Kezzer said:
I agree with what avatar's saying and they explain the reason for the gap so well. I have past experience moderating other games myself and part of that included forum moderation. The game itself was far more complicated than kaw and more often than not evidence was needed to be pulled together to punish players. This meant we had around 100 moderaters or more most of the time. Funnily enough even though in-game moderation was harder in this instance most people focused on that because that's the part that interested them the most and the split was caused by preference not due to a difficulty difference.
Kaw itself requires more mods and as has been said we need a couple extra people who can focus on the forums. Whether or not this means the revival of the forum mod is a different matter but overall I think it's clear why there is the lack of forum moderation. It's mostly because the forum community is only a small part of the game therefore expecting most mods to take part in it is too optimistic.
Not most mods, just some mods.
I can name on one hand the number of current mods I have seen in the forums. The number is even less for those who contribute frequently rather than popping in to lock something.
While, as Avatar said, I understand it's a lot of work - it is a job that needs to be done. If it is too much for the current moderators or they're not familiar enough with the forums or they're not interested in moderating forums, whatever it may be; someone needs to be appointed specifically to do it.
II-roni-II said:
There should be a new added catergory into forums for " Politics " .And it should stay there and not bump into A.T everytime it is written on. A.T should only be for light hearted and fun threads. I think ruggy and kezzer would make great all round forum mods / worldchat mods.i think a new colour should be added to show that they are a merger for both like gold or silver exclusive mod colours. And cheese i know you would favour your own circle of friends .So you shouldnt never be given mod title privilage of any kind.
This is actually an interesting idea and could be something for devs to think about.
However I think restricting it to only politics would be too narrow, maybe controversial issues would be more suitable. If this was to happen, it may lower the trolling and derailing content. Players would have to specifically hunt out a thread rather than having it right there in AT. Plus the players who are actually interested in such debates can look there.
One of the issues I see though, is what constitutes a controversial topic. Everyone's interpretation is different. Would it be restricted to off topic threads or KaW related also?
xXP_3X_Tz-ToXiCxZoNe-Tz_XP_3Xx said:
I agree with reinstating the forum mod position. Forum mods were able to keep the forums clean to an extent while also maintaining a peaceful balance for discussion.
After the forum moderator position was removed, it opened the door to all trolls/flamers.
Now, I see a lot of things that aren't allowed in forums happening and it just goes by unnoticed most times.
I actually read the forum rules to better understand what could and couldn't be said/done on a thread in order for the threads I posted to stay alive and not be locked. Now I see a majority of rules being broke in threads.
This alone has caused to me stop posting threads and commenting in forums.
It is disappointing that you no longer wish to post on forums. I imagine this is probably the case for others as well.
The forum community should be growing with players who can be positive, keep it civil and make it a good place to be. Instead, it's the trolling community that seems to be growing.
Avatar said:
I don't think forum mods will come back. There were a few things wrong with the program overall, mostly just that forum mods could only do stuff in forums. The fact that I can do both now is a lot better.
But, I do think there should be one or two mods that PRIMARILY look over forums. Like you said, Moose was our forum man. Drgn was next and I loved forums too, but neither of us were Moose. Now that he's gone there's definitely a gap. So I don't know what the solution is. Forum modding is no longer as convenient for me as game modding, but I try.
Was the problem of forums mods only being able to do things in forums a problem with the system or was it a problem with the people appointed? Honest question because players should know what they're signing up for when applying. Why was it really a problem though? If a player accepts the position knowing they can only do things in the forums then that was their decision? It doesn't enough of a reason to not have such a position.
I think if forum mod was reactivated, it needs to be made clear their powers lie solely within the forums. If they wish to be a game moderator, apply for that position instead. I imagine the boundaries are made clear when they apply for or are offered the position.
In any event, could it hurt to trial it again?
I think there is too little attention paid to the forums. Eventually it'll drive the positive forumers away.
I hope we will see you around more in the forums
