YAFI-this_is_another_bomb
Member
A large issue many of you are overlooking is that turtling was forced upon the parties of the Summer War Tournament due to the Auto-Join feature. Many of you are basing your ideas off of this. Auto-join FORCES turtle wars. It's that simple. I'm not sure how or why many of you can't understand that.
Prior to the tournament, system wars have been dead for quite sometime. Pretty much since KaW changed the reward system of them and then put Mitrhil for sale in exchange for gold. So between that change and the Summer War Tournament, their have been very little, to no wars going on meaning you would have to go back to the days prior of the reward system being changed to find what exactly killed off system wars. I've said it a few times already, the change in reward for system wars it was killed it. KaW was full of system wars prior to this change, and rarely where any of them turtle wars.
@Rooneycam,
I'm extremely sadden to see this is you alt, meaning your main is probably even bigger and you think fighting from pin in a system war is the best strategy. Sorry mate, but that's not a FACT at all. There are few ways to destroy a clan that takes the fight from pin method, but forcing auto-join eliminates those abilities.
Seriously, I've got hundreds of system wars under my belt. Not once have I lost one. I've faced about every tactic out there including clans taking a full on turtling approach and it didn't stop the war from looking like a pw by the time it was over. In all my time spent in the trenches I've learned that most really don't understand the strategies that can be employed into the current system. If you really think Turtling is the best method feel free to get with me in pm and we can setup a war. Your side can turtle, mine will use other methods, and we can see who wins the war.
I do completely respect you saying that you're not criticizing the pin strategy; maybe someone in this thread actually gets it.
@The Dark Knight,
You claim fighting from pin takes very little skill. For one player to fight from pin, you are correct it takes very little skill and planning. But when you are talking about a whole clan fighting from pin, you are dead wrong. That takes more skill, planning, and coordinating than any other approach you can take going into a system war. As I told Os-Macabre, What LR did against ZAFT Destiny in the finals took more planning, organizing, and coordination than any war you've even been a part of. That is a FACT. If your understanding of taking a Turtle approach in a system war is that of "keep you troops below 20%", you are missing the big picture. There are so many more aspects than just keeping your troops pinned. LR did what most clans fail to do, and they covered all those aspect quite well and it managed to get them a shiny Champion Ring.
Maybe it's you that didn't read what KaW wrote.
KaW plainly states that you will be able to attack an opponent all the down to 0 troops. Meaning that a hansel can no long can take their troops below the "pin" line and not be a target. Say your hansel has 15% troops, guess what...in this new system I can still attack you until I bring you to 0 troops, at which case you are now pinned until you reach 25% troops again, and then guess what. I can do it again, and again, and again, every time, taking away plunder from your side. You are looking at it the wrong way mate.
KaW isn't changing the mechs of the game. Be it in the new system or the one currently in use, A clan must work together to pin a single target. This wouldn't be a new tactic like you claim, sorry. Defenders have always had the upper hand, and it's always taken multiple people to pin them if you are not using xstals. That's nothing new. What is new is that fact that if you do work together as a team on pinning a player, those that did the pinning are now at a much higher risk of becoming a liability due to the fact that they will all be much lower troop and spy levels and now the other side can easily pin them. Hence my SeeSaw effect I spoke of in earlier post. Eventually everyone will be 0'd from trying to 0 out the other side and now you're stuck in a turtle war yet again.
No where does KaW state that the new system for system war will only apply to the weekly wars that KaW will host. They will apply to all wars, even those outside of the 1 weekly war setup by KaW. And even then, they say that they will try to match the clans as closely as possible but can guarantee you anything. This change applies to the all system wars mate, not just the weekend wars. You're a just taking things in context and not thinking outside of the quadrilateral parallelogram.
Yes, this is what you do when you disagree with something. The war system in play is not a broken system. This very system use to thrive, and it was like that until KaW made changes to the reward payout. The current system doesn't need to be fixed, therefore I have nothing to propose to change it. What needs to be addressed is the reward given for winning a system war. As I suggested to ATA, release Estoc's Edge into the current system and what them come back to live and thrive yet again.
