The_Philosopher
Well-Known Member
These days I see a lot of concern about the future popularity of Kaw. Issues with promotion overload, power creep, and attracting new players. It is nice to see we still have a community that is passionate about the game. In this thread I won’t be offering solutions; instead I hope to give insight in what ATA is thinking and the company’s attitude to the game as a whole.
In the early fall of 2013, I had a business trip to Vancouver. I had one free afternoon that trip, and seeing that ATA was near the downtown core, I emailed ahead and booked a visit. I’d like to offer my insights about that trip, not in order to either condemn or defend ATA, but to give insight into what makes them do what they do.
First of all, let me say they treated me royally. They were outgoing, respectful, and generally interested in my opinions. In the end they even gave me a free ATA umbrella.
Now let’s get down to what I learned and what it means to us.
1. There are only 4 people who work full time on Kaw.
We should feel lucky. There are only two who work full time on PIMD. Sure they use the occasional artist from time to time, but they vast majority of ATA’s 70 employees are working on new projects.
Now part of this makes sense. Kaw is in many ways a finished product. Creating a product takes much more time than managing a finished one.
2. Yet Kaw is still expected to bring in the lion’s share of the revenue.
In spite of the skeleton staff, Kaw is still the bread winner for ATA. That means the primary focus of the those four people is to monetize the game. This is why some of the little things never get fixed. While it might be nice to get a better pm system for the PC version, LB reform, or more detailed clan rankings, none of this will make any money for ATA. If it is not going to help the positive clash flow, why bother?
This was driven home to me when the two composers there took me into the sound room to listen to their soundtrack for S.M.A.S.H. I told them how much I liked it, but I also told them how much I disliked KaW’s theme music. They agreed with me that Kaw’s music was fairly lame, but rewriting KaW’s music was not a priority Which brings me to my next point.
3. ATA’s leadership is bored with maintaining KaW and more interested in creating new games.
When I met the founder in 2013, he was a nice guy and all, but he was far more interested in discussing my opinions about S.M.A.S.H. rather than my thought about KaW. I quote, “What interests me the most is finding the next Kaw”. Looking for new projects is all fine and dandy, but it alienates the users of the old products. I have to admit though, S.M.A.S.H. in 2013 looked like an awesome game-ATA were no slackers- but the fact is I prefer the Medieval kingdom war setting over the whole monster movie scenario of S.M.A.S.H.. Despite all its cool music and graphics, it just wasn’t that appealing to me.
Not to be too critical, ATA leadership seemed far too occupied in creating new games and not interested enough to maintaining the ones they have, which is a bit of a shame. Of course this was 2013, hopefully they will discover the beauty of KaW and restore it to former glory.
These are the big revelations from my ATA tour. I will go into more minor details in the next installment next week.
Philo
In the early fall of 2013, I had a business trip to Vancouver. I had one free afternoon that trip, and seeing that ATA was near the downtown core, I emailed ahead and booked a visit. I’d like to offer my insights about that trip, not in order to either condemn or defend ATA, but to give insight into what makes them do what they do.
First of all, let me say they treated me royally. They were outgoing, respectful, and generally interested in my opinions. In the end they even gave me a free ATA umbrella.
Now let’s get down to what I learned and what it means to us.
1. There are only 4 people who work full time on Kaw.
We should feel lucky. There are only two who work full time on PIMD. Sure they use the occasional artist from time to time, but they vast majority of ATA’s 70 employees are working on new projects.
Now part of this makes sense. Kaw is in many ways a finished product. Creating a product takes much more time than managing a finished one.
2. Yet Kaw is still expected to bring in the lion’s share of the revenue.
In spite of the skeleton staff, Kaw is still the bread winner for ATA. That means the primary focus of the those four people is to monetize the game. This is why some of the little things never get fixed. While it might be nice to get a better pm system for the PC version, LB reform, or more detailed clan rankings, none of this will make any money for ATA. If it is not going to help the positive clash flow, why bother?
This was driven home to me when the two composers there took me into the sound room to listen to their soundtrack for S.M.A.S.H. I told them how much I liked it, but I also told them how much I disliked KaW’s theme music. They agreed with me that Kaw’s music was fairly lame, but rewriting KaW’s music was not a priority Which brings me to my next point.
3. ATA’s leadership is bored with maintaining KaW and more interested in creating new games.
When I met the founder in 2013, he was a nice guy and all, but he was far more interested in discussing my opinions about S.M.A.S.H. rather than my thought about KaW. I quote, “What interests me the most is finding the next Kaw”. Looking for new projects is all fine and dandy, but it alienates the users of the old products. I have to admit though, S.M.A.S.H. in 2013 looked like an awesome game-ATA were no slackers- but the fact is I prefer the Medieval kingdom war setting over the whole monster movie scenario of S.M.A.S.H.. Despite all its cool music and graphics, it just wasn’t that appealing to me.
Not to be too critical, ATA leadership seemed far too occupied in creating new games and not interested enough to maintaining the ones they have, which is a bit of a shame. Of course this was 2013, hopefully they will discover the beauty of KaW and restore it to former glory.
These are the big revelations from my ATA tour. I will go into more minor details in the next installment next week.
Philo