Hi devs,
I've written a long email to you since you replied to my pm saying that you listen to all the feedbacks not just those from the forum. However, you reply was to tell me to post in the forum instead. So I'm posting here hoping to receive your response.
I don't want to repeat what's bad about primal wars or indi wars. A lot of people have already pointed them out.
Let's just focus on the issues with the current matchups in normal clan wars and the possible fixes so that we can bring the normal clan wars back and also fit everyone's need.
1. We know that the first and major complaint is the stacking of lbs/shs. IMO all builds are valid builds. They exist for a reason and have their own weakness and strength. People only talked about lb/sh stacking, but they forgot there were other types of stackings including lbs/big stacking, lb/ps stacking(those two happen most often in the top bracket of EE wars), tank builds stacking(popular in primal wars), etc. etc.
What I want to point out is that the problem is not about the stacking itself but that the same type of rosters don't match to each other. If lbs/shs only match to lbs/shs, will you gain unfair advantages from the builds themselves? Is it still an exploit? Apparently not.
The same applies to all sh/gh rosters. I've noticed many times in normal clan wars that when there were all ghs/shs rosters, they all matched to non gh/sh rosters instead of matching to each other. It's a problem of the matchup system NOT the builds themselves.
To fix it algorithm wise, you may consider creating different symbols representing different builds including sh/gh, mids and bigs. So every roster creates a pattern made of different type of builds. When you do matchups, you can do pattern matching so the rosters with most similar patterns will get to match to each other. So a roster of all bigs only matches to another roster of all bigs, a roster of a lot of mids matches to another roster with tons of mids, and lbs/shs to lb/shs, etc. That will solve the lb/sh exploits (as well as other exploits) if lb/sh only matches to lb/sh but not other type of rosters.
Conclusion: MATCH THE SAME TYPE OF ROSTERS TO EACH OTHER.
2. You may ask what if there are no same type of rosters signing up in the war.
In such a case, you can give a no match to the roster with most infrequent pattern. And in the long run, to give more war rewards to encourage the participation is the key. Free war xtals as you've promised since s2, no loss of EE/rancor after losing the war, better payout from wars than ebs... All those would encourage more participation.
Conclusion: GIVE MORE REWARDS TO ENCOURAGE THE PARTICIPATION.
3. Complaints about bfe/bfa mismatch.
We know bfe/bfa are like static stats while raw stats are dynamic. Those two are like two independent coordinates. They don't add up directly when considering matchups. You can compute the average BFE+BFA for a roster as value A and average raw stats as value B. Then matchup criteria could be set up as:
if A > value1 or B > value2, no match;
else match.
Conclusion: CONSIDER BFA/BFE AND RAW STATS SEPARATELY IN YOUR MATCHUP ALGORITHM.
4. Complaints about ppl without decent bfe or towers not able to war.
To solve that problem, you can divide the matchups based on leagues (average BFA+BFE).
For example,
if average BFE+BFA <= value3, then the clan will be matched in league 1 (less experienced).
If value3 < average BFA+BFE <= value4, then clan is matched in league 2 (somewhat experienced).
If average BFA+BFE > value4, then the clan is matched in league3 (most experienced).
After participating clans are assigned into different leagues, the matchups can be done based on no. 3 mentioned above. To facilitate the league wars, more participation is still a must. I believe as more ppl have confidence in your matchups and if wars can give them more rewards than ebs, they will eventually sign up and war.
Conclusion: DIVIDE THE WARRING CLANS BASED ON AVERAGE BFA+BFE.
5. Roster size.
To encourage more participation, roster size can't be made too big. A bigger roster means a clan has to find more players to war. A feasible roster size will be around 11 to 15. I remember the clan wars of size 11 generally provided pretty fair matches.
I also have some other ideas but it'll be better if you can help me understand what your current difficulty is so I can give advice accordingly.
Last but not the least, we're willing to support and help increase the participation by helping those who want to learn about wars. If the clan wars are back and more fair matches are in place we can provide training sessions for those without experience and those with experience but want to learn more. If you can make it an official event... like training wars with refunded xtals to increase participation that would be perfect.
Thanks for your time. We're looking forward to your reply.
Best regards,
DRAGONS SANCTUARY
Update 1:
Fixing the flaws in the matchup system is the key to resolve all the issues. Indi/Primal wars don't necessarily serve the purpose. There are still mismatches. There are some examples as follows:
Primal war:
Primal war match up 300m cs vs 660m cs
viewtopic.php?f=11&t=167203
Indi war:
Unfair Match 33, Cunning Rovers vs Honorable Fiends
viewtopic.php?f=11&t=167143
According to my observation, outmatches of over 200+mil cs seem to happen often in primal wars. This leads to a question: do you remove the BFE/BFA before you make the matchups?
The mismatch in indi wars happen usually when you put more towered builds with better bfe (mith/ee equipments) in one roster while builds with bigger stats but weaker bfa/bfe and towers in another, which means you put more experienced players in one while less experienced ones in another instead of evenly distributing them into two rosters. This is a mismatch of builds, bfe and experience.
Aside from that, another type of mismatch is the mismatch of BFA while you have a top 10 lb in one roster and a top 50-100 lb in another. For 90% of the time, the one with bigger lb wins the war.
All those above proves that by changing the war type won't fix the mismatch issue whether there's stacking or not. Changing your matchup algorithm will.
