When it comes to the men in blue, more than three names come to mind but I'll name a few.
The obvious one being chocolate, he's done a serious job for the community, serving as KaW's stat manager. Tracking EB drops to guides for nooblets, he's the top dude for the Aqua color.
Following chocolate, I would probably roll with Prime. He's like a toned down version of Ashes, with a more 9 plus booby reputation he sets a high standard when it comes to foruming wit and humor.
And lastly, I predict HTLFreak, he's done a lot when it comes to EE in the past, and continues updating his work at time goes on. He's dedicated to his work, respect.
I would roll with Ashes, but his history with the dev team probably nullified any chances of him being officially recognized as a rad member of the community

however, he's more than earned the title to most of the individuals who have seen his posts and remarks both on forums and in-game.
When it comes to the mod team, I believe Ashes would be a great choice, because I think he's got one of the best understandings of the ToU considering his experience with the law
If Titan were to agree to return to the mod team, which I don't forsee (but you never know

), he's dedicated to making the community a better place.
And last, I can totally see the OP himself turning into one of the grinches. His activity of forums would be great to the mod team.
There's my two cents.