive reaction of Islamic interest group that re-frame the narrative of events to present Islam itself as the victim.
I see it as a Muslim ban. Many Americans see it as a Muslim ban. Feel free to call it whatever you want. Islam is the victim here. We're not at war with Islam. We're at war with people trying to use a religion as a justification for barbaric acts.
__Individually_Idiosyncratic__ said:The Executive Order itself only targets a small number of countries that are closely linked to violent Jihad-ism;
So why aren't Saudi Arabia, Pakistan or Afghanistan on the list? How does only banning citizens from these countries make us safer?
__Individually_Idiosyncratic__ said:In your zeal to be "right-on" as a SJW your over-reaction is directly responsible for inciting hatred and Anglophobia.
Actually, my zeal is to defend things this country is supposed to stand for like freedom, liberty, due process, rule of law, etc. If that makes me a "SJW" I'll wear the badge proudly. And spare me the "I'm directly responsible" routine. I don't buy it when a criminal tries to use it ..."If you don't agree to my demands you are responsible for these deaths of these people"... I'm not buying it from you. I didn't sign the order. Trump did. If you get hated on, talk to him about it.
__Individually_Idiosyncratic__ said:As for the merits of the Executive Order itself, well I've been reading that it was in fact Obama who created the list that you refer to, and I also read that Israel has a travel ban on citizens from 16 countries.
Obama restricted VISA waivers from those countries. He didn't bar immigration and visitors from them. Don't blame this on Obama. As for what Israel does, I'm not a citizen of Israel. I'm an American.
