The moderator program was a flawed idea to begin with.
ATA learnt this the hard way, that's why their last two games slowly phased out voluntary moderation from random players.
SMASH? ATA made the mods anonymous.
Heckfire? ATA was clear from the get go that there wouldn't be any moderators.
Why? Because the concept of voluntary moderation from the player base is flawed. Over the years we've seen multiple mods exhibit bias towards their clans and members, sell accounts, run scripts and more. Mods that cant get rid of their bias towards their clan and their allegiance to it's members.
I don't blame them. It's not easy, which is why moderation from the player base is never a good idea. Its hard to separate your allegiance to your clan (if any) and your voluntary duty as a mod.
It's hard to be involved in a game and still moderate it's players while being one of them.
We've had many mod scandals on KaW over the last few years. We've seen mods get caught red handed for aiding and abetting cheating on KaW, mods that used their "position" to selectively silence members on the other side of a OSW whilst ignoring their own. Mods that leaked dev-mod communication to their friends, mods that were know for running bot stores.
Faulty silences, trigger happy mods, threads that have been locked without much reason. Threads that have been graveyard'd at the slightest when a troll shows up and derails the thread.
Like it or not, the mod program has done far more bad than good on this game. It's particularly responsible for its decline. You think players want to fight an OSW, where a mod on the other side can influence bans and more? Yeah, no.
ATA wised up and made it clear on their new game, no more mods ever. They arrived at the same conclusion too.
