I haven't been able to make it through all the post without falling asleep, but a majority of what I've read has been butt kissing and/or utter stupidity. So allow me to shed some light on many things that are wrong with this update based on the information at hand. Chances are this will be a bit of a read so all you TL

R peeps can just skip over this one.
I want to start out by saying this, the more you complicate something, the easier it becomes to exploit. It's a fact of gaming that applies to any game, and KaW is no exception. Our community has a lot of highly intelligent players that will find exploits of this new system. There's not been one update that we haven't been able to exploit in one way or another and this one will be no different.
That being said, lets move on to the issues I see with the up and coming changes to the warring system. Lets start with Estoc's Edges. I talked to many players about this reward and nobody really seems to understand how it's going to work. Say a clan decides to war and wins, receives this reward. Said winning clan only has 50 players. With the only 30% of the clan roster being able to be changed, where does that 30% apply? Does it mean that only 30% of the 50 members that took place in the war can leave the clan or is it 30% change to the overall roster? If it's 30% to the whole roster, you're now saying that clans of 100 that do not have 100 members available to commit to a 12 hour war (we do have lives outside of KaW, ATA) will be punished and have to split the clan in order to war and will not be able to reunite as one after war without losing thier bonus. If it's a smaller clan of 50 that is actively growing and recruiting you are also limiting their abilities to grow into a stronger clan by only allowing them to accept 15 new members throughout the course of time the bonus from the reward lasts If the % applies only to the members that were on the war roster, you now a have very easily exploited option that I won't go into detail on. I like the idea of it, but either way it seems flawed.
Now let's really get into the meat of the potato here and talk about strategy. Disabling the ablitity to pin on quest, sweeping your roster checking for people that are leaking, having outside allied clans pin inactives, xstal usage; You wish to remove all of these things, but they are all STRATEGIES of the current war system. This stuff doesn't just happen on its own. It takes a lot of planning and coordinating to properly pull off all the above mentioned strategies. These aren't even close to the only strategies available, the current system is full of strategy just as is. You're not adding strategy, it's already there, you are making a new system that will require totally different strategies than what your game has been based off of for the last couple years.
As of late, a lot of people of have been complaining about system wars being nothing more than turtle wars. A large part of this has to do with the fact that the summer war tournament forces all players active at the start of war. By doing so, you are also forcing players to make sure they are self pinned prior to the war clicker starting so the enemy can't bum rush them and take a huge lead right off the jump. Not to mention that how a clan enters its players into a war is one of the most vital strategies of war and you completely take that aspect away with the auto join feature. Turtle wars have been around for a long time, and it's a very important strategy to implement when a weaker clan is going up a clan that has merc'd heavily or just flat out is way stronger. Toe to toe they don't have a chance trying to match the larger clan hit for hit so they use this strategy to give them a fighting chance. You claim you want to let clans prove themselves in war not based on stats but on their ability to war and come up with strategy for it, yet you're taking away one of the most important strategies for any smaller clan that faces a larger one. Turtling, as good of a tactic as it is, is NOT the best tactic to win a war. The "pin and sit" method is far superior, but many clans don't have the understanding of system war to be able to successfully pull off this strategy. I've led countless wars to victory under this method, and have only been forced into using the turtling strategy when the opposing side was much stronger and our side did not have the man power or stats to be able to go head to head with them and come out ahead.
Time to touch on something they want to add: the ablitity to bring an opponent to 0 troops and spies. From what is written by ATA, an opponent can be attacked all the way down to 0 troops and spies, at which time they will go dtw until they reach 25% troops. Does this mean that if a player attacks someone until they have 15% troops that they are NOT pinned and other side can hit them down to 0 troops? If so, you just elimanated a whole group of builds out there called hansels from being able to take part in wars. Hansels would no longer be able to self pin their troops and since most have allies they can not drop their attack builds for war otherwise they are an easy strip target that will cost their side the war. Now I mean no disrepect to ATA by this, but are you sure you understand how your game works? You want to allow players to take other players to 0 troops and spies, which will cause the player 0'd to lose plunder made. Are you aware how hard it is to take an opponent to 0? If I were to take someone to 0 troops in war, I would have to use all of my troops attacking them, and a majority, if not all, of my spies assassinating them to finish of thier troops. And they still have spies left. So at the cost of all my troops and spies I can't even 0 a target out completely on my own, but attempting to do so has now killed all my troops and spies, leaving me as an easy target for the remaining duration of war to be taken to 0 by the enemy. Maybe you are trying to get us to use more teamwork. Well, in order for any clan, even with the current system, to win a war they have to use teamwork to try and pin the opposing side. Even if you do work in teams to 0 out opponets, all you do is create a seesaw type effect . You take one player down to 0 troops and spies and now you have multiple players that are at much lower troop and spy level and the enemy does the same to those players. Eventually all the players are back to being pinned, sucking away the others plunder earned. Limiting our xstal usage to only one doesn't help this plan at all either. Defenders have always had the advantage. There's no way in my right mind I would considering wasting troops on trying 0 an opponent so that I can become an easy target to be 0'd myself, losing the plunder which I just earned. I see wars becoming like wack-a-mole, even like the old pwars days, 2 hits and regen so that nobody sacrifices their troops and spies to become an easy target that causes their clan to lose plunder earned. I just don't see any strategy in a system like that. And what happens when a stronger clan takes on a weaker one? Too bad, better luck next time? Not only will the larger clan be able to make more plunder due to their builds, but they can also 0 out the weaker clan much more easily. That kind of takes away from the letting clans show who is better in war based of strategy and teamwork aspects and says no matter your strategy, stats will prevail. NO FUN.
The best thing I see about this whole thread, is that ATA is listening to its players for a change, sadly most of them haven't a clue what they are talking about. But I do commend ATA for reaching out to their players and letting us voice our concerns. Now you have heard mine.
- iProphet