You can't make it battle list only. Servers can't tell the difference from hits on Battle list, off of WC, off of Forums, or off of clan CR.
Lb players have mid sized alts, I know this from experience. Once upon a time a player named Bomanator had a DNH banner. I never thought much of it when I bought his ally. That night it was rebought by him and I hot farmed out of 20b as "tax" Lessoned learned, you never know who has alts out there
One problem, someone of my size could just find someone and kick the ass out of them even if they are inactive
Support. It could generate tons of income for ATA IMO. It could cause OSW and many osw clans 1. Run b2b hte for pots, strip funds, towers, etc. 2. Large strips require xtals 3. For a plunder bonus, one might EE to get EE levels, thus using xtals 4. Not only xtals on strips, but someone might use a few on hte if the clan allows it for extra funds
Note: i wasnt thinking of giving HTE money. I was meant to imply that it sounded fun and added some extra argument as to how adding more pvp could generate income for ATA.
Poor Bomanator, but that's another story. Anyway, I love this idea. It's a hunt made for everyone that everyone can enjoy. Support!
support but i want elves dropped not snowballs, elf throwing is all the rage or jingle bells, because who doesnt love those jingle jingle
Special Epic Battle Put a santa hat on Jorathe the Silver and insted of attacking avalanches like in one of the Jorathes ebs (because people always attack avalanches) scout out presents and attack evil grinches. Fantastic idea. I even suprise myself!
A possible solution to the lb domination... When you successfully scout someone you get a percentage chance to succeed on an attack - based upon relative size and number of troops available of both yourself and the other kingdom. If the win chance is above say 50% then the chance of stealing snowballs significantly decreases. Not entirely sure of the mechanics of the win percentage (eg if it counts equip or bfa) but at least it might solve both the lb and alt farming issue.
Hmm yeah lb would be win no matter what. Redstar can hit a huge portion of Kaw. Where as only half a percent can hit him. And besides if you have an alt (lb has atleast 3 each) you could have one farm another and main would hit that one, guaranteed drop. To many flaws.
Support...I think... The only problem I see is that people would still lose gold as a result of the snowball farming... I might not care if you take my snowballs, but the 20b you also took in the process is gonna be a bit frustrating. Also, I could see the pvp alliances (like kotfe et al) having a huge advantage since people would be scared to hit them.