xX__Tha-Don__Xx said:
If your case is based on Pilmer and volcanos, you don't have a case.
"How climate change sceptic Ian Plimer dodges valid criticism
On page 413 of the book he repeats the old canard that "Volcanoes produce more CO2 than the world's cars and industries combined". It was a claim that he famously made in a recent interview by Justin Webb on the BBC's Today programme. Webb did not challenge him, but I put it to Plimer that the website of the US Geological Survey (USGS) states: "Human activities release more than 130 times the amount of CO2 emitted by volcanoes."
Plimer's response was that the USGS is only talking about terrestrial volcanoes and has not incorporated CO2 produced by undersea eruptions at mid-ocean ridges. "85% of the world's volcanoes we neither see nor measure," he said. "They leak out huge amounts of carbon dioxide... That does not come into the USGS figures nor does it come into the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change's figures."
If he is right, that is an astonishing omission and an oversight that would force a huge reassessment of climate science.
But when I check with the USGS they are very explicit. According to volcanologist Dr Terrence Gerlach:
I can confirm to you that the "130 times" figure on the USGS website is an estimate that includes all volcanoes – submarine as well as subaerial ... Geoscientists have two methods for estimating the CO2 output of the mid-oceanic ridges. There were estimates for the CO2 output of the mid-oceanic ridges before there were estimates for the global output of subaerial volcanoes.
These are just three of the many criticisms that have been made about Heaven and Earth. Plimer dismissed them as "pathetic nit-picking" but if his book is influencing politicians and public opinion around the world then I think his arguments deserve close scrutiny.
He likes to argue that his position on global warming is dismissed by mainstream scientists because they are part of a "fundamentalist religion" and a "mafia". In fact, his arguments are rejected because they are just plain wrong."
http://www.theguardian.com/environment/ ... ian-plimer