Nobody has knocked or said that the current system for wars is broken or needs to be replaced. However once ATA changed the reward payout for the current system in play, everyone spoke out about it and said they wouldn't war anymore because the reward just wasn't worth it. Nobody said, I'm not warring any more because 48 hour wars are too long or people are fighting form pin, I'm not warring anymore, ect ect. Everyone quite warring simply because the reward was not longer worth it.
Mate please tell me where I say any different? Long before I ever saw your name around KaW, I have spoken out for the players of KaW and tried to make this game as enjoyable as possible. One of those things I pushed for, extremely hard , was giving the players the option to choose how long their wars are. I do believe I pushed for 6, 8, 12, 24,and 48 hour war options. KaW has given us 12, 24, and 48 hour options so far, and maybe in time they will add 6 and 8 hour options. But at least they did give the players the options, even if not all the ones requested, it's a damn good start. I'm not quite sure why you would even address something like this towards me. Again it just seems you are throwing words around looking for an argument. I'm not saying that's the case, but you should know the stance of the people you address instead of making assumptions.
Again something else I have always supported. All games must evolve in time in order to stay interesting and on par with their player base. You mention eb warriors...guess what, that's part of the evolution of KaW. KaW is a not even close to being the same game it was when I first started playing. I've always supported the games evolution, hell my clan name is based on evolutionary theories largely because our ability to adapt to the changes KaW has made. I have also always spoke out against updates that will worsen the game and given ample amount of support as to why the will not improve the game. I've already stated all KaW has to do is add Estoc's Edge to the current system and war will come back 10 fold. That's all that needs to happen, nothing more, nothing less.
For the longest of times, people thought the world was flat. Just because everyone thinks something doesn't me it's rights. Luckily a man name Eratosthenes came along and spoke out against what everyone thought to be. Thankfully, he had more knowledge on the matter than the sum of all the people that supported the earth being flat and was able to provide enough evidence for everyone to eventually come to understand that the earth is in fact round....Fear of change lol? Mate it's just a game, nothing to fear.
If you're going to put quotations around something I supposedly said, make sure you properly quote me. No were in any of my post do I ever say the word genius, or anything remotely close to what you said. I can only assume you're one of the many iProphet haters, Being that you claim you use to look forward to system wars, I can understand why you are one; probably ended up against me in one and still want to hold grudges over your defeat. Yeah I know, KaW is serious enough to hold grudges this long over a make believe war.
You aren't a smart man, you got that part right. Nothing you said makes sense. What makes even less sense is that your account is not even a year old and that's about how long system wars have been dead. Unless you're just posting with your alt to hide your main because it would be too apparently that you have some in game grudge to hold.
One last thing, If you use to look forward to system wars, what was the sudden change in heart? Something must have happened to them in order for your interest in them to go away. Please share, because the mechs of the war system haven't changed, the only thing that has is the way in which it rewards players. It's hard to understand what you're talking about with the 40% war tax being that one, it doesn't make sense, and two, being that you're unable to use words that aren't bypassed to get your point across. But from what I can make out of it, you seem to think it's a minor thing. So again I urge you to share, with informative input, why you suddenly lost interest in a system that you claim to be once so interested in, especially since nothing in the system has changed minus the way in which it rewards players.
- iProphet
Prior to the tournament, system wars have been dead for quite sometime. Pretty much since KaW changed the reward system of them and then put Mitrhil for sale in exchange for gold. So between that change and the Summer War Tournament, their have been very little, to no wars going on meaning you would have to go back to the days prior of the reward system being changed to find what exactly killed off system wars. I've said it a few times already, the change in reward for system wars it was killed it. KaW was full of system wars prior to this change, and rarely where any of them turtle wars.
@Rooneycam,
I'm extremely sadden to see this is you alt, meaning your main is probably even bigger and you think fighting from pin in a system war is the best strategy. Sorry mate, but that's not a FACT at all. There are few ways to destroy a clan that takes the fight from pin method, but forcing auto-join eliminates those abilities.
Seriously, I've got hundreds of system wars under my belt. Not once have I lost one. I've faced about every tactic out there including clans taking a full on turtling approach and it didn't stop the war from looking like a pw by the time it was over. In all my time spent in the trenches I've learned that most really don't understand the strategies that can be employed into the current system. If you really think Turtling is the best method feel free to get with me in pm and we can setup a war. Your side can turtle, mine will use other methods, and we can see who wins the war.
