First and foremost, I just want to say, I REALLY enjoyed this format. Not that it is something I'd want to do every time, nor do I think it'll remain as 'pure' as this original test was (people always find a way to abuse and ruin the simple fun for others) however, I do think this is something you should add to your arsenal of war variations, be it an event that runs only a few times a week or even an alternate sign up that runs right along side the normal clan vs clan structure, so players have a choice and can do whatever they fancy at the time.
The balance of the rosters was perfect. I know a few people have mentioned structuring it like a draft, where the roster appears more spread out in terms of build size, however, my issue with this is the probability of inactives. It is almost inevitable in this type of format to have a fully active roster, you are bound to have 2-3 and that's fine, as the enemy roster will have roughly the same. With a 'balanced' roster style, if your inactives fall on the higher end of the power spectrum, while the enemies fall on the lower, now you are fighting with a significant handicap. Further, the fact I could essentially hit everyone was exciting, it gave me something to do all the time, instead of Koing my 'x' amount of possible targets, then waiting for them to come out of pin; not that this is a huge problem in normal wars, regen is important obviously, was just exciting to always have to be on your toes and spamming those out of pin.
Many people may disagree with me on this, however, I really enjoyed the short set up time. One of the BIG fears of many players prior to the war, was the possible obvious abuse of the pure spy mechanic and perhaps paying off an enemy PS so your whole team could just plunder them down. With this short set up time, at least for my clan (we were matched up with about 10 min til war started and put into a clan about 15 before) we hardly had time to get to know each other, let alone establish an organized plan of all hitting 1 paid off PS with troops but no one Koing spy wise.
I think it is extremely important that you either keep the pre match ups short OR, preferably, don't allow PS to war in this format.
Sure it might seem bias or unfair to pure spies, however, in the long run, I can almost guarantee you, they will be what ruins individual wars. A leak on your team is fine, as hits are limited, but an unlimited plunder pool is a different story. Simply give them the message that a pure tower build gets in normal wars and if people want to be a PS (which is a valid build by all means) keep to normal clan vs clan wars where the punishment from this type of behavior is never being allowed to war in that clan again and players can police this type of activity.
Finally, I noticed a number of people in this thread complaining that they have dedicated war builds and this style of war devalues their build in some way. I assure you, I 100% understand the sacrifices of having a dedicated build, I make 30 mil first hit on HTE without EE (which I'm sure is MUCH less than you big attack builds make) yet I've spent a rather large amount of money dumping seals and xtals to build up my BFA. Will less dedicated builds now have access to the same gear as me? Yes. Does this make my build any less useful in war? Not at all! In terms of CR yesterday, I was 13, so right in the middle of the pack, yet I was WR1, with 3 bil in plunder and 15 KO's, plus I wasn't taken down even once. You know who was right up there with me? The other war builds on both sides! If anything, this will begin to encourage more EB focused players to start converting into war builds (or at least semi war builds) as they will see players like you and me outperforming them every time, they wont be useless by any means, however, if there is a good reason for it, logically, people will start to do it.
________________________________________________________________________
On a side note, regarding the individual reward system that you were testing: I was worried when I read you'd get '1 egg per attack' that it literally meant you had to attack the players in order to get it and I think that was, in fact, the case. I had 120ish actions that were ALL either attacks or assassinates (I don't waste time scouting and I'm just used to not stealing because of 0 pot SH and big SDT, so kind of didn't even think of it this war.) With that being said, I only received twenty something eggs (I want to say it was 23, but I forget now.)
I can somewhat agree in not rewarding scouts, prevents people from just farming 'useless' actions, however, I'd like you to look into rewarding the other spy actions properly, as they are just as, if not more difficult to execute than attacks and contribute just as much to the war effort.