is the game shrinking or growing?

Omar said:
House if people arent loyal over an eb they wouldnt have been loyal otherwise..

The issue is the cultivating of new players. Very quickly, they can be drawn over to the dark side. Often these types of fast growing accounts burn out and either give up the game or run off and get as much eq as they can as fast as they can. Back when we ran a sub, people were more willing to learn how the game and the mechanics worked. That bred loyalty, learning and growing through the ranks. This culture is now nonexistant....i've posted an idea to refresh the eaely game, but i quickly realized the devs have no interest in doing anything except turn on "event autopilot" which drives revenue. Nothing wrong with that from their perspective since events bring in cash, but its death to the "community" of players that were the heart of the game....
 
The devs care less about new players, and more about lb players, simply because these are the people who keep spending large sums on the game. Once even these players quit however, and without the influx of new players, the game will start declining at a faster rate than it is now.
 
I think the biggest problem is, is that the devs keep introducing new lands, new buildings etc... these new lands/buildings can only be upgraded by one currency: gold. Therefor you can only grow stronger if you make a lot of gold, once you've made a lot of gold you can start upgrading again and at the end, devs will again introduce a new piece of lands and/or buildings because the BC players get bored.

So what if, players can actually grow stronger by adding another currency. (I'm just starting to brainstorm from here, no waterproof idea has been thought out) - A new set of lands will be introduced and lets call them 'Lands of Terror', these lands are not a set of 25 lands, nor a set of 50 lands, but are infinite! - Lets say, 'battle wins' are a currency. So, once you are in a war, or a pvp arena (e.g. 1v1 or 2v2 etc.) you fight your opponents, and if you win that fight you can upgrade a building or explore a new land. But once you lose that fight, a building can be downgraded or destroyed or a land will turn unexplored and you'll have to fight another battle or war to get it back again. This way, no gold is needed to upgrade, no HTE is needed but just the mechanics and tactics of the game and how you understand will make you grow stronger and beat even more opponents.

Of course this idea is far from waterproof, a lot of exploit can occur, match-ups might suck. But I'm sure many more warriors who are now hitting HTE will enjoy this and start warring so match-ups might be more easily made by devs.

You can add a lot of interesting stuff to this war (PvP arena) idea, such as: irregular regen times; in a war your soldiers might regen after 4 minutes instead of 5 minutes.

One last thing: maybe it's cool if players can invite each other to a battle arena and the other player can accept or decline their invitation. If the invitation is accepted they go to 1v1 each other for lets say 1 hour (can be determined by the players themselves), after 1 hour, the player who won most attacks, steals, assassinations, scouts gets a explored land. The player who lost, gets an explored land unexplored or a building downgraded or destroyed.

I've got many more ideas about this but just too lazy to type them all out.

This idea can be worked out by community totally and worked towards perfection, I'm sure you all are creative enough. I hope I have inspired some of you creative people.


~ Happy Kawing

Bad
 
_____Imma__F__Y__T__R_________ said:
Can anyone show me these statistics that everyone continues to reference?

Troll machine posted a pic on a thread i cant remember, showing the decline of kaw in top gross apps after hte was implemented. Wish I could find the pic.
 
To begin I did not read all posts. That being said I believe the game to be stagnant. However their are 1500 plus at the top that are extremely active many new accounts start and soon after the addition begins the realization that 3 and 4 year players still are not BC. This causes the addition that we all experienced to wane much faster.
 
Bad: I actually agree on new lands and catering to bc players...

I get it, it's hard to satisfy everyone, but even at my peak activity I couldn't keep up with buildings.

I don't spend the money lb players do, but I have supported the app...I think others would be inclined to do so more if the game didn't FEEL like it was catered to the top 5% of players.

I feel the "golden age" of Kaw was the first 18 months or so, when a player could actually make serious headway and build up some BFA in addition to buildings, and really learn the ins and outs of mechanics...OSF were mostly secret/private, and the clan mentality was really the cornerstone of the game.

Those days are gone, but I sincerely believe that the devs should support those types of bonds, because that's what built the game. Not gold or glory as much as comraderie.

Events of the last 24 hours have proven this, as Rusted, a former clanmate of mine fought to preserve the legacy of his old home.

I could give you hundreds of examples of relationships forged with people I still get messages from today from 2,3,4,nearly 5 years ago. That's the game's foundation.

As far as the retention of new players, that is a serious issue.

