After doing quite a few EE wars, the main problem that keeps recurring is the bad matchups. There are 2 main problems that need fixing.
1. No match/ strength difference.
This weekend we saw that the current 'hit ratio' algorithm produced the following matchups.
War 4:
Clan A: Ally LB 51 and 130 plus 27 non LB.
vs
NWoCB: Ally LB 10, 15, 26, 41, 43, 52, 79, 101, 147 and 156 plus 19 non LB.
I'm not even gonna estimate the difference in BFA here but it must be huge.
Week 12 war 5:
BG: 29 people, Ally LB 87, 97 and 190
vs
Silver: 26 people and zero Ally LB
There is simply no scenario where these can be considered fair matchups. This means there is (still) something seriously wrong with this matchup system.
Solution:
- Hit ratio needs to be secondary at best to strength comparison.
- The 'no match' needs to be tightened and BFA needs to weigh in a lot heavier when comparing the strength of two clans. A clan with 8 more LB should get a 'no match', a clan with 3 more people and 3 more LB more should get a 'no match'. This means your system does not function.
- If you really wanna stick to the hit ratio, then get the kingdoms' strengths much closer together by significantly reducing the BFA influence. Make it 0.02% instead of 0.2% just for EE wars; same for BFE.
2. Participation
More participation means better matches. Due to the current matchup system, clans decide to skip wars or even boycot the wars, meaning less participation (full respect for these boycots btw). Fixing the matchup system will bring these clans back to war. Participation needs to improve a lot more tho. Warring should be rewarded more than eb-ing. At the moment however, that is very questionable.
In a losing war scenario: The war takes 2 hours plus 1 hour activity lockdown. Only 29 people can participate. If a clan loses, the VP eb takes about 1.5 hrs since everyone will be empty going into the VP. If we say the war plunder and the VP eb make up for mith and pots lost during war, then that balances out.
In those 4.5 hours of warring, prepping and VP-ing, my clan could have made about 520B doing TFC. Plus of course the 58 xstals this war will have cost us.
IF we win, we get a lvl EE and mith. That still means 3 hrs of no eb for clan so 350B potential plunder loss. EE is easily lost again and mith won't build me any T6 lvl 2. So from a clan's perspective, participating in EE is probably not even the best option. Which is plain stupid in a game called kingdoms at WAR; just doing EE wars should be a LOT more rewarding than eb-ing.
Solution: Start by really rewarding participation and reducing cost of warring.
For the 29 warring clannies:
-Make wars payout a lot more gold, and add aqua and inferno for both sides.
- The winners get more of all that, a lvl EE and of course mith and Rancor (and maybe 1 xstal in a 2 hour war).
- The losers don't get EE or mith but also they don't lose EE. Every level won just expires after 1 week.
To help the 71 non warring clannies:
- Drop the VP eb and just give the losers 14 mith so we can start an eb for all. Or allow everyone to hit the VP eb for gold; mith only for the warriors.
- Let us run ebs until 15 minute before the actual war start. Then lock all activity and just give all warriors full troops so everyone is full going in.
- Let us start an eb even if there is only 1 minute to go until activity lock. We don't mind failing as much as we mind pointless waiting.
Thanks for reading.
༺ཇེ།པྱིཧརྀཔཀཻ༻