School and Religion

lIlIxX-IW_Rio_IW-XxlIlI said:
IlIlIlIlI-Versa-IlIlIlIlI said:
Moose said:
Just as an interesting aside, many scientists are now coming to the conclusion that there must be a God. I won't use this platform to push who I think he is, and the people in the link below don't either.

That being said, if you have 17 min to play with, and you enjoy science, click on this link. Pay attention though, it moves fast and the information is not spoon fed.

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=4C5pq7W5yRM

Well something bad to create us. That is literally what a God is lol. The debate form this issue can only stem from whether it is actually the god from religious texts or just the creator of our universe. Hell we could just be some person's science experiment because there is a theory that we too could create our own Big Bang inside of a little flask that too creates a universe.


I've known about idealism for some time and the idea of a conscious, physical reality, is quite scary.


As interesting as that idea is..

It returns to the question of, if there is a god, who or what created them? And so on and so on.

I believe that the question of the start of the universe is a very difficult question to answer. But, we cannot simply assume that because an answer is hard to find, that it is the work of a god. Whenever man simply assumes that a god is the reason behind something, that is when man stops looking for answers. Thus, when we stop looking for answers, our scientific progress slows down.

I do not think that the amount of religious scientists is going up. It is going down, if anything. The percentage of youth that are becoming atheists is skyrocketing, and youth today are tomorrow's scientists.

I think that we don't know enough yet to try to answer the question of how the universe began. The question predates the answer. We don't even know of all the particles that exist in the universe (such as dark matter which is some sort of non-electromagnetic gravitational particle and dark energy which is a concept used to explain why the universe continues to expand)

My personal belief is that the universe is eternal, and goes through a several-billions-of years cycle. Maybe a new particle will be discovered that proves that in several billion years that the universe will start collapsing in on itself. Maybe there is more than just our universe out there. We don't know. We may never know. We might be thinking about things in the totally wrong way.
 
Chad-Hawk said:
Nathan_WINNING said:
At my graduation, the Lord's Prayer was said at the graduation (most of our class was atheist and disagreed, but the grad organizer was super religious) and grace was said at the supper. I think that shouldn't happen at any graduation. I'm there to graduate, not take part in a religion I think is bull. And I live in Canada, one of the most secular English-speaking countries, yet we still had God shoved down our throat at graduation.

The separation of church and state is pretty damn straightforward. The state cannot endorse any one religion more than another. It cannot promote or endorse religion. Religion is separate. To have Canadians (or ANYONE) pay taxes so that someone else can tell them that unproven myths created thousands of years ago are true is absurd.

If you want your kids to be religious then take them to church. It doesn't belong in school.

Science is based on logical reasoning.

Religion is based on non-logical reasoning. It based on feelings and assumptions.

People didn't create Gods because they ran experiments, made hypotheses, and came to the conclusion, they created them to try to give purpose to life and to give answers to those who asked where all people came from.
If you don't believe in it then why do you give a crap? Like why are you complaining it has no effect on you. If someone who is organizing it feels he needs to do that than let him. It doesn't negatively affect you in any way.

It negatively affects me because it makes me feel like an outcast, as well as others like me, and other religious people who are not Christian. It is paid for by the government, a SECULAR organization, which is funded by many people who are not Christian.
 
Anyone who wants school to teach children to be religious is trying to push their own beliefs and agenda onto others. That's not okay.
 
Sansea said:
Moose said:
Willy, I think I see your hang up. You're objecting to the part if the pledge that says "one nation, UNDER GOD" and are equating that to teaching religion in public schools, correct?

I have several points on this

1. Making a bunch of Americans pledge to a flag every week seems very silly to me.

2. The "under God" part of the pledge (which was added in the 1950s under the McCarthy era) is sooooooo vague as to be meaningless.
For Christians, God is Jesus, for Muslims, it's Allah, for atheists it could be money. Since the "God" in the pledge is undefined, it's really harmless.

That being said, religion should NOT be taught in public schools

It was added in the 50s to show the Russians we are not a godless nation.

And the majority of everyone in office being Christian and most the population being Christian it's quite easy to see who it's for.
according to the constitution it isnt allowed to be there.
 
lIlIxX-IW_Rio_IW-XxlIlI said:
If I moved to America would my children have to say the pledge of allegiance? After all, they're british, not American.

If you MOVE to America, then we Americans would anticipate you becoming a British AMERICAN, with all the same freedoms afforded to you as any natural born American. Would you still have the freedom to practice your own culture? Yes. But would America expect loyalty from you and your family toward this country? Absolutely.

The point of this thread though, is "should religion be PRACTICED in (public) schools".
 
It is generally understood that "under god" was added to the pledge in the 1950's, and was not a part of the pledge as originally conceived and written.

For the record, I am against any sort of pledge or recitation of that sort in schools, as it is pure indoctrination without any sort of understanding, much like what is done to children in other parts of the world, such as in totalitarian regimes that Americans generally disagree with. However, I would consider a compromise, such as the removal of the religious "under god" addition (for grammatical purposes as well).

So, for those of you who defend having school children recite the pledge, would you agree to at least remove the "under god" addition?
 
Tbh, it's all a bit silly, enforcing people to pledge something that they literally do not understand (loyalty to country) at a young age is ridiculous, you could then say any of them that break a law after that is committing treason, as they have pledged their loyalty to country (including all it's laws)
 
KingCalm said:
It is generally understood that "under god" was added to the pledge in the 1950's, and was not a part of the pledge as originally conceived and written.

