Regarding the Misinformation about how Forums Work

Why would anyone listen to anything the devs say? They have about as much credibility as that Iraqi minister of information during the war.
 
Rikkimaru said:
The devs don't control it, they've stated it several times, they outsource the forums.

Doesn't it make perfect sense that they hire some forum coding people to make the alterations? It seems to me that yes the forums are operated by ATA and they have some knowledge of how to use the admin functions but when there are overhauls or changes then they hire forum/web savvy people to make those changes for them...

Not disagreeing with op or any information, but that doesn't mean that ATA are "in charge" of changes if you get what I mean?
 
kaw_community said:
Just to clarify, the forum software is indeed made by a separate company but we're the ones who run them. Pretty much every single forum out there follows this system.

Some things are easier to do (changing themes, adding post counts, etc), and some things would be pretty close to impossible (making a way to alert you in game if someone quotes you) as the forums don't have any sort of features to support that kind of thing.

This Was The Response By Devs On My Thread "Forum Notifications"
Just To Make Things Clearer :)
 
Moody said:
Rikkimaru said:
The devs don't control it, they've stated it several times, they outsource the forums.

Doesn't it make perfect sense that they hire some forum coding people to make the alterations? It seems to me that yes the forums are operated by ATA and they have some knowledge of how to use the admin functions but when there are overhauls or changes then they hire forum/web savvy people to make those changes for them...

Not disagreeing with op or any information, but that doesn't mean that ATA are "in charge" of changes if you get what I mean?

If devs can code an entire successful game, I'm pretty sure they can make some basic changes to the forum. Op showed us how easy it is. Why would devs need to get someone to do it?
 
Grimzy - purely because of time, i imagine the developers are harder at work with season 5 or any other tweaks than to (probably learn)/ change forum code. I agree that the op makes it look easy and is confident in their ability - but the devs may not have spent the time doing a computer science degree that includes forum coding etc

I don't know or have any definitive answer, I'm just speculating but it would make sense to me that they outsource their forum changes to other people so they have more time to sort the actual game :)
 
Phpbb could be edited by anyone, tech savvy or not. If you CANT edit a basic forum script in a minuscule way, you don't deserve to be qualified a developer of any kind.
 
Moody said:
Grimzy - purely because of time, i imagine the developers are harder at work with season 5 or any other tweaks than to (probably learn)/ change forum code. I agree that the op makes it look easy and is confident in their ability - but the devs may not have spent the time doing a computer science degree that includes forum coding etc

I don't know or have any definitive answer, I'm just speculating but it would make sense to me that they outsource their forum changes to other people so they have more time to sort the actual game :)
exactly this. Why do all the dirty work when you can just hire someone else to do all the annoying stuff for you? That's what I imagine ATA does.

You haven't proven ATA controls the forums, just that it's easy to do it yourself.
 
-Deadly- said:
Moody said:
I don't know or have any definitive answer, I'm just speculating but it would make sense to me that they outsource their forum changes to other people so they have more time to sort the actual game :)
exactly this. Why do all the dirty work when you can just hire someone else to do all the annoying stuff for you? That's what I imagine ATA does.

You haven't proven ATA controls the forums, just that it's easy to do it yourself.

Read Below Both Of U vvvvvvvvv
kaw_community said:
Just to clarify, the forum software is indeed made by a separate company but we're the ones who run them. Pretty much every single forum out there follows this system.

Some things are easier to do (changing themes, adding post counts, etc), and some things would be pretty close to impossible (making a way to alert you in game if someone quotes you) as the forums don't have any sort of features to support that kind of thing.

This Was The Response By Devs On My Thread "Forum Notifications"
Just To Make Things Clearer :)
 
tl;dr - Anyone that says that the devs aren't in control of the forums are wrong and I prove it in this thread.

1. You took 1 quote and framed it around your knowledge. What was meant by my post is this: devs own forums. Yes. It's theirs. They probably could change things on their own if they wanted/needed to. But they don't. They have other people do it. Why would it change for 1 update instead of all the others?

Lately I've seen some blatantly incorrect claims about how the forums work. I have a great deal of experience as a programmer and am one year away from getting a bachelors in computer science. It's kind of disturbing how wrong some of these claims are.

2. So instead of posting all this valuable info on the thread this had to do with you make your own? Seems personal.

Our KaW forums run on an open source forum script called phpBB. Since the script is open source, the source code, or code that makes up the forums is freely available and may be redistributed and modified by anyone. "Because phpBB is released under the GNU General Public License, you may make changes to the code without first having to obtain permission from the phpBB Group." (source: https://www.phpbb.com/about/ ) Feel free to read exactly what that licensing entails here.

