I think this idea was proposed back between Season 1 and Season 2 (when the flaws in the matchmaking mechanic were really becoming apparent). The analogy used at that time was that the wars bould be more like a game of chess--each side has exactly the same pieces and it comes down to skill, strategy and teamwork for the win--not who has the most BFA or LB/SHs on roster, etc.
As I recall, the biggest complant AGAINST this type of matchup was from the more experienced/larger players who were complaining that they would not be able to use "their own build" in war. The argument went that they had chosen their build, and that type of build was the one they wanted to use. Some of the larger lb players chimed in and said they did not want to lose all of their hard work only to become the equivalent of a pawn in a war.
An alternative was proposed that would have the devs set the type of builds for each (i.e. a certain number of large attack builds, a certain number of hybrids, certain number of hansels, etc.). The war leader from each clan could then assign the members of his team to the various builds. (i.e. Player X would be assigned by the war leader to be the Hansel, player Y would be assigned to be the attack build, etc.). The devs could even mix up the types of builds for each war (spy heavy, attack heavy, towered tanks, high bfe, low bfe, every combination you could think of) -- and might even have an event where they would NOT announce before the war what type of builds would be involved (you only find out after matchup).
I thought those ideas had real merit and should have been explored, but the negative voices (which seem to be the majority of forum posters, sadly) drown out the idea pretty quickly and it never got any traction.
Personally, I like the idea of two perfectly matched teams. Strategy would become paramount, rather than roster stacking, stripping equipment to get a less experienced clan, etc.
Maybe the devs will listen this time around. Kudos, ER for renewing a great idea.
Cheers,
Kage.