Some very interesting points on here, however I would like to say a few things since we are all throwing in our opinions.
First, I would like to say that VK is more than just being helpful, it's even in the achievement description "..has a positive influence..." so just being helpful, like Chocolate(not saying he doesn't deserve it, he does) would be ignorant.
I think that in terms of positive influence, Chocolate, Ashes, and Kezzer should be recognized. I think being a positive influence means you are active in both forums and WC and do your best to contribute. As for Ashes, I don't see why he couldn't be VK if willy was a VK(love you willy) unless he didn't want it.
Second, let me start on WCs and such. I agree some should get recognition. However, as pointed out by Daphnia, most aren't very active outside of the clan they are in which causes a problem of whether or not they could ever be recognized. Maybe the making of third award, for the best and most helpful and teaching war commanders and PvP in the game would help?
Third, I think many people get overlooked do to there lesser activity in the public and are more behind the scenes players and they should be recognized, I mean, cmon, somebody would've had to suggest them at some point right!?
Which leaves me with this, that positive, active, and helpful are the three aspects which should be looked at carefully when appointing VK/Mods in the future.
<3Snoopy