I do completely respect you saying that you're not criticizing the pin strategy; maybe someone in this thread actually gets it.
@The Dark Knight,
You claim fighting from pin takes very little skill. For one player to fight from pin, you are correct it takes very little skill and planning. But when you are talking about a whole clan fighting from pin, you are dead wrong. That takes more skill, planning, and coordinating than any other approach you can take going into a system war. As I told Os-Macabre, What LR did against ZAFT Destiny in the finals took more planning, organizing, and coordination than any war you've even been a part of. That is a FACT. If your understanding of taking a Turtle approach in a system war is that of "keep you troops below 20%", you are missing the big picture. There are so many more aspects than just keeping your troops pinned. LR did what most clans fail to do, and they covered all those aspect quite well and it managed to get them a shiny Champion Ring.
III_THE_DARK_KNIGHT_III said:No place for hansels. Obviously you did not read the devs response that 0 troops meant 0 attack or spy troops as such spies pinning will be very effective in wars. As regard to no new tactics if full troops for attack builds and spies working in a co-ordinated team effort to pin opponents pref as they enter the war and time their regen and re-entry to the war after being 0'd requires no skill then what does. Pinning an active player in war requires more skill than pinning someone the second they regen from pin. Which easily keeps the bigger builds out of war whilst hitting the smaller builds for plunder.
Maybe it's you that didn't read what KaW wrote.
KaW plainly states that you will be able to attack an opponent all the down to 0 troops. Meaning that a hansel can no long can take their troops below the "pin" line and not be a target. Say your hansel has 15% troops, guess what...in this new system I can still attack you until I bring you to 0 troops, at which case you are now pinned until you reach 25% troops again, and then guess what. I can do it again, and again, and again, every time, taking away plunder from your side. You are looking at it the wrong way mate.
KaW isn't changing the mechs of the game. Be it in the new system or the one currently in use, A clan must work together to pin a single target. This wouldn't be a new tactic like you claim, sorry. Defenders have always had the upper hand, and it's always taken multiple people to pin them if you are not using xstals. That's nothing new. What is new is that fact that if you do work together as a team on pinning a player, those that did the pinning are now at a much higher risk of becoming a liability due to the fact that they will all be much lower troop and spy levels and now the other side can easily pin them. Hence my SeeSaw effect I spoke of in earlier post. Eventually everyone will be 0'd from trying to 0 out the other side and now you're stuck in a turtle war yet again.
III_THE_DARK_KNIGHT_III said:In your view bigger clans will destroy smaller clans. The devs have already said they will try to match clans as evenly as possible. This is weekly wars not a tournament.
No where does KaW state that the new system for system war will only apply to the weekly wars that KaW will host. They will apply to all wars, even those outside of the 1 weekly war setup by KaW. And even then, they say that they will try to match the clans as closely as possible but can guarantee you anything. This change applies to the all system wars mate, not just the weekend wars. You're a just taking things in context and not thinking outside of the quadrilateral parallelogram.
III_THE_DARK_KNIGHT_III said:Yes there are changes and I respect your experience even if you don't respect other players and their views. But thus far you have offered arguments to thus far criticise the proposed changes that are designed to help progress the game and war system. Yet I have not seen any constructive proposals from yourself that would help advance this topic forward. If you want self pin wars don't do the weekly tournament.
Yes, this is what you do when you disagree with something. The war system in play is not a broken system. This very system use to thrive, and it was like that until KaW made changes to the reward payout. The current system doesn't need to be fixed, therefore I have nothing to propose to change it. What needs to be addressed is the reward given for winning a system war. As I suggested to ATA, release Estoc's Edge into the current system and what them come back to live and thrive yet again.
Nobody has knocked or said that the current system for wars is broken or needs to be replaced. However once ATA changed the reward payout for the current system in play, everyone spoke out about it and said they wouldn't war anymore because the reward just wasn't worth it. Nobody said, I'm not warring any more because 48 hour wars are too long or people are fighting form pin, I'm not warring anymore, ect ect. Everyone quite warring simply because the reward was not longer worth it.
