I guess we have to agree to disagree on the gaw thing.
In my mind gaw was kaw designed to reward more aggressive play and more spending. There were also some mechanical tweaks to make the game less complex. If it was a growing game, it would have been released on multiple formats and been updated etc.
Kaw is wonderful because there are many ways to play it. Osw is alive and well and always has been. Ee while flawed does provide a controlled pvp format with rewards. Or you can just eb, build and grow if that play style suits you. The fact that osw n strips provide an ongoing threat encourages players to band together. As they band together into groups. Conflicts arise and the price of war is paid. It's all very organic and rather beautiful.
After the major alliances have had at each other for a while, their resources are spent and its time to build and grow for the next big conflict. Again. A lovely cycle. But if you engineer the mechanics so that winning osw is the most efficient way to grow, you encourage a never ending conflagration that consumes players and kills your game. As the free to plays and less actives leave the game and the big spenders and actives exhaust themselves against each other. We saw this in FC and gaw.