To be honest, I feel this is a knee-jerk reaction by the community in response to a very poorly implemented "solution" by kaw_com in response to the waves of players who did not want a 2 week period filled with heavy PvP.
There were a variety of ways to handle the situation, all of which were better than what they give. I'll even give you a couple at the end. But to remove all ability for a player to be hit is pretty much removing an essential function of the game. I feel its unfair. I feel that that fine print being included was a ridiculous decision. No player, for any penalty, should be able to enjoy immunity from one of the central player-interaction methods (and accountability method) in the game.
Want better ways to handle the situation? One was TROLL's. It's in his thread, look it up.
Another would be to run this like an elimination contest. You get 10 shards a day. On your first PvP hit, on ANYONE, you are guaranteed your 50 start-off shards as payment. You hit 0? You get a spell auto-cast on you that signals you are empty. If you really want to get out? Hit nobody, all you have to lose is 10 shards. How hard is it to lose 10 shards, really. 15 hits? 20? You can handle it.
I feel the main issue in the end is that people cannot be hit, period. I would honestly not be surprised if most people on the hit list are there because they unloaded on someone, then cast the opt-out spell. Said person they unloaded on comes online, finds 30 messages of various attempts, and tries to hit back. "Sorry, person has opted out, you can't hit them anymore". Reaction? "WTF?" Obviously, the very upset event player goes and throws the other guy's name on the opt out list. I've seen players who have the spell. Do I bother to put them on that list? No, waste of my time. If they had unloaded on me before they did? They'd already be up there.
There were any number of ways to handle the situation, and PvP immunity was not one that was high on the list.