Recognizing that households do not buy private flood insurance, the Federal government has long offered, under the National Flood Insurance Program administered by FEMA, subsidized flood policies. In some parts of the country, homeowners are buying these, but not in Texas. In Houston’s Harris County only 15% of homes have flood insurance. And in the coastal Corpus Christi vicinity, only 20% are covered. Simply put, many people currently being affected by Hurricane Harvey who were not required by mortgage lenders to buy flood insurance chose not to, despite the subsidies.
Homeowners’ losses in Houston will be particularly high because, like no other U.S. city, Houston is famous for its lax building codes and permissive zoning laws. Homes are not required to have proper flood elevation, and neighborhoods are not planned to minimize flooding. It is this combination—lack of flood-prevention and of flood-insurance—that may account for the magnitude of uninsured property losses the region is now experiencing.
The immensity of Houston’s disaster, and the likely disproportionate concentration of uninsured losses among the less affluent, could easily teach the wrong lesson. As people begin to dig out from the inundation and struggle to rebuild, we will hear calls for expanding the federal flood insurance coverage, so that more working class people would be able to afford flood insurance in the future. That would be exactly the wrong lesson. It would only guarantee an even bigger disaster when the next 500-year storm (which now seem to arrive in quick succession) hits.
Government subsidized flood insurance is a bad idea for two big reasons. First, our own research shows that the main beneficiaries of the subsidies are not the poor, but rather affluent homeowners living in waterfront properties. And, second, subsidies distort the incentive to develop real estate in devastation-prone areas. If property owners do not have to pay the full cost of living with extreme weather, they flock to such regions, passing on much of the disaster risk to unwitting taxpayers.