Dev's this is wrong. Please change this matchup proceedure. (and dump the useless dtw/dts code while you are at it.)
"To answer all war matchup questions, this is how it works: "
Step 1
We count the number of people who cast the spell, if your clan is below or above the restriction, you are removed. If it is an odd number of clans that signed up, we remove the last member to sign up from the matchup.
**Wrong, matchup's are more important than t a r d i n e s s. With less than 40 or 50 clans warring, you need all the clans available to make a potential match. Put them all in the matchup pot and let the one that does not match be the odd man out. Only if there is the last matchup and you have 3 possible matches, would you use the last one signed up does not get matched up.
Step 2 **Step 3
We look at your hit ratio. We make sure you that enough members from each clan can attack each other and not see without seeing the message 'You are too strong to attack' or 'You are too weak to attack'. We call this the hit ratio.
**THIS should be step 3 if used at all. Personally, I think this is flawed thinking. Keep it simple. If you overthink a problem, you make the so called solution more complex. Listen to your customers. This is not working. Go back to the drawing board and ask yourself, what problem are you trying to solve, because this option is not working. Your paying long time lb players will need to fit into a clan that makes sense for the war. Don't try to negate or hide their strength with dtw/dts, it does not work for what you are trying to achieve. Your goal is to try and match up clans with somewhat equal strength for a war. Ignoring lb strength with this "hit ratio" crap is like having the alcoholic say he does not have a drinking problem... Ignoring it will not make it go away, only make it worse and piss off what customer you still have left.
Step 3 ** Step 2
We add a clan's combined stats, BFA and BFE and match each clan based on these stats. If the difference is too large there is no match. If a player cannot hit anyone from the other team, we do not measure them in this step.
** This should be the key to your matching strategy. With BFE added in to season 1's matching, you should be pretty close. This will not meet everyones wants, but it will be the best chance to match a majority of clans together for a good war.
Note: We know there were some issues with the lower clans not finding a match up. This seems to happen because the differences in hit ratios and clan strength varies greatly between them. Unfortunately, none of the combinations between the lower clans created a matchup within the restrictions we have put in place.
We are still adjusting our matchmaking algorithm and appreciate your patience and understanding.
** our patience is wearing thin now and our understanding is more like puzzlement. Please fix the gh exploit with the suggestion I made earlier and go back to season 1's matching with BFE included.
**The KaW community as a whole has given you plenty of feedback, the least you could do is respond to us in the forums. If you ignore your customers, your customers will leave. Please let me know how that business model works out for you.
As before, please send 100 xtals to this account for fixing your coding. Thanks.