Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
KingCalm said:Can we note here that the Bill of Rights initially only applied to the Federal government, and did not apply to the states - meaning the states could pass any type of speech prohibitive laws. Until selective incorporation, the Bill of Rights was largely irrelevant to most Americans. Actually, that is quite a change from early America.
KingCalm said:The supremacy clause acts to preempt state laws when they operate in the same sphere as federal law. The Bill of Rights limited only the National government and congress and not state governments so the supremacy clause was not relevant.
http://info.legalzoom.com/meant-selecti ... 20152.html
Sorry to give you a Legal Zoom explanation, but I really don't feel like teaching Constitutional Law and History 101 today.

Imitation-Cheese said:Interesting. Why didn't the founders compel the states to extend the Bill of Rights to their citizens?
Regardless of the supreme court's decision, I still interpret the constitutional supremacy clause as meaning the entire constitution supersedes state law. In fact, it also says that any powers not explicitly given to the federal government by the constitution shall remain with the states. So if the power to give certain civil rights is in the constitution, then those same rights ought to be guaranteed by the states.