I'll take the time in the next few days to a week to re-hash the ideas put forward on this thread and put together a comprehensive list of suggestions that we (the folks I'm working with) will discuss.

If anyone legitimately wants to add to the discussion, my pm is easy to find, and I'll happily add friend or foe in a 3rd party app.

Thanks for your time,

~j
 
↑ years of hard work and money spent by all players. Think about the thousands that have been spent by individuals. And then 'poof' , it'll all be gone ?
 
III___Obi-Wan-KiNG-Nobi___III said:
A lot of good ideas suggested so far. I pretty much read each and every post. The Question is did the Apes at ATA read it? And if they did, were they able to comprehend it?

A recent example. We have been doing RoTWB a lot these past few weeks, not a single seal dropped. So I sent a feedback to ATA asking what happened to these free seals from RoTWB. At least 1 used to drop in about 20-30 RoTWBs. And pat comes the reply from support team that they drop in Warbeast, Haunt, TGL, SR, TSG and are chance based. I know they are chance based but what the hell happened to RoTWB not dropping anymore is what I asked them again and got the same reply again. I gave up.

The point is, their own staff hasn't a clue how to comprehend what is being asked in clear English and reply accordingly. I don't see how they can make out anything out of all these sentences in this thread.

The game is going downhill for sometime now. I can actually pin point this to when it started a drastic decline. The time HTE was introduced as a 'Special Limited Time' EB. Everyone loved the extra gold and we all did a few, from the free seals and then from the bought seals, it was a 'Special Limited Time EB'. And then it became a full time EB. And people with $$s figured out new ways to exploit it. Someone came up with the idea of making a HTE clan. Another dude came up with an idea of giving the sealer all Ph1 items. And then, to one up that dude, another guy started a clan with both phases to the sealer.

And boom, everyone who had seals ran to these clans. There goes yøür clan loyalty. And along with that, out went, through the window, the door, the chimney and every other place, your stronger players who wanted to grow rapidly. I saw 3 month old accounts build complete with no equipment, just by running max xtals and seals every day. Discouraging for all others who did not have means and resources to buy their way to better stats. I know there are whales in every game. But you do not give such a short, quick fire, $$ based route to complete your build. It discourages your loyal players who have been with you for a long time. Most of these, so called, whales will run to newer and greener pastures aka other games. They have nothing more to achieve. And the others will horde allies. Are they capable promoters of the game? That is a question left to answer.

The discouragement in this game is much wider spread. Why? Because these, so called whales can smack you everyday non stop with max xtals while doing HTE. In other games, these whales do not have a direct impact on your growth. You can happily go about building your kingdom/village/empire. Those games do not allow 1 whale to farm you into extinction based on $$s. This game has no safety measure in that regards.

What this does then, is it leaves you in a hole so deep you can never crawl out of. Dare you hire an ally from these whales. They will farm you till you reset. The game can do nothing to prevent this from happening. So one whale with unlimited $$s has a wide spread impact on all other tiny fish in this game.

See the BIG picture? The Devs did not see it when they decided to retain HTE as a permanent EB. Now the smaller guys cannot run anywhere and hence the discouragement. You can say all you want about, stand up, fight back, keep hitting. For what? You don't expect a 5-8M CS guy doing a teeny weeny bit of a damage to these massive 40-80M CS guys. More discouragement. See what I was talking about 1 Big $$ whale having a major wide spread impact on smaller fish.

OSWs these days are:- Smack HTE, strip, smack HTE. The guy who is stripped does 1 HTE and Boom, back to max plunder. A few days of seals and HTE and back to a few Tril in allies again. The 'Real Sense' of discouragement from strips is no longer there. Earlier it used to take time and effort to manage enough gold to get back to MP. It used to take time and effort to build strip funds. Now it is a matter of a few days you can count on your finger tips to amass enough gold to strip a clan.

So after all this mess. The whales have tons of gold and BFA. Now what do we do with that gold. Boom, out come new lands and buildings that cater to these guys. More discouragement for the smaller guys. There is no end in sight to this. One mistake leads to another. The problem ATA has is all due to their lack of common sense in planning out a well paced game play catering to a wider player base instead of $$ spenders. They only catered to the BIG guys and are stuck in a spot of bother they can't get out of. Fix the hit range, Oh Noes the Big whale is mad as he cannot hit smaller guys. Remove HTE, Oh Noes the Big whale is mad as he cannot make gold that fast. The game is not run by ATA anymore. They gave it in the hands of the few LB and $$ spenders. And they can't do anything about it unless they want to upset them and lose their source of income(a lot of examples are floating where ATA looks the other way when people raise questions on accounts). Whose fault is it. The community kept shouting from the roof tops all this while. And now even if ATA tried( Frankly they haven't the balls to do it) they can't fix this mess.

