The larger roster / weaker roster still has far more actions this just evens the odds a bit And all those saying let us recruit for 30 minutes if u could have got more members to war u would have already
I vote no. Most can not afford xtals and most clans can not get the roster up to 40 to even have a chance to do the estocs. It's difficult to plan and get everyone's schedule perfect. Estocs are a lot of fun! Give more the opportunity to do it and and benefit by keeping it at 30! Putting it at 40 limits participation folks can give. Making this game harder to play and trying keep up with your changes every other week is a mistake.
You know... Devs trying to fix game and earn money is great, but, I would like to suggest Metal Storm's idea. Make something that you can buy with gold that will act as an xtal but ONLY for estoc wars, costing a decently high price of gold depending on size, lets say 3bil each and they can be sold like Mithril was sold a while back once in a while, a limit per day. You will also have to make sure the people can buy a little more of these 'ee xtals' than there will be wars. (I.e. 1 weekend of warring = 5, 5*2 per war = 10). This way everyone of every age can have a change to war weekly without cost. Not everything has to pay you guys more money, I mean seriously people may spend xtals weekly to save up enough to buy these.
For the extra xstal idea - no support! Ok, so lets take total number of unloads alone just for xstal use. The 60 clan can use 2 xtals giving them 120 unloads from xtals alone, the 40 clan can use 4 xtals giving them 160 unloads from xtals. That's a difference of 40 unloads giving the 40 clan the advantage. Before, everyone can use 2 xtals. So the 60 clan would have 120 unloads from xtals and the 40 clan would have 80 unloads. This is a difference of 40 unloads, but this time its in favour of the 60 clan. This is not a solution, you are simply swinging the advantage to team with fewer members and putting the more populated clan in same position as the smaller clan is in now! Did you guys not spot that when you were doing your sums? I mean its not complicated, its common sense. Fiddle your sums about so each team has an equal number of unloads and the idea will work. Hell I'll even give you some help - give the team with 40 members 1 extra crystal. :-D or hire someone that can add up simple numbers :-D
I vote no because it means we wont be getting enough mith anymore to buy the equip that costs 200+ mith.
I vote NO for all of the above. If your going to allow extra xtal usage because a clan is outnumbered then allow us to kick inactives at halfway please. Also in your small percentage that was over, did u count the clans that had to make people leave to be able to war, or only the clans that didnt war because they were over? I do agree with the system wars not paying mith as i enjoying the ee wars, and new equipment. I truley wish you would allow larger clans to war, especially implenting your xtal rule to creat a fairer matchup, personally i think it should be 1/2 or 2/3 then your equation but I get that your doing your best. Id really like to be able to war with more than 60 for the fr-sun wars
@ rigamortis u are a fail at math 60 players get a total of 5 bars in a 4 hour war plus 2 crystals Clan a 60 members would get a total of 420 bars 40 member clan would get their 5 bars plus 4 more for crystals Clan b 40 members would get 360 bars That still favors the large roster by 60 bars instead of an overwhelming 140 bars