Moose said:
This isn't an attack, its an honest question about big corporations.
If tax breaks aren't the answer to keeping them in your country,mand they are taking jobs over seas, how do you incentivize them to stay in America? And how do you incentivize them to keep jobs in your country?
This isn't s "right winger" question meant to defend the status quo, so much as its a genuine inquiry. I'd be interested in what you've got up your sleeve to fix this issie
This isn't an attack either, but those colors are damn hard to read, on pc and tablet
Anyway, that's a specific problem where manipulating the tax code can actually help. You use a carrot and a stick. You give tax credits for jobs created here, and you give tax penalties for jobs created overseas.
Interestingly enough, there was a bill in 2012 that gave small-businesses tax breaks when they either added to their payrolls or increased pay, and accelerated the way in which they deduct business expenses. It got filibustered and died in the Senate.
It's a localized band aid solution though. It basically lowers labor costs here and raises them there. And it overlooks the fact that there's not much reason for businesses to hire new workers if there's no increase in demand for their goods in services. Still, you have to start somewhere and every little bit helps.
What would help more is restructuring the entire tax code and (here comes that term conservatives hate) redistributing wealth. There are a lot of things we can do that while still progressive would actually make it more fair. Switching from tax deductions to tax credits is one.
Tax deductions lower your taxable income and are equal to the percentage of your tax bracket. Tax credits provide a dollar-for dollar reduction of your tax liability. Deductions favor the wealthy. Credits make everyone equal. Here's an example. Mortgage deductions work on percentages. The more expensive the house, the bigger the deduction. A tax credit of $5000 (or whatever) would be the same for everyone.
Same goes for taxing capital gains at the same rate of regular income. I've never understood why money made from investing gets taxed lower than money made from working. Income is income.
Even Reagan understood that.
Those are just a couple of things we could do. But it requires recognizing the problem isn't a lack of wealth. It's the way the wealth is concentrated. Yeah I know, it's "theft" but what good is a system that creates wealth and increasingly concentrates it at the top while the majority gets poorer? I've heard the arguments that well, anyone can get wealthy, it just requires work, but I don't buy it. There's a reason why they're only 1%. The harsh reality is, most of us are not going to become part of the 1% no matter how hard we work.
That's why "We built that" was so amusing. Most of us don't own businesses. We work for someone else. And you'll notice they trotted out business owner after businesses owner talking about how they "built that" and not once did they bring out someone who worked for any of them that helped "build that" too. They were oblivious to fact that they didn't "build that" by themselves. And it shows in the way wages have stayed flat for so long.
Anyway, I'm all for capitalism. But everything in life requires a balance. Let's use some common sense and temper it with that evil thing called socialism.