Yes, I've not been on or posted for a while, so why should my opinion be of any interest or consequence? Well because despite not being on much and posting much, I still care about how the forums and how they are managed.
Having had another decent period of not posting, I have been able to get a large scale and fair view of the forums, looking in from a distance. And what I have noticed is that a particular issue still exists. I have pointed it out before but to no avail so I shall try again from a different angle.
The issue that I have once again noticed is the locking of many threads with the reasons cited as "lack of effort". This is mainly done by Eagle.
Now, to many people that may seem acceptable. After all, who wants low effort threads on the AT? But what if I told you that it is not mentioned in the ToS or RoC at any point that a thread must have a certain amount of "effort" put in to it. So why should they be locked if they aren't breaking any rules? Well, I guess that the answer is if the threads are detrimental to the forums or forum community.
But if we start enforcing this 'effort requirement' how do we set the boundaries? For starters, what must a thread contain in order to be considered to have sufficient effort?
Here's a conundrum. If we decide that there must be a minimum amount of words of text, then do we lock Dilly's Question thread? It is 5 words long so obviously hasn't had much effort put in to it.
This leads me on to my next point:
Threads can have potential to form in to reasonable discussions that can ultimately be beneficial to the forum community. Yes, I understand that Dilly's thread is a cliché example, but ask yourself, what would have happened if he had posted that thread in today's era? It would have been locked as soon as it was read. And the 1000s of people that it has helped wouldn't have benefited from it at all.
My point is that not all short threads are destined to fail. I think we need to evaluate what's going on here and have a frank discussion about whether we should simply let some threads run before locking them. If a decent discussion comes from them then great! If one doesn't then lock it, but when it is locked immediately you will never know.
Please note that this by no means an attack on Eagle as a person or otherwise. Simply his tendency to lock for lack of effort. He has been a friend of mine for many years and hope he will read this and ponder.
I encourage you all to agree and disagree with me so that we can get a proper discussion going about this.
WBP ️
Having had another decent period of not posting, I have been able to get a large scale and fair view of the forums, looking in from a distance. And what I have noticed is that a particular issue still exists. I have pointed it out before but to no avail so I shall try again from a different angle.
The issue that I have once again noticed is the locking of many threads with the reasons cited as "lack of effort". This is mainly done by Eagle.
Now, to many people that may seem acceptable. After all, who wants low effort threads on the AT? But what if I told you that it is not mentioned in the ToS or RoC at any point that a thread must have a certain amount of "effort" put in to it. So why should they be locked if they aren't breaking any rules? Well, I guess that the answer is if the threads are detrimental to the forums or forum community.
But if we start enforcing this 'effort requirement' how do we set the boundaries? For starters, what must a thread contain in order to be considered to have sufficient effort?
Here's a conundrum. If we decide that there must be a minimum amount of words of text, then do we lock Dilly's Question thread? It is 5 words long so obviously hasn't had much effort put in to it.
This leads me on to my next point:
Threads can have potential to form in to reasonable discussions that can ultimately be beneficial to the forum community. Yes, I understand that Dilly's thread is a cliché example, but ask yourself, what would have happened if he had posted that thread in today's era? It would have been locked as soon as it was read. And the 1000s of people that it has helped wouldn't have benefited from it at all.
My point is that not all short threads are destined to fail. I think we need to evaluate what's going on here and have a frank discussion about whether we should simply let some threads run before locking them. If a decent discussion comes from them then great! If one doesn't then lock it, but when it is locked immediately you will never know.
Please note that this by no means an attack on Eagle as a person or otherwise. Simply his tendency to lock for lack of effort. He has been a friend of mine for many years and hope he will read this and ponder.
I encourage you all to agree and disagree with me so that we can get a proper discussion going about this.
WBP ️