Filthy_Maggot said:
For those that do not know, FC is Future Combat: Patriots At War. It was a futuristic doppelgänger of KaW without Epic Battles or Events.
It was purely PvP with two set of lands that could only be ganged by reaching both game monetary goals and action goals. This meant you had to actually reach a minimum number of attacks to upgrade, you couldn't just buy your way to the top.
In the beginning it was wild and when kaw started Epic Battles, FC as well as GaW stayed truer to PvP. Though they were neglected by the developers.
FC and GaW were only on apple, neither being allowed on Android. The developers never updated them to include any events (like war events. -trust me if they would put an eb on fc, fc would flip out)
So eventually, a game that hasn't seen an update in a couple of years with no advertising drawls little attention. Especially in a time when games like Clash of Clans and Angry Birds are dominating the app stores.
With that, forums slowed and eventually it lead to post staying in active topics for months. The collective and creative minds in the community more or less gave up creating new player ran events as less and less turned up for them. Though they still existed from time to time.
World chat, that place went by slow and had become more for chat with ads being a non-factor. And the biggest killer off all was mercs, (allies)
Then, the devs shut GaW and FC down forever, ignoring FC and possibly GaW players pleas to let them buy the game from the devs.
I never played FC, but from what I've heard it was similar to KaW before ebs were introduced. It was a PvP. And judging by your description of the game, it would never have been sustainable. Why do you think ebs were introduced into the game? The revenue from people PvPing and doing pwars wouldn't have been sustainable. But introduce ebs and people would likely have been xtaling more and buying more nobs. Then came HTE and events and so it goes on. Devs need to make a profit. If KaW had stuck solely to PvP, I doubt it'd have still been around now. I honestly don't believe it would have been profitable enough to continue. Certainly not as profitable as ebs and events. The introduction of 2 sets of lands and ebs killed off PvP. Growing suddenly became a lot more enticing with an easier way to get gold. The more they get involved in ebs, the less and less they worried about PvP and so did many players.
Filthy_Maggot said:
Translated to Kaw: all of these issues took time time to degrade and it is starting to show. Forums In AT sink much slower. Adds in WC are becoming less and less as random chatter takes it's place.
The ally market is horrific. It is so bad the the devs stopped resets. It helped keep the market around but it allowed it to remain over priced.
That and the amount of gray(new) players are dwindling. -Maybe that is why forums are gray, so the illusion of new players are given so to make the money devs feel content.
New players are becoming hard to retain. But I believe KaW is currently geared towards retaining their active player base first and finding new players second. I'm not saying we don't need new players, of course we do. But that's only my observation of the game at the moment. There are still new players coming through.
Filthy_Maggot said:
Then over half of the moderators are inactive. (Look at Moose and Wulf. They are never on enough to do their rolls. They are just the popular ones.)
To be an inactive moderator you need to be a moderator a first...and neither Wulf or Moose are moderators anymore :roll:
Filthy_Maggot said:
The difference is the devs are still updating the game still. Though the events are the same crap and every change is geared to make the game more expensive. The pay to play events, the costly clan rolls to replace admins. The only free change is the forum layout and it's so ugly I would pay money to have an option to have the old layout back.
That's a big difference. The fact that they're STILL updating the game shows they still have interest in KaW.
There's an important distinction people need to make. There are three options in KaW. Spend nothing, spend a fortune or spend a little here and there. The events are only to pay to play if you are seeking the best rewards. The best stuff ain't gunna come free. You want the best? You have to pay for it. If you don't want to pay, then you can still get decent rewards. That's the way most things tend to run. You want the best car? Costs money. You want the biggest mansion? Costs money. You are not forced to spend money in KaW. But you have to spend if you want the best. I agree some updates are probably aimed at wanting us to spend money (HTE, ZTA, Battle Cry) but you can still participate and grow without spending.
As for the clan roles, players were asking for a better clan structure for a long time. Players also asked for a gold sink. The devs found a way to combine them both. We have to remember that devs will never implement things EXACTLY as the players ask for them. They can't please us all.
Filthy_Maggot said:
What are your thoughts. How damned is this game? How long until it reaches FC's fate? Will any of you really miss it? If so, other than the players and friends, what is to miss?
In short, I think players need to stop crying wolf. The game is not dead or dying just yet. IMO, it's simply gone in a different direction to what players expected. This game is now about ebs and events first (it keeps the game running and is the easiest way to grow) and PvP second. I think there should be a lot more incentive to PvP. But I think it's fairly clear that now devs are more interested in ebs, events and having us grow.