I am currently using a lifeproof. It works well under water, protects from drops well, and fits nicely in my pocket but:
I had to replace the first one they sent me because the door to the charging port is just plastic and it cracked. This replacement case also just cracked the same way same door. So I'm going to have to call them again for a second replacement. From what I hear this is quite common. Problem is, once this door cracks, it is no longer waterproof.