IISPllO0lIKYllGUIlNllISHiPlI
Well-Known Member
kingdom_of_doom said:I highly doubt the gay marriage dispute will ever resolve between those in favor and those opposed, because while the arguments use the same word, "marriage," the perceived meaning of that word is fundamentally different on either side of the issue.
The conventional Christian "marriage" is essentially a pact between and man and a woman and God. In this view, marriage is a divine rite that cannot be ordained by God if it's convoluted with their idea of sin. Allowing gay marriage doesn't make sense at all in this view, because how can something that violates the principles of a belief system be sanctioned by that system? It's illogical.
That being said, those in favor of gay marriage see this as discrimination against homosexuals. Pro gay marriage doesn't mean a conventional Christian marriage (although I'm sure very many proponents of this exist), however. But it does mean marriage. Like in a church, by a priest. Why would somebody who is homosexual WANT to be married under a system of belief that labels them as hell bound sinners? I don't understand. That is exactly why Christians offer a "tax purposes" form of civil union instead of marriage, which is, of course, seen as more discrimination against homosexuals.
Essentially, I'm curious whether being pro gay marriage means forcing churches to allow homosexuals to be married under the same ceremonial rites as straight couples, or if it is another, equal but different form of marriage.
Let's not get into the topic of hypocritical adulterers and divorcees getting married. I personally think they shouldn't be able to violate their own beliefs, but just because they do doesn't mean that others should be able to also.
THIS is what I suck at explaining. The legal aspect of marriage affords a homosexual the same exact rights as a strait couple it just has no place in a religious group that doesnt accept it.. To my knowledge the only thing marriage rights really affect is insurance/taxes. Maybe lenders are allowed to lend with different guidelines to married couples as opposed to individuals/co-signers but Im not sure.