NO support to individual wars. Why?
1. It discourages cooperation, strategy, team work or anything that makes the game more interesting intellectually. You could be assigned to a team where nobody has wc/tracking experience or there are a bunch of noobs who know nothing about the wars. When you war with such a team, anything intellectual is a luxury. Keep in mind that if what you are doing is to drive the smart people away, this game is already one foot in the grave.
2. It destroys clan unity (isn't it what devs claimed to promote in the beginning of EE wars?), forces clan mates to fight each other and discourages serious warriors who are usually your spenders to spend more on the game just to rely on their luck or prayer's list to win the wars.
Don't be fooled by the increasing amount of participation if that's what you think the positive feedback from the individual wars. Most of the xtals used in those wars came from quests or events. In other words, they are free. Most of the people don't spend to join noob wars. Free loaders couldn't get accepted into any serious war clans but now they are free to participate. What good news! Their victims could be those serious warriors who just love to war or have no choice but to join to extend their ee. They have to spend much more time and efforts because of those free loaders. How is that fair?
3. It denies all the hard work including time and rl money serious warriors have spent on the game to improve the war experience. They built up towers at the sacrifice of the plunder, xtaled every day to grow the strength and went through the tear-down-and-rebuild process just to make their builds more competitive in wars. Now those eb builds can easily achieve the same without any efforts on the build change or growth. If they are lucky to be assigned in a good team, they don't even need to xtal to win the wars. Does it make sense?
For all the reasons stated above, we do NOT support individual wars.
On the other hand, however, we understand that eb players also want to have some fun in wars although they are not willing to put in much effort. A feasible solution could be to have both clan wars and individual wars at the same time. When a clan signs up for the war, it will enroll in clan wars as usual. If a player wants to participate in individual wars, all he/she has to do is to cast WOC and leave the clan. Then he/she will be assigned to a random clan for the individual wars. It should not be difficult to implement. Both ee warriors and eb players can enjoy the fun of wars that way.
The most important is not to force those who don't want individual wars to join individual wars. Give them a choice at least!
Meanwhile, please continue to work on your matchup algorithm. Individual war is NOT a fix other than it provides a bigger pool. You have put gh/sh or even statless accts together with big lbs in individual wars as a roster. Are you "exploiting" your system with the rosters you made?
If you really can't figure out a way to fix the current matchup system, maybe a quick and dirty solution is to set a fixed roster structure and limit the max difference in strength between clans. We'll be happy to make changes to fit into your structure.
Thanks for your attention, devs. We're looking forward to seeing the improvements to make the game more fun to play.
--DRAGONS SANCTUARY