I've done Amnesia, I've also played every Fear game (no thanks to Cheese telling me), Dead Space. I don't do jump scare. And have you ever played Slender?
The game I never though was scary was dead space. Maybe it helped that I played alot so I'd be like something's gonna jump through this window and try to kill me kinda easy then.
I couldn't predict the alien thingies. I hate jump scare. If someone or something jump scares me, I will freak out.
Why ask how long I have left at MIT? Planning to pay me a visit? :3 Also, Dead Space is one of the most predictable jump-scare games ever.