This OP has effort

Yeah clumsy. That's why I brought his name up in particular. But it doesn't matter that other mods don't do it as much because they don't get the chance as he immediately does it
 
It's like it's be become a knee jerk reaction. One line = lock. Consider the thread first. Saying its a lack of effort can be rude on some threads if the person who posted it thought one or two lines would suffice. Nowhere does it require there to be a wall of colorful text and pretty pictures.
 
IA-CrazyRuggy said:
It's like it's be become a knee jerk reaction. One line = lock. Consider the thread first. Saying its a lack of effort can be rude on some threads if the person who posted it thought one or two lines would suffice. Nowhere does it require there to be a wall of colorful text and pretty pictures.

It just requires a bit of insight to evaluate whether a thread has potential or not
 
TheRealDMC said:
BuTtNaKeD_-MaGiC-_TwlnKy said:
I also agree with DMC.

:D So do I! Was surprised to find my name here. Alas I did!

Also I agree Tom, too many good potential threads locked under the catch all. So yes, even though I haven't spoken I do agree with Twlnky who agrees with me through precognition.
Freaky...
I really thought i was responding to a post you made.
 
CHUBBY__CHASER said:
How else do you measure osw experience? Near bc spy build with less than 12.5 k steals? That's an hte build sorry


Honestly the only way to evaluate someone's "OSW" effort is to view & evaluate their entire battle stats ...ie: fight, steal, scout, offenses & defenses (won/lost) ..all of it. How else can you tell how effective or how much effort someone puts into OSW/PvP? ..how much of it is from ebs and actually from OSW/PvP?
 
CHUBBY__CHASER said:
You don't say? Really? wondering why steal achievements matter? hmmmmm maybe strips?

Steals from strips don't determine OSW prowess ...OSW is a battle of the mind. It's a psychological battle. The best OSW/PvPers make you ask for CF with the least amount of hits possible. The actual amount of inc is meaningless, UNTIL they develop some sort of OSW scoreboard (which I've asked for repeatedly). As of now the best OSWers win with their chat button lol
 
Think of it this way. Later in its life, a thread's OP will only make up something like 15% of the thread's discussion at most, the rest will be from content that is posted in the thread somewhere else. A thread should not be measured immediately by how good an OP is, although a good thread is usually started by having a good starting post, but how entertaining the thread is, and to see that, the thread needs to be alive for a little time.

We shouldn't be locking threads immediately (unless they are the 1 line question threads and their purpose have been fulfilled), but wait until they have time to get responded to by the community. If the community likes it, even though it's not that great of a starting post, it shouldn't be locked; however, if the community dislikes it, the thread will die on its own, but, if the thread is only being kept in the AT because of hateful or nonsensical comments, then it should be locked.
 
Tom_Burger_Pie said:
Moose said:
The main thing in my opinion is "community enjoyment". If I come across a low effort thread and the community is happily posting away on it and enjoying them selves, then I see no real reason to throw a lock on it.

If the low effort thread isn't generating good discussion, however, it needs to slide off the AT board to make room for Better threads

Exactly my point. When eagle immediately locks for lack of effort, he doesn't allow the opportunity for the thread to create enjoyment. It's not just the OP that creates enjoyment on a thread, it's the people that post on it and the content of those posts

Eagle takes pictures of himself wearing bras. Anyone remember that? 
 
Pretty good. To be honest I'm only really on kaw for a few days every couple of months in spells.

At uni and absolutely exhausted.

You?
 
Back
Top