guild vs stronghold

Discussion in 'Strategy' started by M120, May 25, 2011.

  1. Or 1st 10mins of war, you spam keyboard and unload 10-15 xtals. Then leave clan regen outside.
    Come back in and unload, crystal and unload, crystal and unload,then leave clan
    Regen outside
    Come into clan and crystal and unload until you have used up 10-15 crystals 1st 10-minutes 24 crystals for 1st 24 hours,
    Then you stay within clan and continue to unload every 10-mins x2, until 24-hours up
    You unload 3 crystals, leave clan regen, come back in and unload and crystal until you've used up your 24 crystals in 24-hour. Then continue to unload x2, every 10-mins

    Guess how much gold you generated?
     
  2. Male. I make 38 mil roughly off HCBC spy and not hc yet
     
  3. Wrong Acct. Lol. My 489/489 hansel makes that
     
  4. @MaleStone...

    You mean twice every 5 minutes not 10 minutes right?
     
  5. @Malestone: wouldnt leaving clan will erase your war plunder? Because I look at Blackhawks clan and their pwar stat, I just cant see how an hansel like _xo_ can get 53bil without someway to manipulate the xtal rule.

    I am always confused by that clan pwar lol
     
  6. War plunder goes a way but war tax stays

    War plunder is used to determine which clan wins the war. The portion contributed leaves with the person.

    War tax is the prize the winning clan receives. This stays no mater if a person is booted or is dropped from the clan. Hence why there are so many hit and run pwars.
     
  7. The most war tax earned that I heard was 400B in one pwar. They had to cycle people through that clan day and night for 48 hours. A hit and run would make that a realistic amount.
     
  8. Thats what I said. If the result listed him earn 53bil in plunder, then he must have stayed in clan the whole time. I remember seeing his stat was 600k/600k spy hansel, how could he earn that much without leaving clan for xtal?
     
  9. Being in top 1000 ally lb effects plunder? Hmm never heard of lb effecting game play before? U pulling our legs mal?
    What do u say havoc? You've been around for a long time?
     
  10. Well as you move up on the lb you are getting stronger so indeed you will be making less plunder if the osf stayed the same without strong allies.
     
  11. It's true your ally bonuses bring your plunder down.
     
  12. Not pulling your leg @gold, it's true I've seen it on a ZAFT's iPhone screen.

    As he entered a more powerful clan his ally bonus dropped.

    When he joined a lower LB clan, his ally bonus came up

    As he hired more allies, his ally bonus decreased compared to when he had less allies

    @Havoc, you are correct to say 2x every 5-mins, but did you notice that, when the clock count down to zero and replenished troops/spies, it was not full. Do I'd say 3x every 10mins, would be better
     
  13. @whitey...
    Yes you make more money against a HLBC spy, and you've guilds and you are not HC yet. Nice.... 38m

    But it's a war game, so need to upgrade to SoS, so conclusion

    Guilds make more money in Pwar, not in RealWar and out of Pwar
    SoS makes less money in Pwar, but makes up during rest period if he continues stealing.
     
  14. Sigh lets keep it simple...

    Guilds are better for plunder in every situation when compared to sos.
    Separate a guild's allied plunder from attack builds troop plunder since its 2 different situations.


    People who have 5-6 or 7-8 sos use the comb spy stats for protection, if they were to replace with guilds they would make about 2m more a hit, plus a little more with steals.

    For people with attack builds, thinking 1 guild will make a difference it won't, to see the big difference you need 5-6 guilds, you gain 1 -2 m per hit plus gain decent steals. :mrgreen:
     
  15. This is ridiculous. I have one war aviary LVL 3, 20 SOS LVL 1, 2 SOS LVL 2, 9 guilds.

    What do you hansel scholars think I hit for?
     
  16. Please tell us T5. I'm curious lol
     
  17. 20 to 25 mil is my guess on max osf
     
  18. Know what..I'm getting pretty sick of this Hansel is better for plunder stuff.

    For your information Hansel earns less cash than attack builds. Yes ally bonus is higher with Hansel but what everyone does not take into account is build plunder. Build plunder with ally bonus is much higher with attack builds than what ally bonus from hansel can earn alone.

    Now has anyone experimented for themselves how plunder systems work? Anyone experiment with different builds? I have and hansel build is crap plain and simple. You think Hansel is best because you heard that from someone that heard that from someone and so on and so forth.

    Now for a moment think...

    SOS hansel is not good for plunder until you add attack buildings. Well here's a shocker...It's the Attack buildings and not the SOS providing plunder.

    Lastly for any troll and grammar Nazi that needs to point out any mistakes. Go **** yourself.
     
  19. I agree with your last part grammar nazi need to take the sticks out there butts
     
  20. 28.1 mil on a 2.56/2.56 and a lil more on up.

    I have been doing extensive research using the builds thread that shows plunder bonuses for buildings. I key note I will make is in the early going you can hit almost any osf as a guilded hansel and make 25 mil as a lowlands land conquerer.

    You pick up a measly 21 grand extra converting to a SOS. However the size osf you must hit will go up little by little.

    In conclusion, SOS DO INCREASE PLUNDER. so slightly......it may not benefit someone who isn't going to be all spy in the long run.