Estoc Trials - Open Beta - Feedback

Discussion in 'Past Events' started by admin, Nov 3, 2012.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. It was fun. Great experience.
    The updates are good. Like *you'll know those opponents knockd themselves out, it'll make the fight more exciting. You'll know if whos active and not.
    Some may disagree. But for me it was good.

    Some of my mates says . Why did they limit the use ofcrystals. Its a game of crysrals. Haha. Thats what i thought at 1st. But i realizes. If it is a game about crystals. Low clan/players will definity be K.Od .
    Well. Again. Good jod devs. Thats for now.
    More powers to you and God bless.
     
  2. As a spy I don't particularly like alerting the opposing clan that I just KO'ed one of their members. That is one of the benefits of a spy, being undetected, which is completely foiled by the update. I am then instantly scouted because "update" told them I was active. I don't believe it is necessary to report who KO'ed an individual, just say they were KO'ed or self KO'ed

    Also... This is supposed to promote clan unity but the auto-join makes people leave the clan that might be sleeping during one of the wars. In turn, they also lose some/any estoc edge they might have had. I understand the auto join helps ensure better match ups but definitely effects who is able to remain in clan and who needs to step out.

    Overall, I do like the new war system and how active it is, well done devs!
     
  3. The ESTOC EDGE we recieve is a spell so u shd give us a 1 hr. time to its auto activation so that we can join the clan we want to be in.
    Fixing this feature will be really appreciated
    We dnt want to be stuck in a clan we dnt know.
     
  4. Drops. What drops. Haven't had one since winning war
    Bronze bars is a way to reduce plunder not increase it. Treasure used to pay more and when you sell bronze bars you lose gold. It's a rip off and we get less for our effort than before.
    Being smaller in bigger war clan I earn less a day than I did before ( % percentage of plunder per eb)
    Pots used in war should be replaced with bronze bar drop at the end of war. ( accounting for sale price)
    Wars harm growth not enhance the game or reward players.
    Forced to stay out of home clan is annoying. HGL are great!! but friends in home clan are missed.
    Estocs is a worthless anti bonus from what I have seen.
    15 minute ko and cc announcement rather than clan having to actually report bleurgh  more xtals no I don't want to have to pay more real money just to war and why should wins go to clans with players paying to win? Play not pay wars
     
  5. Ah so much feedback to know what to do with! Well ill add a bit more, new war system with a few tweaks brings a whole new spin on kaw and it really is like having a new game. I'm sure this is what the devs are intending so thx for ur efforts devs.

    So to the tweaks:
    1. Announce attacking ko not defensive ko to both clans. Defensive ko is an achievement for the defending clan member so don't penalise them for it. Announcing to defending clan tho does help and should b kept
    2. Many clans do have designated war clans different from home clan so I'm all in favour for keeping EE during the subsequent move back home. Allow 1 clan move without EE penalty and subsequent move drops a level. This will still promote clan loyalty.
    3. Functional tweaks as stated in previous posts I'm sure will b addressed in due course. All part of the beta trial to address these which justifies the trial.

    Now what id like to know is when we can expect to be able to war with the new system proper? Are there going to be further trials before going live? If I've missed a thread that answers these questions then apologies but I am itching to get stuck in to more system war and I do prefer the new anti-turtle regime. 
     
  6. Don't you mean "attach a screenshot if possible" ?
     
  7. The amount of item drops are not increasing, I'm seeing the same amount, if not less than prior to these wars. Also, I'm seeing items dropping for players that don't have ANY level of Estoc's Edge! That's just ridiculous. If the edge is supposed to increase our chances by 42%, then something is definitely wrong and it needs to be fixed!
     
  8. I think that for a certain amount o mith maybe 15 u should e able to not become active at start of war so if u cant do war u dont have to leave the clan an u wont leak
     
  9. Re round 3 beta: More mith spell colors, #'s on war roster, KO stats, matchup tweaks. All good changes. BUT THE START TIMES ARE HORRIBLE.
     
  10. Pls take out the AUTO JOIN thing....so peeps who can't war don't need to go out of clan  Thanks
     
  11. Beat me to it Elektra lol.. Yep get rid of the auto-join!! 
     
  12. Estocs Edge should be a clan bonus that stays for a week and if you want it back you must war again the next week and win, it should not be given to individuals but to the actual clan.
     
  13. Any chance of a self ko countdown timer? I usually pay attention to cc too much and forget my own ko time. Pretty sure other people may have the same problem?
     
  14. If you really DO Want to promote clan unity you have to get the war start times right. All 3 start times in beta round 3 are bad for my clan (lots of Europeans). As a result almost 1/2 of my clan left to give those remaining a better chance at winning.
    Some ppl have suggested adding a mechanic to allow ppl to leave / come back / visit sub clan and not loose estocs. This is something I'd like to see. It would help reduce friction in my clan over things like war time, real life commitments etc. also, this is largely a social game, and visiting is as aspect of social activity that would benefit from a game mechanic such as this
     
  15. Not sure if it's been posted, but since the first time these wars were introduced till now. Everytime i get the last hit and it still says that they ko'ed themselves! And i know its the last hit because they lose less troops at the last hit and when i try again it says They are knocked out. This is very frustrating and a waste of troops. PLEASE FIX THIS.
     
  16. The new war roster with plunder totals is great. The only problem was I couldn't att or spy from it from android or pc. The pc did nothing and the droid just went back to the roster page. Get this fixed and it's a good addition!
     
  17. There is a glitch that when you ko an opponent it tells you they ko'd themselves and there is lag that doesn't tell you until you're ko'd already
     
  18. Overall I really like the update. I like the newest update where you can see actions and plunder but I don't like the war roster showing the players order by plunder instead of by strength. Also hope you get the glitch fixed up by next round where on android you cant get to player from roster. Also find it much slower to war on android than iPhone or pc. Wish we could use more crystals; ).
     
  19. it's great! But it would be helpfull if you could see wich enemy is KO and who isn't, an idea for that: color the KOed ones red and the rest green or do it however you think it's better because I didn't like to test every enemy to find someone who isn't KO...
     
  20. hey i particpated in war there yes the clan i was in for war lost last weekend but still havnt gotten a beta badge yet where is it

    also neva heard back from m last querry for war?
     
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.