Just a question on thought process

Imo, there is no difference. Death is death. The problem with this area is both sides are on two different sides of Abrahamic religion. The history there dates back centuries, and the militants today (on both sides) are channeling hatred and prejudice passed to them from their ancestors.

I don't condone either side's violence, because the real casualties are the non combatants, their children, hospital facilities, and the cultural history of both peoples that is being destroyed by needless bombs.
 
Black-Dragon said:
Eighty-six percent of those killed in Gaza were civilians. Yeah, I know the Israelis said they tried to avoid civilian casualties, but the fact is, they killed a bunch of them. You can't shell and bomb neighborhoods and not kill civilians.
Fair point. And true. However, the terrorists purposely surround them selves with civilians,musing them as human shields so that they can feign outrage when those civilians die.
Black-Dragon said:
And it's not the first time. In Lebanon back in 2006, the Israelis fired around 1,800 MLRS cluster bombs, containing over 1.2 million cluster bomblets. They scattered that **** everywhere. Whole towns were covered. 40% of the bombets don't explode. They stay on the ground basically becoming land mines.
I have no response to this, so, this point stands with out my challenge
Black-Dragon said:
While we're on the subject of double standards, why is it that Israel is ready to bomb Iran to stop them from developing a nuclear weapon, when it's widely known that Israel itself has a nuclear weapons program and already has about 80 or so nuclear weapons? Don't you think that's a tad bit hypocritical?
My answer is no. And the reason is because nit every nation should be allowed to have nukes. Is Israel as clean as the wind driven snow? No way. But, I personally view Iran as a bad actor and an enemy state. Of course I don't want them to have nukes. They will probably use them. Is it fair that Israel has nukes? No. Its not fair, but neither is life.
Black-Dragon said:
You may not like Iran, but they're a sovereign country just like Israel. So what gives Israel the right and moral high ground to say we can have these weapons, but Iran can't? Iran is a "terrorist nation" and Israel isn't? That's a matter of perspective. If your neighborhood got cluster bombed you might think differently. Anyway, if I were an Iranian, I might be pissed about the double standard.
Its a matter of perspective, true, but the real question is this..... Will Iran having nukes threaten America. That's the real issue, and the answer is yes, and, since Israel is an American ally, they get the nukes and Iran doesn't. That's kind of what happens when you don't stand with team USA, and that the commentary if a Canadian! Lol.
Black-Dragon said:
Don't get me wrong. I don't think Hamas are the good guys. But I don't think the Israelis are as pure and innocent as they want everyone to think either.
I think I read you correctly. Your not pro nuke for Iran. You do, however, take umbrage with Israel having nukes. The issue to me, is complex.
Personally, I think the Brits screwed up after WWII when they created the state of Israel. They pretty much ensured there would be a forever war there when they did that, and now, America and its allies simply need to try and deal with the mess as best as they can, but there are no good answers
 
FYI moose, the Brits gave the decision of what to do with that area to the UN I believe. It was the UN that failed to act on it's own suggestions and plans (britain included)

However, by suddenly and completely withdrawing from the area without a stabilising influence taking over, we did effectively start an endless war.
 
I don't think the UN leaving caused the endless war. The endless war has been there for ages. The problem was, after WW2, some wise UN saints decided that splitting Israel between two religious enemies was a good idea.
 
Moose said:
I think I read you correctly. Your not pro nuke for Iran. You do, however, take umbrage with Israel having nukes. The issue to me, is complex. Personally, I think the Brits screwed up after WWII when they created the state of Israel. They pretty much ensured there would be a forever war there when they did that, and now, America and its allies simply need to try and deal with the mess as best as they can, but there are no good answers

I'm not pro nuke for Iran or Israel.

I'm simply saying there are two sides to the story and if we expect to solve the problem we need to consider their perspective. Everyone is up in arms over the Iranian nuclear program, but no one says a word about the Israeli one. Netanyahu constantly calls for war against Iran for basically trying to do what his country has already done. And nobody ever points this fact out. If I were Iran, I'd be a bit pissed.

And yeah, it's a complex problem. It doesn't help when we only consider one side, nor when people get blasted for speaking the truth that the Israelis aren't entirely innocent here. Me, I'm not pro Israel or pro Palestinian. I'm pro peace. And that's going to require concessions from both sides.
 
Back
Top