I've written a long email to you since you replied to my pm saying that you listen to all the feedbacks not just those from the forum. However, you reply was to tell me to post in the forum instead. So I'm posting here hoping to receive your response.
I don't want to repeat what's bad about primal wars or indi wars. A lot of people have already pointed them out.
Let's just focus on the issues with the current matchups in normal clan wars and the possible fixes so that we can bring the normal clan wars back and also fit everyone's need.
1. We know that the first and major complaint is the stacking of lbs/shs. IMO all builds are valid builds. They exist for a reason and have their own weakness and strength. People only talked about lb/sh stacking, but they forgot there were other types of stackings including lbs/big stacking, lb/ps stacking(those two happen most often in the top bracket of EE wars), tank builds stacking(popular in primal wars), etc. etc.
What I want to point out is that the problem is not about the stacking itself but that the same type of rosters don't match to each other. If lbs/shs only match to lbs/shs, will you gain unfair advantages from the builds themselves? Is it still an exploit? Apparently not.
The same applies to all sh/gh rosters. I've noticed many times in normal clan wars that when there were all ghs/shs rosters, they all matched to non gh/sh rosters instead of matching to each other. It's a problem of the matchup system NOT the builds themselves.
To fix it algorithm wise, you may consider creating different symbols representing different builds including sh/gh, mids and bigs. So every roster creates a pattern made of different type of builds. When you do matchups, you can do pattern matching so the rosters with most similar patterns will get to match to each other. So a roster of all bigs only matches to another roster of all bigs, a roster of a lot of mids matches to another roster with tons of mids, and lbs/shs to lb/shs, etc. That will solve the lb/sh exploits (as well as other exploits) if lb/sh only matches to lb/sh but not other type of rosters.
Conclusion: MATCH THE SAME TYPE OF ROSTERS TO EACH OTHER.
2. You may ask what if there are no same type of rosters signing up in the war.
In such a case, you can give a no match to the roster with most infrequent pattern. And in the long run, to give more war rewards to encourage the participation is the key. Free war xtals as you've promised since s2, no loss of EE/rancor after losing the war, better payout from wars than ebs... All those would encourage more participation.
Conclusion: GIVE MORE REWARDS TO ENCOURAGE THE PARTICIPATION.
3. Complaints about bfe/bfa mismatch.
We know bfe/bfa are like static stats while raw stats are dynamic. Those two are like two independent coordinates. They don't add up directly when considering matchups. You can compute the average BFE+BFA for a roster as value A and average raw stats as value B. Then matchup criteria could be set up as:
if A > value1 or B > value2, no match;
else match.
Conclusion: CONSIDER BFA/BFE AND RAW STATS SEPARATELY IN YOUR MATCHUP ALGORITHM.
4. Complaints about ppl without decent bfe or towers not able to war.
To solve that problem, you can divide the matchups based on leagues (average BFA+BFE).
For example,
if average BFE+BFA <= value3, then the clan will be matched in league 1 (less experienced).
If value3 < average BFA+BFE <= value4, then clan is matched in league 2 (somewhat experienced).
If average BFA+BFE > value4, then the clan is matched in league3 (most experienced).
After participating clans are assigned into different leagues, the matchups can be done based on no. 3 mentioned above. To facilitate the league wars, more participation is still a must. I believe as more ppl have confidence in your matchups and if wars can give them more rewards than ebs, they will eventually sign up and war.
Conclusion: DIVIDE THE WARRING CLANS BASED ON AVERAGE BFA+BFE.
5. Roster size.
To encourage more participation, roster size can't be made too big. A bigger roster means a clan has to find more players to war. A feasible roster size will be around 11 to 15. I remember the clan wars of size 11 generally provided pretty fair matches.
I also have some other ideas but it'll be better if you can help me understand what your current difficulty is so I can give advice accordingly.
Last but not the least, we're willing to support and help increase the participation by helping those who want to learn about wars. If the clan wars are back and more fair matches are in place we can provide training sessions for those without experience and those with experience but want to learn more. If you can make it an official event... like training wars with refunded xtals to increase participation that would be perfect.
Thanks for your time. We're looking forward to your reply.
Best regards,
DRAGONS SANCTUARY
Update 1:
Fixing the flaws in the matchup system is the key to resolve all the issues. Indi/Primal wars don't necessarily serve the purpose. There are still mismatches. There are some examples as follows:
Primal war:
Primal war match up 300m cs vs 660m cs
viewtopic.php?f=11&t=167203
Indi war:
Unfair Match 33, Cunning Rovers vs Honorable Fiends
viewtopic.php?f=11&t=167143
According to my observation, outmatches of over 200+mil cs seem to happen often in primal wars. This leads to a question: do you remove the BFE/BFA before you make the matchups?
The mismatch in indi wars happen usually when you put more towered builds with better bfe (mith/ee equipments) in one roster while builds with bigger stats but weaker bfa/bfe and towers in another, which means you put more experienced players in one while less experienced ones in another instead of evenly distributing them into two rosters. This is a mismatch of builds, bfe and experience.
Aside from that, another type of mismatch is the mismatch of BFA while you have a top 10 lb in one roster and a top 50-100 lb in another. For 90% of the time, the one with bigger lb wins the war.
All those above proves that by changing the war type won't fix the mismatch issue whether there's stacking or not. Changing your matchup algorithm will.