SHOULD towers drop plunder?

Vanessa said:
I'm not sure how much they drop plunder, but it should be a pretty small amount. People who war have a disadvantage because of their towers dragging down plunder, preventing them from growing.

Also, somebody who does ebs usually and wants to grow probably won't war because they need towers but don't want to sacrifice plunder.

It all matters on the % of plunder that is lost. A minuscule amount is not a big deal to most people.
When I've said this before, most people usually just tell me 'You can't have the best of both worlds'
 
_-xDA-HeLioSuRGe-RAx-_ said:
Personally i don't mind towers. In short they shouldn't increase or decrease plunder. The dedicated to a tower is not earning gold so its con is there.
thats what i think is the best option as well
 
IC_Spider570_IC said:
It is same thing as state and federal tax do we like or agree with it no but we pay it and adjust accordingly. My suggestion to you would be to do the same and play game as designed. No support
LOL it is a discussion thread what exactly are you not supporting?
Anyway, this game is open to improvement that is why devs have a special section in forums for new ideas :)
 
wtfamidoinghere said:
Plunder is achieved by sending your army out to attack and they bring back the loot basically. My tower doesn't leave my kingdom to attack. It stays home to defend. Why should it generate plunder. If anything perhaps you could gain plunder on a defence. But what army brings gold to attack?
 
Not sure if it's posted or not but towers to do not lower plunder. They are a building that does nothing but defend. The reason your plunder drops when adding a tower is because you remove a plunder making building, which is why it takes a plunge.
 
-_-III-SUNE-III-_- said:
@Goofy building towers actually do drop your plunder on existing buildings.



Incorrect. Allow someone who knows what he's talking about to clarify for EVERYONE

Prior to abyss towers did a few things..
They added to your static defense for either attack or spy. At the same time that they did this they lowered your POTENTIAL plunder, ie if you max a coe's where you once had a lookout tower your plunder goes UP. On top of taking away potential plunder, Hoarfrost, Highlands, and Lowlands all LOWERED existing plunder. Ie if you're making 200m a hit, unlock a land, and build a tower, on HL. Your plunder drops 15-20m. This is true for all lands except abyss. If anyone needs further explanation, pm me.



Edit: I just tested again, ORIGINALLY towers in all but abyss dropped plunder, apparently now they do not. This is good.
 
Nothing lowers plunder.

You either get plunder or you don't. Towers only "lower plunder" in the sense that they don't provide any offense so, logically they shouldn't and don't provide plunder.

Still doesn't stop half of KaW running around with half their cs in towers though. New meta: turtle and pretend that you like PvP.
 
BuTtNaKeD_-MaGiC-_TwlnKy said:
I kinda agree with alpha.

New/small accounts really get hit hard on plunder if they want to tower up for war.

I just want to point out that I purpose for this game is to grow bigger, then war. I find no reason to war with a small build but that's my opinion
 
ISS_CynderStryke_ISS said:
Nothing lowers plunder.

You either get plunder or you don't. Towers only "lower plunder" in the sense that they don't provide any offense so, logically they shouldn't and don't provide plunder.

Still doesn't stop half of KaW running around with half their cs in towers though. New meta: turtle and pretend that you like PvP.

Cyn, LL, HL and HF towers actually do decrease plunder

Like stated before, if a build a HF tower on an empty land then hit an eb, I would see my plunder drop. However, if I did the same for an abyss tower, my plunder would actually just stay the same
 
riceNramen said:
ISS_CynderStryke_ISS said:
Nothing lowers plunder.

You either get plunder or you don't. Towers only "lower plunder" in the sense that they don't provide any offense so, logically they shouldn't and don't provide plunder.

Still doesn't stop half of KaW running around with half their cs in towers though. New meta: turtle and pretend that you like PvP.

Cyn, LL, HL and HF towers actually do decrease plunder

Like stated before, if a build a HF tower on an empty land then hit an eb, I would see my plunder drop. However, if I did the same for an abyss tower, my plunder would actually just stay the same

Just tested with this newbie account. Three hits at full troops. One with one LL balanced building, one with no building, one with defense tower. Defense tower lowered plunder, and increased the lowered amount as I upgraded it. 20k~ at level 1 and 400k~ at max upgrade.
 
Tiny said:
riceNramen said:
ISS_CynderStryke_ISS said:
Nothing lowers plunder.

You either get plunder or you don't. Towers only "lower plunder" in the sense that they don't provide any offense so, logically they shouldn't and don't provide plunder.

Still doesn't stop half of KaW running around with half their cs in towers though. New meta: turtle and pretend that you like PvP.

Cyn, LL, HL and HF towers actually do decrease plunder

Like stated before, if a build a HF tower on an empty land then hit an eb, I would see my plunder drop. However, if I did the same for an abyss tower, my plunder would actually just stay the same

Just tested with this newbie account. Three hits at full troops. One with one LL balanced building, one with no building, one with defense tower. Defense tower lowered plunder, and increased the lowered amount as I upgraded it. 20k~ at level 1 and 400k~ at max upgrade.

Yup that's what I was saying if I didn't get the point across, thanks tiny!
 
Back
Top