For the record, I am against any sort of pledge or recitation of that sort in schools, as it is pure indoctrination without any sort of understanding, much like what is done to children in other parts of the world that Americans generally disagree with. However, I would consider a compromise, such as the removal of the religious "under god" addition (for grammatical purposes as well).

So, for those of you who defend having school children recite the pledge, would you agree to at least remove the "under god" addition?
It is because nobody finds it important to teach our children the value of country anymore, that nobody cares about the country anymore.
Kids aren't being raised to love America, they are being raised to have no attachment to it whatsoever. It makes it easier when somebody decides they want to step in and take over three generations from now, because nobody will want to stand up for their rights or country.
You're grooming the children to be completely alright with no loyalty at all.
 
lIlIxX-IW_Rio_IW-XxlIlI said:
Tbh, it's all a bit silly, enforcing people to pledge something that they literally do not understand (loyalty to country) at a young age is ridiculous, you could then say any of them that break a law after that is committing treason, as they have pledged their loyalty to country (including all it's laws)
We are the only country to do that since that country that had a leader that everyone hates in ww2.
 
Sansea said:
lIlIxX-IW_Rio_IW-XxlIlI said:
Tbh, it's all a bit silly, enforcing people to pledge something that they literally do not understand (loyalty to country) at a young age is ridiculous, you could then say any of them that break a law after that is committing treason, as they have pledged their loyalty to country (including all it's laws)
We are the only country to do that since that country that had a leader that everyone hates in ww2.
Brace yourselves, the Democrats and their Nazi Germany comparisons are coming.
 
XIVI_ZETHOR_IVIX said:
KingCalm said:
It is generally understood that "under god" was added to the pledge in the 1950's, and was not a part of the pledge as originally conceived and written.

For the record, I am against any sort of pledge or recitation of that sort in schools, as it is pure indoctrination without any sort of understanding, much like what is done to children in other parts of the world that Americans generally disagree with. However, I would consider a compromise, such as the removal of the religious "under god" addition (for grammatical purposes as well).

So, for those of you who defend having school children recite the pledge, would you agree to at least remove the "under god" addition?
It is because nobody finds it important to teach our children the value of country anymore, that nobody cares about the country anymore.
Kids aren't being raised to love America, they are being raised to have no attachment to it whatsoever. It makes it easier when somebody decides they want to step in and take over three generations from now, because nobody will want to stand up for their rights or country.
You're grooming the children to be completely alright with no loyalty at all.

Real values such as love of country cannot be mandated and programed. What of those other values we have, such as freedom of speech and expression, or even the freedom to learn to love America for what it does offer rather than becoming a brainwashed reactionary. If America is worth being revered, there is no need for the pledge.

Also, I think demanding the government not force us to recite and pledge, is standing up our rights as an American to freedom of speech and expression.

However, you nicely avoided the question: for those of you who defend having school children recite the pledge would you agree to at least remove the "under god" addition?
 
Firmly believe in powers of separation of church and state. We should teach about religion in school but not practice our religion in school.
 
lIlIxX-IW_Rio_IW-XxlIlI said:
Were off topic really guys. Start a new thread to talk about this before mods shut this one :)

We can discuss the aspect of patriotism as it applies to the "Pledge of Allegiance" which is the basis of the OP.

Moose, "Under God" is vague. It could apply to any God. The fact that it is still in that pledge, when my 10 year old can now ask me what that means, I can only tell him that some people believe that there is a Devine being that is always watching them and they live their lives to serve him.


He says "That's silly, Dad."


Yes. I'm raising a Godless hellian. Funny thing is my wife graduated from a Christian School.


I was an acolyte in a church up until I was excommunicated for bringing in a Ouiji board to overnight church group. I was 16.


The only person excommunicated in my town since the late 1800's.


LEGENDARY.
 
XIVI_ZETHOR_IVIX said:
KingCalm said:
It is generally understood that "under god" was added to the pledge in the 1950's, and was not a part of the pledge as originally conceived and written.

For the record, I am against any sort of pledge or recitation of that sort in schools, as it is pure indoctrination without any sort of understanding, much like what is done to children in other parts of the world that Americans generally disagree with. However, I would consider a compromise, such as the removal of the religious "under god" addition (for grammatical purposes as well).

So, for those of you who defend having school children recite the pledge, would you agree to at least remove the "under god" addition?
It is because nobody finds it important to teach our children the value of country anymore, that nobody cares about the country anymore.
Kids aren't being raised to love America, they are being raised to have no attachment to it whatsoever. It makes it easier when somebody decides they want to step in and take over three generations from now, because nobody will want to stand up for their rights or country.
You're grooming the children to be completely alright with no loyalty at all.

Are not raised to love America? The pledge is basicly brainwashing but ok

If you want them to love something let them have a actual reason to love it.

People are more likely to stand up for the country if they can form a reason other then idk why I love America.

Also if you have to be raised to love something you don't really love it.

But king calm put it better.
 
The nation was founded by people of religious beliefs. It's the baseline of our nation's birth. It shouldn't be changed because people of different creeds and beliefs won't accept it.

I'm 3rd generation in America. My great grandparents came here in 1910. When my grandmother was born here and started school my great grandparents said now that we are in America we will speak English. They assimilated because they were proud to be here and wanted to live the American Dream as Americans.
 
Back
Top