III_THE_DARK_KNIGHT_III said:As for players wanting more options what is wrong with that. Variety particularly to war duration will help others with real world commitments to have a more varied experience in kaw.
Everyone jumping on the band wagon first few weeks. Great hopefully many will enjoy this new experience and continue to desire to war. If not then its worth a try and more dedicated players will continue to war in the tournaments etc.
I honestly believe 6 hour wars or shorter would encourage a significant amount of players who otherwise wouldn't to war. More wars more experience more enjoyment more wars. Where is the downside. If there are exploits I'm sure they can be addressed.
Mate please tell me where I say any different? Long before I ever saw your name around KaW, I have spoken out for the players of KaW and tried to make this game as enjoyable as possible. One of those things I pushed for, extremely hard , was giving the players the option to choose how long their wars are. I do believe I pushed for 6, 8, 12, 24,and 48 hour war options. KaW has given us 12, 24, and 48 hour options so far, and maybe in time they will add 6 and 8 hour options. But at least they did give the players the options, even if not all the ones requested, it's a damn good start. I'm not quite sure why you would even address something like this towards me. Again it just seems you are throwing words around looking for an argument. I'm not saying that's the case, but you should know the stance of the people you address instead of making assumptions.
III_THE_DARK_KNIGHT_III said:As for all war games I play everyone evolves and changes it keeps it interesting and fun and I for one am glad ata are giving us a chance to progress the war options rather than all being eb heroes.
Thus far the majority of players in this forum seem to support these changes and yourself and a couple of others fear the changes. If you can propose some changes rather than just criticise kaw for their suggestions please let's hear them.
Again something else I have always supported. All games must evolve in time in order to stay interesting and on par with their player base. You mention eb warriors...guess what, that's part of the evolution of KaW. KaW is a not even close to being the same game it was when I first started playing. I've always supported the games evolution, hell my clan name is based on evolutionary theories largely because our ability to adapt to the changes KaW has made. I have also always spoke out against updates that will worsen the game and given ample amount of support as to why the will not improve the game. I've already stated all KaW has to do is add Estoc's Edge to the current system and war will come back 10 fold. That's all that needs to happen, nothing more, nothing less.
For the longest of times, people thought the world was flat. Just because everyone thinks something doesn't me it's rights. Luckily a man name Eratosthenes came along and spoke out against what everyone thought to be. Thankfully, he had more knowledge on the matter than the sum of all the people that supported the earth being flat and was able to provide enough evidence for everyone to eventually come to understand that the earth is in fact round....Fear of change lol? Mate it's just a game, nothing to fear.
bunuoxide said:Roll out these changes kaw. Can't wait to try out this new system, looking forward to sw like I used to.
I tried reading prophets rant but got lost at the “ it takes a genius trained by geniuses to turtle ” part.
And as for rewards someone said 40% war tax bla bla bla... A few hits/steals for 24 hrs ( 12 hrs for that matter ) = **** all. Now I'm not a smart man but 40% on **** all = **** all.
And I'm pretty sure these rules only apply to dev match up wars, so... problem?
If you're going to put quotations around something I supposedly said, make sure you properly quote me. No were in any of my post do I ever say the word genius, or anything remotely close to what you said. I can only assume you're one of the many iProphet haters, Being that you claim you use to look forward to system wars, I can understand why you are one; probably ended up against me in one and still want to hold grudges over your defeat. Yeah I know, KaW is serious enough to hold grudges this long over a make believe war.
You aren't a smart man, you got that part right. Nothing you said makes sense. What makes even less sense is that your account is not even a year old and that's about how long system wars have been dead. Unless you're just posting with your alt to hide your main because it would be too apparently that you have some in game grudge to hold.
One last thing, If you use to look forward to system wars, what was the sudden change in heart? Something must have happened to them in order for your interest in them to go away. Please share, because the mechs of the war system haven't changed, the only thing that has is the way in which it rewards players. It's hard to understand what you're talking about with the 40% war tax being that one, it doesn't make sense, and two, being that you're unable to use words that aren't bypassed to get your point across. But from what I can make out of it, you seem to think it's a minor thing. So again I urge you to share, with informative input, why you suddenly lost interest in a system that you claim to be once so interested in, especially since nothing in the system has changed minus the way in which it rewards players.
- iProphet