Gamehendge
Well-Known Member
I mentioned this in passing earlier but wanted to expand on the idea some. I really do think locking Rosters to a pre-set number of Members is the way to go here. If only 5% of Clans are fielding over 60 Members anyway, Roster sizes of 30 or 60 even should not be difficult to accomodate. As it is now the Roster sizes have be parred down to 30-45 or 30-60, just change this to 30 or 60, period. This would solve all the issues of disparate Actions, Crystals, etc. without having to build anymore smarts into the War System.
The downside to implementing this would be that some Kingdoms may be left out of a War they otherwise could participate in, but I think this is the lesser of two evils as these Kingdoms could always War elsewhere, if not have a go the following day. I would have the top-30 or top-60 non-Veiled Kingdoms (depending on the size of the War joined) automatically fill the War Roster at Match-Up, with the extra non-Veiled Kingdoms getting bumped. This Roster-Cropping will make management of a War Roster easier too, since you only need to worry about your 30 or 60.
The extra Kingdoms looking for a home to War from may form run-off Clans to fight together, which will only add to competition. Two Clans of 30 could band together to try their luck at a 60-member War as well. This solution adds a lot of flexibility and significantly less headache than a wonky Crystal handicap.
The downside to implementing this would be that some Kingdoms may be left out of a War they otherwise could participate in, but I think this is the lesser of two evils as these Kingdoms could always War elsewhere, if not have a go the following day. I would have the top-30 or top-60 non-Veiled Kingdoms (depending on the size of the War joined) automatically fill the War Roster at Match-Up, with the extra non-Veiled Kingdoms getting bumped. This Roster-Cropping will make management of a War Roster easier too, since you only need to worry about your 30 or 60.
The extra Kingdoms looking for a home to War from may form run-off Clans to fight together, which will only add to competition. Two Clans of 30 could band together to try their luck at a 60-member War as well. This solution adds a lot of flexibility and significantly less headache than a wonky Crystal handicap.