Devs if you knew anything about your game you'd know nobody uses your, how do I put this lightly, crappy war systems, to settle a grudge. Years ago when you managed to rid this game of pwars (thank god btw), you had an easy opportunity to either take the idea of mithril very far and do great things with it, take the mith idea and do nothing with it, or simply tweak a slight little thing to make the system wars profitable but only to the side that is actually winning. That would have been make it so only the losing side can forfeit.
Now, you have a much bigger opportunity than anything you've had before. Let's face it, now nobody is going to do system wars very much at all since there is not much real benefit. All a system war would do for a grudge is limit how much they can beat the crap out of the other clan. Everyone can, and probably will, settle grudge outside of system wars. So that means the only way to make a system war work well is a high incentive. But at a high incentive, since its war, you need a high risk. So perhaps you could do some sort of payout again for the winner, remove forfeit from the winner (anti-abusable stuff), and take something from the loser. And I don't just mean the losses of fighting.
That's just a rough idea, but it would essentially combine everything you're looking for. You want to reward people in a war environment. Put a high risk high reward set up to wars. You want people to fight over grudges. Let the winner take something from the loser (money, mith, you name it). And you don't want more pwars, mwars, or anything along those lines. Only let the true winners win, no forfeit for the leading team.
Man this went way longer than I thought it would.