I agree, doom is likely to be more gore than anything; still, it looks friggin awesome. I guess it depends how easily you get scared from a video game... Or what scares you. I like games that 'keep me on my toes.' Fallout 4 has some catchy screenplay with ghouls that jump out etc.
Original deadspace was pretty creepy. That trailer game for silent hill that never came out was freaky too. Think it was called P.T. (Playable trailer)