An interesting topic and one not likely to be easily agreed upon. I don't think the US is going to crumble any time soon. I also think that the question is asked in a partial way. I guess it would be more interesting to me to ask how well the average American will do over the next 40 years not just economically but in many other spheres: social, political, health, happiness, they all matter. The Scandinavian countries have most of us beat by a mile in terms of how happy people are living there.
Japan's economy has not grown very fast (or at all) in the past 20 years and yet people enjoy very high standards of living there.
Back to my argument though. One way of thinking about how well a country is doing for its citizens is to look at income distribution and/or the Gini Coefficient (the latter is used to measure income distribution).
so.... In the US this is the distribution by quintiles (fancy word economists use to say they measure what amount of income is split in each 20% of the population)
so as you can see the bottom 20% of the population has very little compared to the top 20%. If we reduced the income share of the top 20% from 51.2% to 50% (not much right?) and transferred it to the bottom 20% we would grow their income share by over 33% - pretty amazing.
That said the US is doing pretty badly in the OECD group in terms of its income distribution: only Mexico, Turkey and Chile are less equal.
Form your own opinion from the data.
About the US economy in more general terms: it still is huge, loss of basic low-tech manufacturing or not.
It will take some time for any other country to even come close. It is a different (but not terrible) story when we look at the GDP/Debt ratio. The US is climbing for sure
But here I would notice that much of that increase is due to the economic crisis and it is reflected throughout the world. There is no escaping as someone said that this is a globalized world where international trade is here to stay. And oddly enough a lot of countries run a balance of trade (BoT) deficit. that means that the spend more money importing than they gain exporting.
In fact the OECD country that has done the best in the last decade has been tiny Ireland - which had a 3.6B euros surplus in its BoT last year but this is a very specific economy where exports of pharmaceuticals account for 28% of the total value.
You often hear that the US has been obliterated by China in this trade competition. While there is some truth to the fact that China has done very well in its export-focused development strategy....
the problem may have been a shift in the nature of the economy where the structure of the economy changed towards a service orientation (which is generally easier to sell domestically than abroad). So, historically the US started running BoT in the 1980s, increased them as its economy moved more steadily towards services and took a nose-dive after the first Gulf War.
So, it may be much a different picture than the one OP painted, more granular: where some American dreams get shinier and better and richer and some other turn from dreams into nightmares.
Another point about the oil point. The US has been producing as much oil as Saudi Arabia for a fairly long time (it was an attempt to increase supply and lower prices). However it has what can be considered modest oil reserves.
The US is actually right behind Nigeria with a little over 33B barrels. the other issue with oil is that one should really look at it in terms of its connection to the rest of economic and political issues.
Anyways
In God we trust, all others bring data.