Spirit of the Holidays Fan Art Finalists

Discussion in 'Past Events' started by [ATA]Grant, Jan 4, 2014.

?

Vote for your favorite entries! (Up to three)

  1. #1

    37 vote(s)
    17.5%
  2. #2

    12 vote(s)
    5.7%
  3. #3

    48 vote(s)
    22.6%
  4. #4

    22 vote(s)
    10.4%
  5. #5

    75 vote(s)
    35.4%
  6. #6

    12 vote(s)
    5.7%
  7. #7

    36 vote(s)
    17.0%
  8. #8

    75 vote(s)
    35.4%
  9. #9

    9 vote(s)
    4.2%
  10. #10

    14 vote(s)
    6.6%
Multiple votes are allowed.
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. Well I was curious, and so I went ahead and counted the votes from the poll and the amount of likes on facebook. Also for my own records to what devs come up as their results :p

    Image 1: 33 votes + 14 likes = 47
    Image 2: 12 votes + 4 likes = 16
    Image 3: 43 votes + 32 likes = 75
    Image 4: 19 votes + 12 likes = 31
    Image 5: 68 votes + 54 likes = 122
    Image 6: 11 votes + 3 likes = 14
    Image 7: 24 votes + 115 likes = 139
    Image 8: 72 votes + 25 likes = 97
    Image 9: 8 votes + 3 likes = 11
    Image 10: 14 votes + 1 like = 15

    1st Prize - Image 7
    2nd Prize - Image 5
    3rd Prize - Image 8


    These are NOT the official results, these are just what I tallied up. No idea how they are actually calculating the winners, or how many of the likes were made in time etc.
     
  2. I like image #7
     
  3. 7 Is my vote please .
     
  4. It is so blatantly obvious that this was a popularity contest... I'm sorry but if you compare image 7 to image 5 there is absolutely no comparison... Image 7 looks like it was colored with kids crayola crayons.
     
  5. That's why number seven is loved more. It also happens to resemble the feel of the holidays more than the other.

    How I actually got votes, I'll never know :lol:
     
  6. ^ That's exactly why I voted for 7. It made me happy and felt like it best represented the happiness of Christmas
     
  7. It has a yellow... I repeat a yellow, destroyer rock dude, foxes and other unidentified characters, as well as ice moths trapped in floating red bubbles. It's getting more votes because this individual rallied her/his fb friends. i.e a popularity contest. I rest my case 
     
  8. I just justified why I voted for 7. I don't even know who they are so don't give some bull crap that its a popularity contest. Take your hate elsewhere.

    Each drawing has a different level of drawing skill, but also each hold a completely different artistic style and perspective.

    Yes 5 has the best pencil work, but all entries have their positives. This was not a contest purely on w hay drawing looked the "coolest"
     
  9. and if it were just based on in game votes, then #8 would win. Would you also like to hate on that persons drawing too?
     
  10. The real question is why are the devs wssting time with this shitaki mushrooms and not changing the ebs and putting pvp rewards in
     
  11. They feel like trolling you.
     
  12. What is that yellow thing in #7 anyway? Not criticizing, but if it's something from an eb I haven't kept up with some of the newer ones so I'm curious.
     
  13. The yellow thing in number 7 is a gold version of Thorak.
     
  14. Honestly, I don't think it matters on who likes it or what not, it is voting, that's why they said vote for your opinion, and another thing is, all of them but 1,3,5,8,10 look like they were drawn up in about a few hours, while 1,3,5,8,10 look like they spent a lot more time on them. Look at 5 for example, that looks like it took forever to draw, even if it doesn't have colors. If something like 7 wins because "it won in voting because it had likes", then I would be quite suprised.
     
  15. I voted for 3,5,8 because the detail in them is so amazing, and it has a message sent out, I'm not a hater on 7, but I'm going to use it again as an example. 7 doesn't really have a theme, they just grabbed some moths and drew them along with what looks to be the No Mans Land guy in a Santa suit.
     
  16. I vote #8 mcarni
     
  17. How does it not have a theme? It's everyone out in the snow playing..
     
  18. Voting is now over. While you'll still be able to actually cast your votes in the above poll, and like the images on facebook, any new votes won't impact the outcome.

    We've noted down the numbers as they are at this moment, and will announce the winners tomorrow :)
     
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.