IMO, KaW is a social app first and a game second. The social aspect is what has kept the game alive. A number of things has effected this aspect.
Let's start with HTE. It was nice when it was limited time but now that it's been around for quite some time it has really damaged the game. Clan loyalty has gone out the window. So many people flock to and sit in HTE clans. It's much more enticing to earn gold than ever before. As such the social aspect has suffered. CC just isn't alive as it used to be. Everyone wants HTE.
The introduction of HTE eventually lead to more lands and events. This further pushed people to only be concerned about their own kingdom rather than working together. Anyone who could hit B2B HTE, does. Anyone who can't, leaves their clan to hunt for ASoF/LOTL or a faster event rotation. It's no longer about finding a great clan and having home. It's no longer about finding great people and having fun. It's simply: I want gold and I want it now. (This obviously isn't the case for everyone. But I find it's common among the new generation of players.) KaW is putting pressure to grow more than ever before and with every event, they push for stand alone players rather than clans working together.
Now censorship is at an all time high. From one point of view, I can understand. War, forum and general in game banter is no longer just some fun jabs at each other. It has become really personal. Threats on your family, on your life. Rude comments about appearance, about nationality, about religion. I've seen some players really cross the line with comments. So I can understand why ToU is being more harshly enforced more than ever before. However, we must also consider another situation. One where devs keep their mouths shut and tape anyone else's shut who so much as mention a certain situation. We have threads and comments disappearing with out a word. No one knows what they've said that is so wrong but apparently warrants a delete of their post. Devs don't respond and instead choose to bury their head in the sand and hope it will go away. Now I'm told devs are working on sorting in game problems out. Good for them! But there's no way players can know that unless they tell us. Devs are under no obligation to explain to us what's going on. It is their game after all. But when it is having such an effect on the game? Damn right they ought to start talking. Keeping quiet only makes them look bad. Can you blame players for being quieter? All this censorship (not talking about comments like threats) and the deleting of posts makes for a negative environment. Players are probably unsure and not interested in participating anymore, hence activity in forums has gone down.
Just my two cents worth :grin: