ESTOC TRIALS SEASON 2: PRE-SEASON, Week 0 - War 1 *UPDATE*

  • Thread starter Thread starter admin
  • Start date Start date
I don't think you all understand my point here. I have no allegiance to DS whatsoever. Like I stated, it was a closer match than the CS alone suggested. But however slight it was, this match is slightly above the match threshold in my book. A line needs to be drawn and I would like future matches to be drawn on the other side of this. If there was a hard CS differential cut off, then GH/LB clans would never face top 50 strength clans due to CS differential. It's just a solution looked at in a different way.
 
If you fight with a big LB u will get hard matches some. Btw some of that cs difference was b/c intentional small alts. You can't count a gh as a 10m cs difference. And still how can u complain on a 55-52b war??? If you complain about that then you have absolutely no forum credibility. Crying in forums about a matchup you almost won just makes you look bad. You should have learned something from that war that will make u better. If you didnt you will be back complaining again every other day. Life isn't fair. KaW is even less fair. Stop warring gh's and small alts. Decide if a big LB is going to skew your matches up too much. But quit complaining. Ill take a bfe advantage any day over a cs one btw.
 
You know what I find???

Everyone that cries and complains about fair matches are the losers.... Point simple...

I have warred plenty all preseason last year, all of season 1, trials this summer, and now ready for season 2. That being the case I have lost plenty and yet I'm not in here whining about match ups. Why you ask? What goes around comes around...

If I get a bad match and win I feel better for overcoming the obstacle. If I lose I say to myself what did they do that was so awesome?

It was an even match. They were ahead at times as were we. They fought their hearts out and were ahead, up until about 10-5 minutes before end. At the end of the day it boiled down to strategy.
 
ST4T1ON_H1N3Y said:
Stary u have to multiply spy cs by 1.5 to calculate ur real cs advantage disadvantage

A Hlbc spy is worth the same as a Hlbc Att build the way the devs see it that's t5 complete a 6 mill or 1.5 x size difference in stats but not size

U had spy advantage of 25 mill which really equates to 33.5 mil they had u on Att def by 138 mill Att stats ... That's a 104.5 mill stat advantage give or take

U also had a huge lb player I'm sure bfa advantage was u but atleast that much

That match was as close to fair as it gets in this system u just got beat ... I can do math too

Really? You can do math? So 51,346,320 - 37,774,180 = 25mil ? Lol

And how are you sure about the bfa advantage? Have you counted the total BFAs of both rosters? I'm sure you didn't because I did and I can tell you are wrong! One lber can't beat 7 to 8 close to ally 200 lbers. Do you think we had bfa advantages over a roster with more than 94 trils in total BFAs? Other than top 20 ally lbers, I doubt if other ally lbers have such big bfa.
 
CzarCastic said:
The problem is we have forty clans warring now. Why?

1) The devs suggested that losers get an EE. Forum response forget the losers they deserve nothing.
2) The devs tried to be fair about the equipment distribution. Forum response, forget the losers they deserve the minimum. Devs changed season 2 to exactly that.
3) Forum request, we want less no matches. No matches went to almost nil.
4) Forum request, we want matches to be within some small % of CS, and at the same time X% of BFA/BFE. Statistically improbable with only 40 clans warring.

If we want to fix the matchups, we need to get more clans warring again. The simple solution is to make it better to war, than to hit eb’s. This means giving people that war an advantage over those that do not.

No I do not believe that everyone deserves a trophy at the end of a season.

I do wonder what the next season of FIFA, NBA, or NFL, would look like if only the teams that made the last year’s playoffs received magic shoes making them 10% faster?

Nice post with thoughtful advice. The root cause for the mismatches is the lack of participation. A lot of ppl have pointed it out and provided ideas on how to improve it. Unfortunately devs won't listen as always.
 
IlI________KING-WSP________III said:
For those people throwing out numbers on why DS and Risk match was fair, consider this: even with station hiney's 1.5 adjustment the CS disparity was over 100 mil. Now let's just say that DS's members all had 100 mil advantage in bfe (highly unlikely but possible against a clan with all EB equips) that still leaves u at around anywhere between 30-40 Tril in allies more than risk that DS needed to have to make it an even match. One big lb may bridge that gap but what about the rest of the clan? Can't only look at one player. Looking at the rosters it seems to me like the two clans bfa was probably pretty similar. Any way you look at this, this was probably a bad match. Score doesn't tell it all. The allowable window should not be this big IMO. Tighten up the window and let the clans adjust to find theirselves a match.

Finally someone who really knows what's going on instead of blindly throwing out their conclusions without any investigation or back up from the facts.

Totally agree with you. The allowable window is too big to overcome. This is not only happening to DS, but also many other clans. I've seen enough mismatches recently and it's funny that ppl try to defend the current matchup system coz they can benefit from it.
 
ST4T1ON_H1N3Y said:
How close u think the matches can get?
And yes DS bfe way is larger then risk ?
Matches will never be perfect but that was about a close as one as ur going to get ...

It was a pretty fair fight u want to use lb and gh ur going to get some bigger cs differences that's the price ur going to pay ur got two types of builds that can't be touched for profit

Rh does this to the extreme and are always out matched cs wise .... U see them in forums?

Again, the same questions, how do you know "yes DS bfe way is larger then risk"? Have you counted the total bfe of both rosters? If yes, mind providing your numbers? Numbers won't lie, will they?

And how do you know "u want to use lb and gh ur going to get some bigger cs differences"? Did devs tell you?

You don't have lbs or ghs in your clan?
 
ST4T1ON_H1N3Y said:
Now I do agree if window was closer clans would adjust but devs screwed themselves on that one by bringing out t6 and not leaving enough time for kaw to settle into it thereby making their system more accurate but under current system and all things the way they are that was as good a match a u will get ... A disadvantage to DS maybe but not by that much and remember risk isn't a noob clan they have 3 seasoned clans in there working together

I agree with you. It's true. The release of T6 screwed a lot of small clans who can't afford such a big amt of money to upgrade to a big build with monster stats. DS is pretty young with a lot of players playing only for a few months. There is no way they can grow from a gh to a 15mil atk build in just a few weeks.

So you do know risk is a seasoned war clan. I have no doubt with that. I repsect them for their warring skills and strategy. But then how could you conclude they didn't have good bfe? Isn't it a bit contradictory that a seasoned war clan only has eb equipments?
 
I'm not defending it by any means the match up system is total garbage .... But it's wat we have to work with devs aren't changing it now u need to figure it out for yourself and adapt to it or u will find ur self in wat seems like really bad matches all the time ...

But u using lb and gh is wat caused ur match up and the difference between 67 lb and ur other lb player and lb 300 allie lb is the same difference between top 10 and 50 it's huge

I've fought risk recently and know some of the players there I know wat their bfa looks like and Urs I keep notes on every player I come across in ee period it's my thing ... Allies showing is just that allies showing ask ur guys how many they have and total bfa and figure out the bfa needed to counter that ill bet anything it's a heck of a lot plus the difference in bfe

I'm not saying u weren't at disadvantage I'm saying u think u were at huge disadvantage and u weren't not that bad compared to others or even compared to clans u cleaned clocks on

The current system is crap but don't try to abuse it by using lb and gh together then cry foul when it backfires in ur face and u face a more well rounded even clan u can't hit as well
 
IlI________KING-WSP________III said:
What people fail to realize is that plunder alone is not a good determinant of overall match. I stated my opinion on the CS/BFA/BFE window and I stand by the fact that it was uneven. Yes it may have been seen as fair, but looking at raw numbers (CS, BFA, BFE) DS did what they did to keep it close but in no way was it a fair match. @ Devs who look only at plunder score to assess matches - maybe one side didn't have to xstal? Keeping the score closer than it really was? Not saying RISk had xstals to sit on... But i bet there were Some of them full at the end... And in no way am I disrespecting RISk. They have some great people there. Main point was that window of allowable match may have gone too wide to allow for this type of match... Was it closer than what the CS suggested? Yes, but not to the extent as to call this a fair fight

Very well said. That's also the reason why some clans including us will boycott the wars with uneven matches - not to provide the devs the delusion that the match was fair just by looking at the "close" plunder score. And I'm pretty sure that if our roster was given to the other clans, the plunder gap would be much bigger than that.
 
I do have lb players in clan but we don't mix them with gh to try to skirt the match up system

And yeah I know ur bfe and theirs not totals for exactly who was in but I faced both ur clans recently and as I said I have notes risk bfe is below average for the most part and DS above look at the rosters
 
ST4T1ON_H1N3Y said:
King I'd really like to agree with u .. But for all the reasons stated that was a good match ...

Now onto real issues that still need to be dealt with ... Ur match last nite for 1

Lb may not be accounted for correctly in ee and gh diffidently are still an issue ... Ur match proves it best

U guys are a really good ee clan I've fought u twice personally lately and can attest to it

But u can't beat a broken mechanic and gh are a broken mechanic

DS didn't get to use that mechanic cause they faced a clan with ADT gh couldn't plunder on and is the only option left to us players since devs have ignored us about the issues since before season 1 even started

If gh was fixed I think lb players would be matched better since u couldn't try to drop overall clan average that way and clans would have to adjust and to facing other clans their own size ...

Just saying dont harp on none issues if u don't want the devs even more confused 1 clear message is wats needed or else we as players are just spinning our wheels

Lol You must not have seen us requesting for fixing the gh exploit. So having 2 or 3 ghs in the roster is exploiting the system? Small players are deprived of rights to war coz they are ghs? You must not understand the difference between gh exploit and having ghs in the roster.

If we really wanted to exploit the system, our roster would be totally different.

Anyone who really understands the wars will know what I mean. We always war with what we have. You can ask any of our members to see if we particularly select the ppl for the roster. We'd rather compete in the skill and strategy level instead of manipulating with the roster. That's why we request for a fair match. A mismatch only destroyed our fun of competing not under the same ground. We don't mind fighting a stronger clan as long as the mismatch is not too big.
 
I'm not saying its an exploit I'm saying its an attempt to draw an easier match

The way the new system is set up ur war roster has to be all in the same dtw/dts window or close to it to draw even matches with out anomalies such as wat happened in ur match or wat happens with rh ... Problem is the system doesn't take those anomalies into account and still try's to match u with overall strength

If u do it with just a couple gh and lb players u most of the time get a favorable match as the other clan will be smaller but sometimes u get screwed chaos reborn is another great clan but they use the same kinda roster alot .. Wether it's on purpose or not top 37 Allie lb balanced with a couple really smalls gets a favorable match most of the time

The other extreme which I do feel is an exploit is rh 15-20 gh a few lb and only a couple mid range players matching medium to medium large clans with no hope to plunder on them
But that's another issue altogether
 
ER-Rudementary said:
If you fight with a big LB u will get hard matches some. Btw some of that cs difference was b/c intentional small alts. You can't count a gh as a 10m cs difference. And still how can u complain on a 55-52b war??? If you complain about that then you have absolutely no forum credibility. Crying in forums about a matchup you almost won just makes you look bad. You should have learned something from that war that will make u better. If you didnt you will be back complaining again every other day. Life isn't fair. KaW is even less fair. Stop warring gh's and small alts. Decide if a big LB is going to skew your matches up too much. But quit complaining. Ill take a bfe advantage any day over a cs one btw.

"intentional small alts"? Lol How funny. I didn't know that our members were actually some alts intentionally made by someone. Or was that someone actually you so you can be so sure?

"You can't count a gh as a 10m cs difference." Yes we had two ghs in the roster. So that shouldn't be counted as a 10mil cs difference and instead they should be counted as 110mil??

"And still how can u complain on a 55-52b war???" Lol how ignorant one could be just telling the fairness of a matchup from the plunder score, especially from a leader of an experienced war clan. Now I really can't blame devs for sharing the same thoughts.

"If you complain about that then you have absolutely no forum credibility." Well my forum credibility is not up to you to judge. I speak by the truth, back up by my investigation and stats collected. Numbers don't lie. I don't accuse other clan's small members as intentional alts. Just from this, it's obvious who has the better forum credibility.

Sorry to disappoint you but I won't stop complaining or "crying" in your word if that's what you meant. Not just for ourselves, but also for many other clans who have experienced the same as us. Ofc we learn everything good from other clans. Every clan has their own strength and learning is the way to make us better. You don't have to worry about us. Why would I care what others think about me? I only do what I think is right.

But matchup is a totally different thing. Sending feedbacks doesn't mean we stop learning and giving no feedbacks doesn't mean your improving otherwise. Unfair matchups still need to be pointed out and pushed till they are fixed.

"Stop warring gh's and small alts." Sorry I have no right to tell our small members to stop warring unless some are your alts. Then let me know who they are so we can stop them from "screwing" our matchups.

"Ill take a bfe advantage any day over a cs one btw" Well I'd like to take the other way around otherwise. It's annoying to be punished by something you fought hard to earn. I'd rather devs tell us what bfes to use to get a fair matchup and then we go with it. We don't fancy taking advantage of anyone else, either.
 
It's real simple the way the system is designed for the best match ups to happen size differences in ur war roster and the other need to be close to the same top to bottom that means bigs fight together mediums fight together and smalls fight together in their own size clans ... Then the system works close to properly

I don't like it any more then u .... i hate this match up system but its now wat we are stuck with if u want more even matches its wat u have to do and hope everyone else does too

Mixing them together gets u the uneven results that u see doesn't mean it's not fair u fielded it just means its uneven and can yield the inconsistent results
 
ST4T1ON_H1N3Y said:
It's real simple the way the system is designed for the best match ups to happen size differences in ur war roster and the other need to be close to the same top to bottom that means bigs fight together mediums fight together and smalls fight together in their own size clans ... Then the system works close to properly

I don't like it any more then u .... i hate this match up system but its now wat we are stuck with if u want more even matches its wat u have to do and hope everyone else does too

Mixing them together gets u the uneven results that u see doesn't mean it's not fair u fielded it just means its uneven and can yield the inconsistent results

Well your advice only solves the problem for your own mismatch or better provide you favorable matchups but the system is still flawed. The problem is not fixed. A favorable matchup to you would be an unfair match to your oppo. That's what we don't want to see either.

We feel bad if we outmatch our oppo too coz we are depriving their rights of competing under the same base. In fact, we like challenges and don't mind facing clans stronger than us within a tolerable range. If we just wanted easy or favorable matchups, I wouldn't spend time sending feedbacks here to devs instead of tweaking our roster silently to make other clans victims of the unfair matchups.

I'm using the stats of our war as an example to show devs what the bottomline should be. If we can't overcome it, how many clans can say for sure they can?
 
If they don't fix the gh issue with it doesn't look like they will u will see a few clans running 5-10 of them with lb players trying to match down I already know a few doing it
 
ER-Rudementary said:
If you fight with a big LB u will get hard matches some. Btw some of that cs difference was b/c intentional small alts. You can't count a gh as a 10m cs difference. And still how can u complain on a 55-52b war??? If you complain about that then you have absolutely no forum credibility. Crying in forums about a matchup you almost won just makes you look bad. You should have learned something from that war that will make u better. If you didnt you will be back complaining again every other day. Life isn't fair. KaW is even less fair. Stop warring gh's and small alts. Decide if a big LB is going to skew your matches up too much. But quit complaining. Ill take a bfe advantage any day over a cs one btw.

By farming me can justify what you've done? Lmao!

You just proved how weak you are, from inside to outside. And you lost my last respect for you.

Pathetic.
 
starry_night said:
Very well said. That's also the reason why some clans including us will boycott the wars with uneven matches - not to provide the devs the delusion that the match was fair just by looking at the "close" plunder score. And I'm pretty sure that if our roster was given to the other clans, the plunder gap would be much bigger than that.

Will boycott? Looking at your history it seems you boycotted a fair bit of matches for quite some time. Oh how I wish you would match up against Bg so you can boycott togheter so we can finaly see how a draw looks like.......ye right, that would happen :D

starry_night said:
I agree with you. It's true. The release of T6 screwed a lot of small clans who can't afford such a big amt of money to upgrade to a big build with monster stats. DS is pretty young with a lot of players playing only for a few months. There is no way they can grow from a gh to a 15mil atk build in just a few weeks.

Sooooo.......there is gh's and there are 15 mill cs. Nothing in between those two? Where do you find the building that gives you 14 mill cs? I want one too! Or two!
I loled, ofc you have gh's by choice....and a good bunch of them has problaby the funds to reach those 15 mill cs at any time, but you choose not to. Simple as that.


On another note I see you have stripped yourself of eq this fine evening. That tells me two things. First is that it's prefectly ok to complain on a flawed system but on the other hand corrupt and use it to your benefits. Oh those double standards, I love it!
There other thing it tells me is that your bfa is far better then you claim it to be since you obviosly feel that you don't need equipment to successfully hit.


I had such respect for DS last season, now you have made it all go away starry. Shame.
 
Back
Top