Upcoming Feature: Clan Roles!

This is no way to change the game, there is nothing wrong with the way it is now. This will cause the demise of this game! It's just plain stupid!
 
Nerfarious said:
Right, here's my 2 cents:

It's about time the clan system was overhauled. Very welcomed change.

HOWEVER there are significant flaws in this. Firstly, if you're the owner of a clan - surely you should be able to decide how many you want of each type of admin. Why are the devs limiting it?

Secondly, the role of an admin in 99% of clans is to keep back to back EBs flowing and answer the door. Yet there are only 16 people out of 100 that can do that?

I see absolutely no point in an admin that can only kick players. What use is that?

From my point of view, the pricing is going to kill new starter clans. Which will in turn kill new starters, which will result in a lack of new blood which will make the inevitable and looming decision to turn the servers off a reality. If this game is still a viable money maker, this needs to be reconsidered.

There needs to be a new level of admin that can open the door and start ebs - not even fussed about forfeiting ebs. This needs to be unlimited, or have a far greater limit on it and be realistically priced.

While you're overhauling the clan system please consider:

Admin Chat - this would make admin meetings far easier and don't rely on taking players out of the game to use a 3rd party app to chat.

Clan Tax - Clans should be able to earn money (only to be used on clan slot upgrades and any future clan purchasable items) through an EB tax. Clan owner should be able to set this tax from 1% to 25%. Tax can only be set while there is not an EB active and should be clearly visible to new players and a notification should be sent to all members once this is changed). Essentially the % chosen should then come out of every members final EB payout.

Private Clan Info Section If I want to share an EB rotation or EB intructions or clan adverts with the clan, I either have to PM them all separately, put it on the public Clan Profile or try and fit it into a tiny CA. It would be great if there was a page, like the Clan Profile which was only viewable by members and could only be updated by admins.
 
I'm loving the concept but can't help but notice the more relevant titles comes with a hefty price tag, was wondering will said titles have Correlating plunder bonuses to make having a title worth while?
 
I love it, full support!!! I do have some tweaks though I think there should be. Sorry if I missed it being said already 56 pages is a lot to skim through.

1] Top 3 Spots should only have access to Clan Page. No one else.
2] All positions should be able to watch the door.
3] All admin positions have a 12hr window they can leave and reenter without waiting to be accepted. Resetting once you have remained in the clan for 12 hours or more. Making it possible for someone to jump out to help a friend or do an indi and get back in quickly with their admin position.

With the amount of money needed to open all positions why not add a guild tax into the equation? This can then tie into more cool things like eb bonus for clan, static stats, increased drop rates like EE, buying more member positions, clan pots, I'm sure the list can go on forever. Or even a simple bank to fund members for growth or clan strips.
 

Important Note Regarding Admins


When this transition to the new Clan Roles system is implemented all members other than the Clan Owner will have their ranks automatically set to Peasant. Owners will then need to manually assign ranks to their members using the new Clan Roles.

If your clan does not have an active owner, players can follow the following procedure to appoint a new owner before the new clan roles go live:
  • Have 3 Admins leave feedback requesting a transfer of ownership and stating which player they would like ownership transferred to.
  • Have 1 Clan Member email support@athinkingape.com informing us of this request, and list the names of Clan Members who have sent in feedback.

For clans with fewer than 3 active admins:
  • All active admins must leave feedback requesting a transfer of ownership and stating which player they would like ownership transferred to.

For clans with no active admins:
  • At least 50% of the active clan members must leave feedback requesting a transfer of ownership and stating which player they would like ownership transferred to.
[/quote]


It'll be interesting to see if this is rolled out as currently structured -- and clan admins are all MASS de-admined and the owner isn't active that day or that week (hey maybe vacation - and maybe they are smart and delegate duties) how many clans will die because no one can get door or start an eb. Then see how many people (some potentially that are moles in clans ) take clans from owners (who paid for them) by emailing support that their owner isn't active at the time the mass de-adminning happened. And who is to define Active (daily active, weekly active monthly)? You can offer this system fine, but make it optional. Let folks keep their admins as they are, when they bought the clans that was part of the deal. The Gold and BS titles don't bother me personally -- heck let us pay 99T to just unlock it for everyone -- but thats us. But the lack of admin types that can get the door and start an eb will hurt some clans, especially when you are pushing for more ee wars so when the one admin that can get door leaves who is left to answer it to let him/her back in? And taking away admin from those who already have it -- I can see the rage pms to owners who have no idea this is happening and people just quitting the game. I can't see this affecting our clan one way or another -- just fighting for some simple common sense here, I see horrible things happening.

I am sure people are already trying to figure out how to get enemies in rival clans snag owner one day and change name then grab the name on the main in their real clan. Hey it is Kingdoms at War, and I guess all is fair in War -- but I doubt your Support is gonna wanna get the mass influx of rage mail.

One point of support, clan owner being able to change clan name -- that's one positive. But the willy nilly roll out of this needs to be rethought with some intelligence. Allow owners to 'opt in' to the new system when they are ready or something.
 
