The poetry wars sign up

Discussion in 'Fan Fiction' started by *lady-marian (01), Sep 25, 2010.

  1. Thanks Kimber. Your review gave me an idea lol. Yo LM, being defiant as I am, care for another bout lol. I'm really competitive lmfao.

    iZ
     
  2. I would vote with Marian. Zain you're concept had merit but you relied heavily on simile and descriptive rather than being experiential. In other words your poem told us about being lost rather than actually being an experience of being lost. Even more profound would be to cause the reader to experience being lost themeselves in the reading. Not an easy feat to be sure.

    Marian yours did more to express a first-person experience of being lost. I did find some of the metaphors to be a bit strained and you don't seem to trust your reader much. Seems like you want to give them everything rather than letting them discover themselves in your words. They leaving some of the meaning indeterminent.
     
  3. Dang auto correct. Last sentence should be "try" for first word not "they"
     
  4. Interested! Average skill
     
  5. Thanks EC. Though, I don't know who Zain is...

    iZ
     
  6. You told me the limits the sky
    Then you turned a blind eye

    My luminous glow started to fade
    Then I began to lose my way
    Serve only yourself, steal, destroy and cause disarray
    Family, friends and love, the prices I was willing to pay

    Less is not more
    When you want you take
    You neglected to guide me
    To correct my mistakes

    I've gained all the possessions I've ever desired
    But what will it mean when my life has expired?
    What first came free, now is lost
    And cannot be bought back at any cost
     
  7. Not sure if I covered the topic of greed properly and btw I'm female so stop saying 'he' and 'his'! :D
     
  8. Oh there you are Abi! Nice poem btw. Applause
     
  9. Oh sorry bout that
     
  10. Oh Abi that was awesome poetry! Can I take a shot at greed?
     
  11. Haha it's ok =)
     
  12. Should I post my poem again?
     
  13. Abi! Quite nicely done for short time to work! Nice turn of phrase at the end.

    Kimber I like how you take greed away from obvious ideas of possessions and turn it to greed for relations. However I think you got a bit muddy because 2nd half of poem seemed more about envy or jealousy than greed. While I agree they can certainly be related, I think the connection needs to be better developed in the text
     
  14. K this has nothing to do with anything I just like it!

    Caught

    I am caught.
    Caught by the restraints of the wind,
    The mountains, the grasses.
    Every living thing holds me,
    And I can not escape.
    The pain is harsh,
    A living fire in my soul.
    I cry out,
    But my cry is lost to the wind.
    I slump, defeated.
    I let my life slip away,
    Blown to the wind.
    My spirit, at last, is free.

    God that stinks!
     
  15. Yeah I did stray off subject a little.......... Bunny!
     
  16. Please tell me what u thought of my poem!
     
  17. The topic of your poem is nice but the very last line doesn't appeal to me.
     
  18. The whole death part? I'm trying out a new style of poetry, so I might drop that style later
     
  19. Dark poetry is nice sometimes. That and I'm pretty tired so I wasn't exactly paying attention.