First off it's not a court system, it's a private enterprise.
Secondly, the only evidence we know so far is 11 of the 12 Patriots balls (and none of the Colts 12 balls) had been deflated.
Third off, there is a major issue with the integrity of the sport here. The Patriots essentially have been caught cheating AGAIN.
The only reason the NFL is holding off judgement on this is because they chose to protect the investors rather than the game itself. People paid MILLIONS for 30 second ads, these people would be pissed if a back up QB had to go to the game resulting in less people watching.
Honestly, it's not a 100% but it pretty much is almost right there that this happened and we won't know until judgement passes but this cannot be tolerate in a professional sport. The fact not only that it's outright cheating and directly affects the outcome of e very game it happens in (not saying they would've lost the game, but it does have direct effect on it) and that this Patriots Team has a
.500 post season record with NO SUPER BOWLS since they were last caught cheating (and have rumors to have been cheating in all 3 close Super Bowls they won) they need the book thrown at them in order to maintain integrity of the sport if found guilty. The penalty needs to be larger and more significant than the Peyton penalty because at least his crime had no immediate impact on the actual integrity of the game.