Well that was a wall of text. I did try to space it out. Shorter version:-

- Fix the mess created by 'Limited Time Special EB called HTE'.

- Fix the Hit Range.

- Fix your events, where, if you aren't doing HTE, you have to friggin' do 4 EBs to make the Special Item. Why can't the top most EB in every tier drop all 4 event items. I am sure these small guys will still not catch up to your Whale doing b2b HTE. But at least you will have a happier player base with a realistic chance at some nicer equipment from the upper rack instead of the bottom leftovers.

- Give the players some rewards for loyalty. Those free nobs and xtals from quests run out before you are HLBC.

- The EBs need a revamp. Warbeasts was from the 18th century. Remove the old EBs and put up some newer EBs for the smaller guys.

- Increase the EB plunder for all EBs in the lower tiers. We are into the Abyss lands and the payout from Warbeasts, all the way to A Cold Calling is still in the 'High Lands Released' era.

- Revamp your PvP side of the game. Think out of the box. Increase the payout. Let inferno/aqua/BB drop randomly from hitting others in PvP. Give a bonus when you KO someone. It doesn't have to be what I said, you can figure it out. But work, don't just sit on your ass watching people buy SOD.

- Give new players max plunder spell to help them out. Or float some bogus tiny allies in the market for them to hire.

- Revamp clans. Increase clan spots. Put up some clan stats, for say, OSW rankings, opponents hit, EB speeds on clan page. Just mumbling here, but you get the drift.

- Get rid of 25B to make a clan. There are so many noobs making failing clans that drive half of your new players to the woods before they even understand how this game works.

Listen to the people and pull your heads out of the rear ends of your so called '$$ whales'. If you want this game to survive you cannot have half your community dissatisfied. No business ever survived sitting on their ass looking at the $$ bills coming in. 1 dissatisfied customer will drive 10 away. And that is what has been happening. You created a mess, fix it before your cash cow is gone. People will find another means to entertain themselves when this game is gone. Everyone does. We are still here because there are aspects of this game which aren't found anywhere else and because of friends we have made here.

There is an issue and everyone is telling you that there is one. Why can't you Apes come out of the woods and address the players? That road map went so far up your rear end while looking at SOD sales that even Kaw_Com can't see it when he ducks his head there while we tell him what is wrong with the game.

- Android still does not have game sound like iOS.
- Everytine to you go to someone in the CR and come back you are sent to the top of clan roster in Android.
- Go to Clan Events-EBs and search for an EB, scroll through 10 pages. Find a clan running it, click on clan to see if they have a spot, come back to EB search. And Eureka! You have been sent to page 1 again. Now I have do the damn thing all over again. Why can't you put an EB search by Name.
- Can't see troop and spy %ge in iOS. So if I want to unload to 60% of troops and spies, I need to get a calculator to do the maths. You can see it on android.
- Can't copy from clan page on Android. You can copy in iOS.

I am just pointing a few random things here that would make the gaming experience better. These have been pointed out a 100 times. But only if the Apes can get to work on it. There are a lot more. 5 years into the game and we are still trying to get the basic things rectified. God bless!
 
Respect Joe, what started with a 6 words forum thread that I thought would just create some polemics and be locked quickly, grew into an excellent thread with a lot of food for thought. Well done.

The player base seems to be shrinking, if I judge it by the activity of the wc I´m in. I do however see quite a few new players joining, which looks positive.

I do think that Obi has said most what could be said about some shortcomings of the game and their impact on the player base. A few of his points are excellent and are some that struck me too.

- Increase the EB plunder for all EBs in the lower tiers. We are into the Abyss lands and the payout from Warbeasts, all the way to A Cold Calling is still in the 'High Lands Released' era.

This in my opinion is one of the best analysis I´ve seen. A few years ago, clans were doing hauntings day and night and most clans were doing it as cash cow. It´s an easy eb, that paid well during the Highland era. It never got replaced by another easy eb paing well for the HF or Abyss era, but the new cash cows are SS, TS, AFF (next to HTE) for clans able to finish those. And there you have a problem. Clans around clan rank 200 with less than 2/3rds of active members won´t be able to do those. Either they rely on HTE to keep their players satisfied, or they face an exodus of their large players towards top 20 LB clans. You basically managed to create a depletion of big players in midsized clans and those are slowly dying.