Since phpBB is open source, anyone can download and run the forum script for free.




To further prove a point, I downloaded it.


3. Again. I never said it wasnt easy. I said that devs don't do it. Would you rather them work on the games or waste time on the forums when other people are willing to do it?


Now, I just need to unzip it and upload it to my server. Now, your average person doesn't have a computer dedicated for anything like this; but anyone can buy web space for cheap. Anyone can install and run this forum script.

Here it is, uploaded to my server.




Then I created an SQL database.

All that's left to do is open my web browser, navigate to the directory (on my server) where I uploaded the forum script, and complete a basic installation (filling in database details, making a default admin account for the forums, etc).




The final step is to delete the installation directory; and now I have my own installation of phpBB.



Anyone that's used the forums on the pc: it looks familiar doesn't it? The default style, prosilver is shown. Other styles can be installed too. phpBB has an active modding community and there are hundreds of free, downloadable, user-created styles on the website. Furthermore, anyone can edit a style downloaded to fit their liking.


I can also modify the code as I please!

Let's say I want my background to be pink instead of grey.

So on my server, I will navigate to Styles>prosilver>theme and edit the file colours.css




All colors are hexadecimal. This thread is already long, Google it for an explanation.



The colour is F5F7FA, which is a nice grey: █████
I'm going to change it to a nice pink, FF00FF. It looks like this: █████




And now, when I refresh the page:

4. I never meant "oh devs don't know what they are doing." I meant "oh devs have other people for this in another company that is not their own."


So what is the point to all of this?


Devs don't control KaW forums. They use other people to control their forum codes and updates and such.
The developers do have complete control over their forums. Not only that, I demonstrated that phpBB can be edited with ease. Updating is also a simple task that they can perform in probably under 5 minutes.

5. Yes. They COULD control the devs. But they chose to outsource, and continue choosing to outsource. As they said themselves later on that thread. Are you saying that they devs could have made it so that you're notified when you are quoted? My. I wonder how many notifications you would be getting right now.

It's not that they created forums and hired people to work them. THE FORUMS ARENT KAW DEVOLPED.

That's why we had to wait years for a forum update. They have to ASK the forum people to do something. And HOPE they get around to responding. AND THEN the have to work with them to try the ability to even do this. It's not "yo. Do this".

The forums were not written by KaW developers. KaW Developers installed phpBB just like I did and wrote some basic modifications to it. They didn't ask the "forum people" to do anything. The features this forum has aren't in the default installation of phpBB. The "forum people" didn't do anything to begin with! :lol: There are all sorts of mobile mods already available written by other people. The developers probably based the mobile version for the forums off of that.

The people that are in charge of phpBB don't really get paid to work on it. They might make some money off of advertisements and endorsements of various webhosts, but this is more of a side project for them.

6. They said themselves that they have other people to work on it. So. Yea.


It's not "yo. Do this".
Lastly, this line: If a client wants a feature, it gets implemented. That's the how software development works.

The only reason that we got the forum update was because someone on the AtA team was told to do it. Why it didn't happen sooner? Laziness probably.

Feel free to ask me questions.

Was it necessary to quote me that last line 2x? Or did what I say personally offend you?


But no worries! I have emailed the devs and have asked them to fully explain the process so I can explain it to people that think KaW devs do EVERYTHING by themselves and don't have other people for this crap.

Next time you quote me, a little heads up would be great. Especially since it seems it seems I struck a nerve to your precious programming soul.
 
@Lovely

Op was trying to show that devs DO have control over forums and that they COULD modify it. Previously people thought that the devs have no control over the forums and that it was all to the developers of phpBB.
 
GRIMZY said:
@Lovely

Op was trying to show that devs DO have control over forums and that they COULD modify it. Previously people thought that the devs have no control over the forums and that it was all to the developers of phpBB.

And wanted to use me as an example. His point could have been made without quoting me at all. Yet, he did.

Not only did he quote me. But he quoted me out of context.
 
@Breezy
Not quite sure how that equalised the scores. Although I'm not in favour of making a forum in what looks to be like a vendetta against someone, the OP was definitely the best blow struck.
 
ldeasAreBuIIetproof said:
@Breezy
Not quite sure how that equalised the scores. Although I'm not in favour of making a forum in what looks to be like a vendetta against someone, the OP was definitely the best blow struck.

Agreed
 
The guy didnt post your thread because this would be one long ass comment genius, he clearly said this isn't personal, your qoutes were probably the most recent and he could use them to address the situation, instead of bashing him, why not just say thank you for clearing up some confusion on the difficulty of running a forum software and the high likely hood that the devs do indeed run their own forums. Ty OP for your efforts in this thread.
 
Back
Top