Os-Macabre,
You think turtling takes no skill whatsoever and isn't a valid tactic? Are you discrediting what LR just did against ZAFT Destiny as a totally fluke and they got lucky? ZAFT's 23rd member in clan was larger than LR's 7th. Please tell all of us under what circumstances LR could have went toe to toe with ZAFT besides going the turtle route? And then for you to say it takes no skill, I find that to be disgraceful
Your clan is one of the main reasons turtling is such a tried and true method. Remember back about a year ago, when OS was a mean, green, warring machine. I'd say i met up with OS members easily twice a week to merc into a war, never once losing because the sheer overwhelming power we would bring with us. After my good friend yoongy left OS, I no longer felt the need to merc into wars with OS. But I certainly felt the need to still merc. So I started mercing against OS with my little rag tag team from Forty Six and Two, and ya know what....We never lost. Even though we would be going up against the might of OS, who had multiple LB players in it, our tactics still proved to work better and we walked away with the victory...every time.
Fact is, there are very few clans that can go toe to toe with a clan that stacked with the lb players. Not to mention, the ones not LB are rather large themselves. Turtling is a vital role for these match ups.
I'm still in awe you think there's no skill to turtle war. It's a slap in the face to what LR pulled off to win the summer war(which trust me, took way more planning and coordination than any war OS has ever taken part in).
@The Dark Knight,
I read through some of your earlier post in this thread, but the one you addressed to me, I simply couldn't make it through. You started bringing up matters of which I didn't even speak of and it makes no sense why you would address those concerns to me unless you're just grasping for something to try and argue about.
Based on your other post, and one addressed towards me, I truly don't think you are the kaw master you think you are. Sorry mate, but a lot of what you say has no backing and is just you throwing words around.
I did make it to your part about the who cares if war pays crap, if we win we get our Estoc's Edge and can make up for the lost time/money the following week bit. Let me point something out to you. Not every war is going to give you Estoc's Edge, Only one war a week will. So what about all the other wars in between the ATA setup Weekly Wars? This system doesn't encourage players to take part in war because it's fun, more strategic, or any other reasons you or anyone else wants to throw out there. This new system is only going to draw people into war because of the reward of Estoc's Edges. That's a FACT!
I challenge ATA to prove me wrong on this matter. Figure out how you want to work Estoc's Edge( I agree with the thinking of 'giving it to the player(s) that are in the war and not the clans' , otherwise it will be way to easy to exploit) and introduce it into your current war system. Watch what happens. Anyone wanna bet me that the current war system wouldn't take off like never before and the pulse of system wars would thrive throughout KaW has it did prior to the change in how wars rewarded players? I've got some pretty hefty accounts to wager...any takers at all?
@ KaW,
I really do challenge you on what I stated above. Sticking with out "car analogies", that's great you want to add a new engine thats going to give it 100 more HP. But what you fail to understand is that Its not about how much HP the engine produces, it's about how much of that HP gets to the wheels.
Again, I don't mean to sound or be disrespectful with my posting, but I honestly do doubt the understanding you have of your own game play. From the many failed updates to us beta testers beating the devs in a system war(how the hell do the makers of the game not beat the players!?), you often show you work hard to improve and add to the game, but you also show a lack of understanding of it's game play. I think it's great you are taking feedback from players on this upcoming update, but just because someone downloaded kaw from itunes doesn't mean they will be giving you good solid feedback. We both know that a majority of the post here are things that will never come into effect, due to most people not truly understanding the game itself and what can be done with a game of this sorts.
I believe the best thing you can do for this update is really look at the pros vs the cons. I've collected my thoughts one this issue since you posted this, and I have come up with many pros, but I have far more cons. Really reflect on what changing the current war system in play with the one you propose will change as far as game play goes. Not just from a developers pov, but actually break down all the aspects of game play you have in this game and see how much they will change with the proposed system. Also think about what type of strategies this new system can bring to war. And don't just mindlessly think of them, test them out and see how realistic they are.
And last but not least.....You've been putting in some serious hours lately ATA, tons of updates rolling out across all platforms...How about we finally get a KWT(KaW World TIme). It's so simple to do, literally an ape could code it. Just pick a spot somewhere in WC to add a little box with KWT and give your community a standard time in which they can base everything off of. That little change would go farther than any update I can thinking of in recent times. so pleeeeaaaassssseeeeeeeee, I'm tried of begging for it =P
- iProphet