Gwen also made very accurate observations.

In the past, large accounts (HLBC, vets,...) were easier to be found in academies as they didn´t sacrifice that much in growth. Ambush was an excellent eb as it permitted newbies as well as build complete players to hit it with a very decent plunder payout. Compared to haunting, one didn´t lose that much hitting Ambush. Honestly, nowadays you almost have to be Mother Theresa to stay in an academy past 10 or 20m cs. Adjustment of the plunder curve on lower tier ebs might be the solution, but it needs to be carefully thought out.

Plenty of other things come into my mind, like additional equipment drops in those low tier ebs, new lower tier ebs (not sure about this, as newbies shouldn´t know the old ones anyway), double plunder promo ebs (though you may argue that the BR ebs kind of took that over and created a bit more variety in ebs running). Oh yes, really get rid of those "gather 4 kind of items" events, it´s just painful. I would prefer them to be just activity based (with HTE having a larger payout, sure, why not).

I do think that it is also of our own responsibility to try to retain the newbies joining. I like the implementation of the "new" spell as well as the wc update, but we as players can´t rely only on those mechanisms to do magic. We have to approach those players. Volleying them to billions is all nice, but it doesn´t really help them find their way in this game. I rarely volley new accounts, but I try to give one or two building tips as well to direct them to some academy (thanks Daphnia for that thread) by walling them. I guess that´s still an old reflex from my days as academy admin and owner, I somehow miss those...

The main aspect of this game that all keeps us sucked in, is the social one. Compared to other games, we have a fantastic community, let´s use it to keep this game alive.
 
The task force has been all abuzz the last few days with ideas and the like, and we'd like to share them with the community:

Hitting the high notes:
-Player retention (new and existing),
-Focus on clan unity and system,
-Expanding plunder for academy level eb,
-Expansion of quest system,
-More developed tutorial,
-Addition of max plunder to new user spell,
-Removal of new player volley announcement,
-Changes to hit range for non system-war pvp,
-Improved interface,
-and increased reward for pvp

Quite a few players receiving consistent support from the community have recently been added to the conversation aimed at creating a better gaming experience for the community.

Please keep up the good work and let your voices and ideas be heard.

~j

Special thanks to Obi, Frog, and Sir_Misfit for their focus and expansion on initial ideas, and to some iG jackhole for driving the conversation. ;)
 
Glad we have a task force on it, good job.
I remember that suggestion thread from Killzone in the past, that was one nice thing too.

I agree on most of your points except for one: the removal of the volley announcement in wc. I might have been one of those that came up with this idea, as well as the newbie spell on some tutorial revamp thread and once it came live I suddenly was extremely sceptic. It didn't seem to achieve what I thought it would.

Sure, it adds to the depletion of low cost allies, but this was the case even before its implementation. A few players already were scanning for low priced allies and volleying them up. A new mp solution for newbies could solve the associated problem imo.

Nowadays, when I catch a newbie telling me he can't keep an ally in his hiring range, I advise him to play the volley game by just using those wc announcements. In fact, I do think it's quite effective to get enough cash to buy that first ally that sticks more than 1 hour.
 
Kassio,

Apologies for the late reply, but realistically, the wc advert destroys the ally market as a whole.

It overpriced all allies, especially new players who've pretty much only finished the tutorial. I'm not going to say it's unfixable, but it does flood the market with heavily overpriced inactive allies thereby making the market unattainable for new players and in many ways removing a valuable teaching element for many new players and creating a larger disparity of new and established players.

While yes, many can play the wc vollies, it negates low-level vollies that have long been the lifeblood of training clans and puts that gold out of reach by putting a "free money" sign in wc.

Furthermore, we end up with hundreds of inactive accounts with no intent to grow that could eventually cost current active players billions as they're reset, which could, imo, lead to further player defection and frustration.

Again, no offense intended, but others, along with myself, feel that there are other ways to effectively grow and retain the player-base.
 
IIlII-D-IllIl-A-IlllI-N-IIIll said:
Why don't they make a new server then? Everyone can start again.

In addition to the original response, this idea simply changes the power-brokers in the game economy short-term, and has little long-term benefit. It's been done 3 times.
 
Back
Top