IIIllElIBlILlIlOlIRlIDllIII said:
I too asked for and supported a richer clan structure, and have to agree that the prices are a bit rediculous and labels demeaning.


Owner/Leader x1
Co-Owner/Co-Leader x1
War Commander x1
Recruitment Officer x2
Officers x5
Soldiers unlimited

Additional slots for each position could then be purchased, by the owner, for an additional 50b per slot starting at 100b for the first slot purchased. Second slot would be 150b, third 200b etc.

Sounds like a better label structure to me.
--------------------

--------------------

So after I thought about it a bit, the best thing I could come up with to compromise the issue between players and devs is this:


Clan Bank

This feature would enable everyone in the clan to donate to buy said slots with in the clan instead of the burden resting in one player. Of course there would be a 10-25% tax (like war tax) for any gold donated to the clan bank.

This would help offset the costs and make it a more reachable goal.
 
This is bull! The only ones who are able to play this stupid game anymore are the powerhouses that spend ridiculous amounts of money and time on the game! Being a mom with 4 kids and taking care of a disabled mother this game used to be my getaway my escape! I remember when I started that 25 mil CS was damn decent now I can barely touch anything! I thought this was also supposed to be a game for kids how are they supposed to afford to play? Now I know that a lot of the leaderboard are players who have played for over 5 years. But it seems to me that the devs just want money money money money money
 
Oh. How about adding a new position :
(Insert fancy bbc)
WENCH
Slots = 1
Cost = 1 Trill
When you hit the wench, your troops unload faster, you lose a little plunder, but you feel really good about it.
 
Splooger said:
Oh. How about adding a new position :
(Insert fancy bbc)
WENCH
Slots = 1
Cost = 1 Trill
When you hit the wench, your troops unload faster, you lose a little plunder, but you feel really good about it.

 
TAnked said:
Majin_Venom said:
We ask for Co-owner Position, why did you Turn this in "To a Pay to Play Feature"? This gave is having issues with Real people Playing.. You are killing around 80% of The Clans out there? .. But devs i hope you stop and open Your eyes, that you continúe to kill The game... Too much ads, pay to Play... This is only a simple tap to Play , and you are still killing The community that AtA created by accident 5 years ago... Pls stop with this nonsense and FIX YOUR GAME WITHout US PAYING FOR YOUR MISTAKES OR LACK OF EFFORT, this co-owner is something every Mmorg game already have , every person who Play this type of games we know this...

Good, the more clans that die, the larger the better clans get. Eventually those big clans make smaller clans etc. eventually there will be two alliances that split kaw up.

And since one alliance isn't gonna attack their own :O
Massive OSW!!!!!!!!!!!

Look. Kaw is already hosting massive turf wars... Apoc/Zaft/ig/.wog....is BH around any more? I have friends from all those alliances, but the damn pissing contests is all we hear about. That's fine, because there are still a ton of other Strong yet peaceful clans out there Filled with people who welcome you and chat about your day. If you weed out some of those friendly small clans, like somebody else mentioned here in the forums, there will be no new blood. Those who occasionally would spend money will stop and find another game. And, I suppose that's find for the devs because they have players that are willing to spend their hard earned money and I mean dumping hundreds of dollars a month on this game, so, they don't care. The players that struggled to get where they are, like myself playing for almost 2 years to get even as small as this. Having to pay for admin slots and giving the horrible title of peasant takes away from a plan to be able to make the decisions on what names and titles and rank they give people it takes the creativity away from them. Anyway I'll see you guys around until I can't afford to play anymore....lol

Y
 
Terrible updates and terrible new way to earn free nobs! Very irritating 1 out of 15 offers I completed with actually valid information gave me 20 nobs. Ready to leave reviews on the Apple Store that 3rd party apps are a scam in game
 
1) No true co-owner position that we have requested. unacceptable
2) Too many confusing levels. Ranks should increase in responsibilities/power as they go up, not have random powers. Unacceptable
3) Need fewer ranks with the ability to change role & clan page. It appears that people other than clan owner/co-owner can randomly change roles on their own without any restrictions. Only power the owner will have that others don't is the disband the clan & change the clan name. Unacceptable
4) Need more with basic power to start & ff ebs, accept applicants & kick anyone with a lower rank
5) No one should be able to alter the role or kick someone in a rank higher than theirs.
6) This is a WAR Game, we have soldiers, not peasants. That is a demeaning name & unacceptable.
7) Limits assume everyone plays 24/7. It will be difficult to balance abilities for coverage through the different time zones with limits on ranks
8) Ranks should be something people can work their way up through not revolving doors with random authority.
 
RoyalB said:
This is bull! The only ones who are able to play this stupid game anymore are the powerhouses that spend ridiculous amounts of money and time on the game! Being a mom with 4 kids and taking care of a disabled mother this game used to be my getaway my escape! I remember when I started that 25 mil CS was damn decent now I can barely touch anything! I thought this was also supposed to be a game for kids how are they supposed to afford to play? Now I know that a lot of the leaderboard are players who have played for over 5 years. But it seems to me that the devs just want money money money money money
Just let the big spenders buy the slots then use them yourself...
 
Back
Top